To: Neocon who wrote (6732 ) 2/27/2001 2:27:58 PM From: Solon Read Replies (1) | Respond to of 82486 Well, still here--last post today:Since I am the one who invoked the term "stewardship", what I meant by it, as attested in a reputable dictionary, is most relevant. It might be most relevent to you , but it was not the first time I have seen the word used--and I'm not fried liver.My son was, in a manner of speaking, entrusted to me; the various task I have undertaken, whether remunerative or purely voluntary, have been entrusted to me; many things may be entrusted to one Take it easy. I'm not arguing with you here. All I asked was: "By who"? I am curious as to whether it is a promise to self sort of idea or if there is something else. It seems to be an important idea for you. I was wondering.A right is a moral claim against another, to do or to forbear. You cannot assert a right without acknowledging that we do have moral claims upon one another I don't believe that. I make a distinction between inherent RIGHTS and social "rights" which are mercurial and often based on might . RIGHTS (based on reason) are bound to be understood slightly different over time, but still, we find that physics, chemistry, etc. invite a fairly consistent agreement over time. I believe a RIGHT is a moral claim FROM another. I don't believe RIGHTS are obligations; They are Freedoms. I don't believe the RIGHT to be left alone is an obligation to stay alone. Do you understand the difference I am getting at?If we do not have moral claims upon one another, but each simply follows his nature, you have no basis to assert the right to be left alone. I do not require a moral claim of you to assert my right to be left alone. If you were the only other person on earth I WOULD assert that RIGHT; Although I would probably only avoid your company if you were a psychopath or someone I detested.Whatever you may hold unjustly, for example, if you occupy a house and take hostages, may morally be taken from you by force Absolutely, now we have agreement. I don't have a right to take hostages, because other people have the right to be left alone.