To: Brandon who wrote (11002 ) 12/18/2000 3:03:53 PM From: LPS5 Read Replies (3) | Respond to of 18137 With very rare exceptions, there are no good books on trading. If you have 16 of them you have been "taught" a lot of crap. I personally agree, and take that sentiment several steps further. IMHO, and as I have said several times before: the only way - and the indisputably best way - to truly learn to trade is to sit (i.e., work - perhaps starting as an intern or assistant) for a year or two on a trading desk, with professional, experienced (and typically licensed) traders. More importantly, that this firm, fund, or desk provide an environment wherein the traders around you and the firm itself - whether it's a reputable proprietary trading firm, a dealing desk, or an equities-focused hedge fund - have an incentive to ensure that you are profitable , as opposed to being viewed as source of immediate cash flow via commissions. Not lip service, not conceptually vacant or pitifully out-of-date classes, and not the same daytrading book that's been rewritten 500 times. An actual development plan, with a thoroughly hands-on approach, wherein over the prescribed time to become a full-fledged trader, there are required performance thresholds, required demonstration of the mastery of certain skills and/or knowledge; levels of advancement (each introducing a greater amount of capital/size of position/number of positions, additional trading strategies, or other advancements), and the like. And, once that's done - or while it's going on - there are indeed some market- and trading-related books worthy of a read. Interestingly - and again, IMO - very few of which have the words "daytrad[ing]," "direct access," "scalp," or "swing" in them. LPS5