To: SpecialK who wrote (34255 ) 10/27/2000 3:23:19 PM From: Paul Shread Read Replies (1) | Respond to of 42787 SpecialK, Don & all, My own view of value is when a stock is trading at historically low levels for that stock, based on its current growth rate. That makes GM a buy at 59 at a PE of 6 and MSFT a buy at 58 1/2 at a PE of 32. And that makes sense: GM is a highly cyclical company, while MSFT is like a drug company -- it costs a lot to develop the first product but pennies to produce subsequent ones, and it is not tied to the PC cycle as long as its new product pipeline is promising. I use a service at trouncingthedow.com , which costs $200 a year and with which I have no affiliation. It also works for tech stocks, although the service mainly follows blue chips. It's based on Value Line, so if you get that, you only need the book. If Value Line covers it, you can track it using the theory. I adjust the theory as I see fit, based on technicals and my own view of what I want to hold. It avoids some of the more extreme sell-offs you get with the Motley Fool and other approaches, although it's had a few of its own doozies. A simpler measure of value is of course PEG, which anyone can do. As far as the Dow's 1932 trendline goes, we've been above it for a couple of years and been below it during that time. I was wondering if the return to that line could actually be a return to the norm from the extreme of the 70s (it's possible to put a positive spin on it). Of course, the 1932 trendline itself might have been a correction of the extremes of '29-'32 that ended in the 1960s. I think the Dow's real test here will be ~10,800, the apex of the broken diamond. As far as the Nasdaq goes, it broke out of a falling wedge, so by definition it should rise slowly, so that could support the view of a shift to value. Some thoughts, FWIW. My own view is that you've got to find what fits your mentality the best and stick with it, be it trading, value, growth, small cap, large cap, whatever. I think discipline, not style, is they key to sucess in the stock market, the ability to stay the course when your style is out of favor. However, one of the nice things about the Trouncing the Dow approach is it beat the market for most of the last 5 years, a pretty dismal time for value. Buying IBM in 1993 didn't hurt. Paul