SI
SI
discoversearch

We've detected that you're using an ad content blocking browser plug-in or feature. Ads provide a critical source of revenue to the continued operation of Silicon Investor.  We ask that you disable ad blocking while on Silicon Investor in the best interests of our community.  If you are not using an ad blocker but are still receiving this message, make sure your browser's tracking protection is set to the 'standard' level.
Politics : PRESIDENT GEORGE W. BUSH -- Ignore unavailable to you. Want to Upgrade?


To: J_F_Shepard who wrote (138952)4/17/2001 2:15:47 PM
From: Neocon  Respond to of 769667
 
My objection is not that nothing every happens along these lines, but that the incidence is exaggerated, and conflated with things that are untrue or unproven. A link like this is neither here nor there.....



To: J_F_Shepard who wrote (138952)4/17/2001 2:17:16 PM
From: Neocon  Read Replies (1) | Respond to of 769667
 
Remember, this is what I was reacting to:

WAKE UP! Catholic priests have committed some of the most despicable acts of our time. And I'm not talking about the molestation of children and nuns, or the failed cover-up attempts by the Vatican. G-E-N-O-C-I-D-E has long been their specialty.



To: J_F_Shepard who wrote (138952)4/17/2001 2:20:01 PM
From: Neocon  Read Replies (2) | Respond to of 769667
 
MAJOR CREDIT FOR THE RESCUE OF ITALY'S JEWS
GOES TO CATHOLIC CLERGY, YAD VASHEM SAYS
Although the Vatican was justifiably criticized for its deafening silence during the Nazi deportation of Jews, a loud chorus of refugee assistance resonated in its monasteries, convents and churches. A large number of priests, monks and nuns sheltered and fed desperate Jewish men, women and children, a chapter in the Holocaust that too many historians have over-looked or minimized.

In Italy, the clergy played a major role in rescue activity, according to Mordecai Paldiel, research chief of Israel’s Yad Vashem, which uses stringent standards to honor Holocaust heroes. Paldiel, who himself was hidden as a child by Father Simon Gallay of France, says that much of the credit for the rescue of most of Italy’s 45,000 Jews is due to the clergy.

"There can be little doubt that the rescue of 85 percent of Italy’s Jews," he says, "can be safely attributed to the massive support extended to fleeing Jews by the overwhelming majority of the Catholic clergy (without in most cases even waiting for clearance by their superiors) as well as of persons from all walks of life, even of officials and militiamen within the more intensely Fascist Salo regime."

These are powerful words of recognition and support from an authority with impeccable credentials, and a revelation that should have inspired a mini-series, if not a mega-series, on TV. And is even worthy of a major motion picture by Hollywood. But so far their response has been as deafening as Vatican’s reported silence.

Despite the Vatican’s official aloofness from the Holocaust question, many were surprised to learn after the war that 450 Jews were hidden in its vast enclaves during the Nazi occupation. And hundreds of priests and bishops throughout the Italian peninsula put their lives in jeopardy to shelter, feed and clothe the countless refugees.

One of the earliest organized rescue efforts unfolded in Assisi, the birthplace of St. Francis, the founder of the Franciscan order. Shortly after the Nazis occupied Italy, Padre Ruffino Niccacci of the Damiano monastery received an unusual assignment from his bishop: Find homes and hiding places for more than 300 Jews who just arrived from Trieste.

Padre Niccacci, a peasant turned priest, managed to have many of the refugees sheltered in buildings on the monastery grounds and dressed them as monks and nuns to hide their true identities during frequent Nazi searches. Others were placed in parishioners’ homes and blended into the community. He also provided them with false credentials to speed their journey to other monasteries and convents, where it been reported the nuns prepared kosher meals for their Jewish guests. Not a single refugee was captured while staying at Assisi.

Maria Benedetto (known as Father Marie Benoit when he was in Marseilles) transformed his monastery in Rome into a way station and rescue center to aid hundreds of Jewish and anti-Nazi refugees. When Delasem (Delegazione Assistenza Emigranti Ebrei), the highly-efficient Jewish service agency, had to go underground during the Nazi occupation, it carried out operations from Father Benedetto’s monastery. Here, Delasem stored its archives, held meetings, processed refugees and provided hiding places. In just 12 months, the number of refugees receiving shelter and meals at the monastery swelled from a few hundred to over 4,000.

In the strategically located city of Turin, Monsignor Vincenzo Barale conducted rescue activity for Jews streaming into Italy from France. The refugees received food and money and were assisted by priests from surrounding villages. However, one refugee who had received aid, informed on him. Monsignor Barale was arrested and thrown into jail.

High level Catholic officials as well as ordinary clerics extended a helping hand. Monsignor Quadraroli, a secretary at the Vatican, issued countless false IDs to refugees and sent them to the convent on Via Cicerone to be fed and sheltered. And in northern Italy, Abraham Cohen, on the run from the Nazis, recalled the assistance he received from unknown clerics: "The Catholic Church helped me a lot. They found a place for me to stay and a priest went with me from Ivrea to Azeglio on a bicycle. . . There we found another priest who arranged a place for me to hide."

