To: cosmicforce who wrote (8244 ) 3/13/2001 1:43:14 PM From: Solon Read Replies (2) | Respond to of 82486 If you do all the math I thought Godel already did that?!...From Russel: It can be shown that a mathematical web of some kind can be woven about any universe containing several objects. The fact that our universe lends itself to mathematical treatment is not a fact of any great philosophical significance. True Reality just doesn't mesh very well with our notions of anthropic reality! Did YOU say True REALITY?! :) Now...you are placing the argument within a commonly held concept of time. By doing this you are closing the door on the intuitive argument. For instance, the "10 minutes ago" might have been in a parallel universe. Furthermore, a "logical possibility" in philosophy is independent of fact in science or mathematics. Once again, Godel showed that mathematics was unreliable, and he showed it by (arbitrarily) relying on philosophical logic as a higher order. Logic may or may not be reliable, but he used it to trump the certainty of mathematics. Having said that, I have no problem with: "time simply is a memory of probability relationships. Past relationships (states becoming less likely) are being compared with other states (becoming more probable)" . However, my ideas are behind QM , so how can you possibly see and critique them?! :) And what do you mean, (I am) "...trying to be "God""?!! :)I believe you deceive yourself: Then I have succeeded.You are trying to be "God", but the fabric of the universe doesn't permit such manipulations - Where is your brother? What have you done? I made it clear that the task of recreation was an impossible one. It is impossible for you to physically eat the moon (probably, but I've never met you); But it is logically possible and therefore can be used in an argument. I want you to slaughter a huge ram and soak your big toe in the blood; Also put some blood on your pinky and your left ear and spatter the rest in a 4 square cubit area. Make it real messy. Tomorrow I'll teach you how to crochet doilies!