To: excardog who wrote (83286 ) 1/3/2001 11:24:28 AM From: Evolution Respond to of 95453 There you have it... Prudential report on XOM... EQUITY RESEARCH JANUARY 3, 2001 XOM: REDUCING XOM TO HOLD FROM ACCUMULATE BASED ON VALUATION TARGET PRICE IS $84. ExxonMobil XOM | 86.94 | NYSE Michael Mayer • 650.320.1620 • michael_mayer@prusec.com Current: Hold Andrew F. Rosenfeld • 650.320.1632 • andrew_rosenfeld@prusec.com Prior: Accumulate Risk: Low Target: $84.00 FY Rev (mil) EPS P/E 1Q 2Q 3Q 4Q Actual 12/99 $2.38 36.5X $0.46 $0.53 $0.62 $0.77 Current 12/00 $4.70E 18.5X $0.95A $1.18A $1.22A $1.35E Current 12/01 $4.65E 18.7X *Target price based on $20/bbl WTI, $3/mcf U.S. natural gas, and normalized downstream and chemical margins. ** All EPS actuals and estimates exclude special items and are fully diluted. Estimates rounded to the nearest $0.05. Avg. Volume: 5,700,000 Div / Yield: 1.80 / 2.07% EPS Growth NA Market Cap: $302,220 mil 52-Week Range: 95 - 70 P/E / Growth NM Shares: 3,476.19 mil ExxonMobil (XOM), headquartered in Irving, TX, main activities are exploration for and production of crude oil and natural gas; refining, marketing, supply, and transportation of petroleum products; and the manufacturing and marketing of petrochemicals. HIGHLIGHTS · The Major Oils have outperformed the market by 13 percentage points since mid December (Oils up 9%, S&P 500 down 4%). · We remain bullish on the operating and earnings outlook for the sector. We continue to forecast that these key earnings and valuation drivers will average well above normal levels over the next 12-18 months. · However, given the recent sharp outperformance, the group is now discounting $20/bbl oil. All of the major oil stocks are at or near our target prices and the group now has an average of only 15% upside potential. · We are therefore reducing XOM to Hold from Accumlate. XOM is 6% above our $84 target price and has 3% upside potential. DISCUSSION The Major Oils have outperformed the market by 13 percentage points since mid December (Oils up 9%, S&P 500 down 4%). About one-fourth of this outperformance occurred yesterday after Saudi Arabia unequivocally stated its support for a production cut of about 1.5 million b/d. The major oils have moved from the bottom quartile of their 15-year historical relative valuation range to fair value in only 11 trading days. The market is now factoring in a significant OPEC production cut, which was the basis for our very bullish upgrade to a 150% weighting on December 15. We remain bullish on the operating and earnings outlook for the sector. Oil prices, U.S. gas prices, and U.S. refining margins all hit 15-year highs in 2000, with natural gas prices and refining margins ending the year near all time highs. We continue to forecast that these key earnings and valuation drivers will average well above normal levels over the next 12-18 months. This should result in excellent earnings, very high free cash flow, substantial debt reduction for the more leveraged companies (COC, MRO, P, and TX), and large share buybacks for the under leveraged companies (BP, XOM, RD and SC). However, given the recent sharp outperformance, the group is now discounting $20/bbl oil. All of the major oil stocks are at or near our target prices and the group now has an average of only 15% upside potential. Target prices are based on normalizing $20/bbl oil, $3.00/mcf U.S. natural gas, and midcycle refining margins while upside potential is based on normalizing $23/bbl oil, $3.75/mcf gas, and midcycle refining margins. Both are relative to the market. See the table below and page 3. We are therefore reducing our recommended weighting to 100% of a market weighting from 150% and cutting all stock ratings to Hold. Recent Target Price Upside Potential Rating Price $/sh %Chg $/sh %Chg BP (BP) Accum to Hold $49 $49 1% $52 7% Chevron (CHV) Accum to Hold 86 85 -1% 97 12% Conoco A (COCa) Strg Buy to Hold 29 29 2% 35 22% Conoco B (COCb) Strg Buy to Hold 29 29 0% 35 20% ExxonMobil (XOM) Accum to Hold 89 84 -6% 92 3% Marathon (MRO) Accum to Hold 28 29 2% 38 36% Phillips (P) Strg Buy to Hold 57 60 5% 77 34% Royal Dutch (RD) Accum to Hold 63 61 -2% 65 3% Shell (SC) Accum to Hold 50 50 0% 52 3% Texaco (TX) Strg Buy to Hold 63 65 4% 74 19% Source: Prudential Securities Estimates. ************************************