Susan Zuccotti, Holocaust historian, gives a very balanced view in assessing the overall picture: "When the Germans finally retreated from Rome after nine months of occupation, at least 1,700 Jews arrested in Rome had been deported. Over 10,000 had survived. Every survivor owed his life to one, and usually to several, heroic non-Jewish supporters. But except for those caught in that first, unexpected roundup in October, most deportees could also trace their tragedy to non-Jews who had, in the last analysis, failed to provide support."

However, there’s no denying that the network of Catholic institutions played a significant role in providing asylum for Jewish refugees.

"In no other occupied Catholic country," says Paldiel of Yad Vashem, "were monasteries, convents, shrines, and religious houses opened to the fleeing Jews, and their needs attended to, without any overt intention to steer them away from their ancient faith, solely to abide by the preeminent religious command of the sanctity of life. Through this, they epitomized the best and most elevated form of religious faith and human fidelity."

holocaust-heroes.com



To: J_F_Shepard who wrote (138952)4/17/2001 2:22:10 PM
From: Neocon  Read Replies (3) | Respond to of 769667
 
CONVENTS, CHURCH INSTITUTIONS
SHELTERED THOUSANDS REFUGEES
(Note to film and TV producers and intrepid entrepreneurs: The following segment covers aspects of the Holocaust that have been grossly under-reported or totally ignored. The material is ripe for a TV mini-series or a documentary film by a resourceful church group, foundation, History Channel or an enterprising individual.)

WHEN THE NAZIS launched their roundup of refugees in Italy late in 1943, Nathan Cassuto, the chief rabbi of Florence, urged Jews to leave town or go into hiding. Several years later, while testifying at the Adolf Eichmann trial, the rabbi's sister recalled: "My brother went from house to house to warn them to hide themselves in convents or in little villages, under false names." Hundreds of Florentine Jews took his advice and survived.
Convents, monasteries, orphanages and other church institutions throughout occupied-Europe were some of the very few "ready-made" safe harbors that Jews could turn to when escaping Nazi raids, arrests or terror. There was "room at the inn" for refugees who found shelter and protection at these church havens that stretched from Poland to Belgium and France, Italy and the Balkans.

These religious institutions also provided sanctuary for countless Jewish children whose parents were shipped to labor or death camps. Being hidden in a convent or orphanage, the children were assured of shelter, food and access, when required, to medical attention. Their identities were usually masked with Christian names as a safeguard during Gestapo searches and interrogations.

CHURCH INSTITUTIONS in Poland were among the first to open their doors to the flood of children thrust upon them by desperate refugees facing deportation. It is estimated that at least 190 convents in Poland offered asylum to thousands of children of refugees. In Otwock and Pludy, suburbs of Warsaw, the convents of the Sisters of Maria's Family were active in rescue efforts as well as hiding and feeding of many refugees. In other convents, the Ursuline Sisters and the Franciscan Sisters in Warsaw and Laski, took in children from distraught parents. And in Pruzany, nuns rescued scores of Jewish women by disguising them in the habits of their order.

Irena Sendler, the Warsaw social worker who rescued more than 2,500 Jewish children from the ghetto, accomplished her incredible deeds with the active assistance of the church. "I sent most of the children to religious establishments," she recalled. "I knew I could count on the Sisters." Sendler also had a remarkable record of cooperation when placing the youngsters: "No one ever refused to take a child from me," she said.

The vast majority of nuns in convents led quiet if not reclusive lives, insulated from outside forces. But the seven sisters in the small Benedictine convent near Vilna Colony railroad station in Poland were active undercover agents who specialized in smuggling Jews out of the nearby ghetto. Among those who found safe harbor in the convent were several Jewish writers as well as leaders of the ghetto underground: Abba Kovner, Abraham Sutzkever, Ariel Wilner and Edek Boraks.

The convent's mother superior, Anna Borkowska, a Cracow University graduate, together with other nuns, provided the underground with weapons and ammunition. They would visit nearby homes, under the pretense of church business, and instead "borrow" guns, pistols, grenades and knives from the farmers. Philip Friedman, the Holocaust historian, has poetically described their undercover activity in these words: "The hands accustomed to the touch of rosary beads became expert with explosives."

Clemens Loew, born in Stanislawow, Poland, was only five years old when his mother left him in custody of nuns at a convent in Olsztyn, on the outskirts of Warsaw, where he remained hidden for three years. Loew, who later migrated to the United States and became a psychologist, vividly remembers one close call he had during a surprise Nazi raid on the convent.

