To: Cautious_Optimist who wrote (57692 ) 7/2/2000 2:50:35 PM From: EightyEight Respond to of 122087 Is this relevant? Berko on Conseco: CONSECO Hold, or Bail? PUBLISHED: June 28, 2000 Dear Mr. Berko: What are your thoughts on Conseco? I bought 300 shares at $16 and it now trades at $6. Should I buy another 300 and average down? SN: Erie, PA Dear SN: Conseco (CN-$5.50) made a monumental goof in 1998 when its shares were trading in the mid $50s. Arrogant with success and believing they were among the privileged few to sit at the right hand of God, management paid $6 billion for the purchase of Green Tree Financial (GNT). CNC paid a hugely rich premium for GNT (a sub prime lender) and soon thereafter discovered that GNT’s balance sheet had many of the properties of Swiss cheese. Well, management got caught with their collective pants down and CNC’s stock began a deep, full-bodied decline. GNT hurt Conseco, decimated its balance sheet and so destroyed CNC’s credibility with the investment community that management’s only recourse was to blow it off the books. Consequently management is considering an offer of $750 million from Lehman which translates into a $5.25 billion loss. CNC used to be a classy health and life holding company, with its ownership of Colonial Penn, Washington National, Pioneer, Banker’s Life, National Fidelity, Jefferson National, Beneficial Standard, Great American, Lincoln American, American Travelers, Transport, Massachusetts General, United, Continental Wabash and others. And since 1992 revenues increased 6-fold while net income and the stock price exploded…that is until 1998 when GNT sold CNC’S management a pig in a brown paper bag (poke). CNC, which is the or 8th largest insurer in the U.S. has made an unholy mess of itself in the past 18 months. Its CEO, Stephen Hilbert was recently resigned with a $72 million severance package, exclusive use of the CNC corporate jet twice a month plus a few other amenities. However, it’s often said that the time to buy a stock is when no one wants to own it. CNC’s short interest of 44 million shares represents 18% (really high) of its float. The company’s book value (according to S&P) is about $3.25 a share, its portfolio of insurers is really top drawer and First Call Financial expects CNC to earn $2.00 a share this fiscal year. That’s good. So good in fact that several groups including financier Irwin Jacobs, Lehman Brothers and a consortium of European investors are considering bids for the company. CNC has some exquisitely beautiful assets and certainly the sum of its various individual insurers (the parts) is worth a lot more than the whole. There are eleven analysts on the Street who follow CNC. Two analysts rate CNC as a “strong buy,” two rate CNC as a “buy” and seven rate CNC as a “hold.” Because CNC has significant cash flow, because CNC has an impressive portfolio of insurers and lenders and because CNC has an established franchise, I also rate the stock as a “strong but speculative buy.” And I’d even go a step further. Buy the common shares but I’d also like you to consider its $2.29 preferred (CNCT-$11.00) which yields 21%. In my opinion, CNC’s cash flow can easily make the payments. And if there’s no buy-out, but rather an improved credit position, the value of the preferred will skyrocket and you’ll still earn a juicy and bankable 21% current return.