"The Gestapo officers were actually dragging me away," he recalled. "One was yanking me out the door when a retired bishop living in the convent hobbled down the steps and yelled, 'If you take him, then you have to take me too.'" Loew added that the Nazis could have easily arrested both of them, but for some unexplained reason they left both unharmed.

RETURN TO PAGE MENU

IN BELGIUM, the La Providence orphanage in Verviers, operated by the Sisters of Charity of St. Vincent de Paul, played a major part in sheltering and caring for hundreds of children whose parents had been shipped to concentration camps or were in hiding themselves. Sister Marie (Mathilde Leruth) was in charge and made sure that the Jewish children didn't give away their identity during the many unexpected visits by the Nazis. Once, when a major Nazi raid was expected, Sister Marie had the children put aboard a bus and taken on an impromtu outing to a nearby village for the afternoon. Sylvain Brachfeld, who was one of the children at the orphanage, years later described Sister Marie as "a marvel of love under circumstances which obliged her to risk her life and liberty every day." Sister Marie was elected to the Righeous Among the Nations by Yad Vashem in Israel.

A Belgian cleric who had a pivotal role in rescuing hundreds of Jewish refugees, including many children, was Father Bruno (Henri Reynders). Working in conjunction with the JDC (Jewish Defense Council), the Benedictine monk used Mont Cesar monastery near Louvain to carry out his vast network of placing children in convents and private families. In addition to insuring the children's safety, Father Bruno provided the host families with food ration cards, false idenities as well as financial aid.

When some of the host families requested his permission to convert the children in their care, Father Bruno responded: "We are responsible for the lives of these children, but their souls do not belong to us." One JDC executive emphasized that Father Bruno personally made all payments for the children in his care. Years later, when he visited Israel to plant a tree at Yad Vashem, Father Bruno recalled his war-time rescue activities: "Three hundred and sixteen Jewish souls passed through my hands, among them 200 children. I can't begin to tell you how many doors I knocked on. I literally wore myself out, but it was all worth it."

Rose Meerhoff, of Brussels, was only seven years old when she was confronted with Nazi deportations. One day in September, 1940, when she returned home from school, a neighbor stopped her at the door and said, "The Germans were here and took your mother away. Don't go upstairs to your apartment." The neighbor then took Rose to the train station and escorted her to Louvain, where the Benedictine sisters operated an orphanage. She remembers that there were Jewish children already there when she arrived and more kept coming. She adds that all were given Christian names. Hers was Christiane DeGraef. "I stayed in that convent for two and a half years," she later wrote, "and I still have a special feeling for Catholics and nuns in particular. They were risking their lives for us."

Lucien Steinberg, in his book Not As A Lamb, which tells about the rescue efforts of Jewish organizations in Europe, describes the assistance they received from church institutions in Belgium: "The protection of Elizabeth, the Queen Mother, as well as Cardinal Van Roey and others, including the exiled government, ensured a place for a child in any convent."

Other Belgian clerics, laymen and institutions that took active roles in rescuing and protecting Jewish refugees:

Father Joseph Andre of Namur forsook a life of study and contemplation to devote his energies to saving hundreds of refugees, primarily children. Working in conjunction with the Committee for the Defense of Jews (CDJ), a clandestine Jewish organization, he pleaded and cajoled monasteries and convents in Belgium to house the refugees. When he died in 1973, several of his rescued wards were pallbearers at his funeral.

The Belgian underground was closely allied with convents and monasteries in its rescue efforts. Jeanne de Mulienaere, a Flemish-Catholic newspaperwoman, and her colleague Vera Shapiro, working with the underground, were instrumental in saving over 3,000 Jewish children by dispatching them to monasteries and convents in Belgium.

Louisa Mercier, personnel chief of a manufacturing firm in Louvain, is credited with placing dozens of refugee children in a Catholic institute in Chimay in southern Belgium.

Our Lady of Zion (Notre Dame de Sion) rescued 200 Jewish children from terrified parents facing deportation and hid them in several convents in Belgium.

The Queen Elisabeth Home, a chateau located in the village of Jamoigne-sur-Semois, was transformed into a center for feeble children in 1941under the care of the Sisters of Charity of Besancon. But following stepped up Nazi roundups, it opened its doors to children of fleeing refugees. Of the 75 children hidden at the center, more than 50 percent were Jewish.

holocaust-heroes.com



To: J_F_Shepard who wrote (138952)4/17/2001 2:23:39 PM
From: Neocon  Respond to of 769667
 
IN FRANCE, the legendary Father Marie-Benoit (born Pierre Peteul), a monk in the Capuchin monastery in Marseille, resolved to thwart the Nazis after witnessing frequent roundups of Jewish refugees. Gifted with extraordinary ability as an organizer, he turned the monastery into a far-reaching rescue operation, working with frontier guides who smuggled Jews and anti-Nazi refugees into Spain and Switzerland. In the basement of the monastery, the printing press turned out countless false ID cards, certificates of baptism and other documents needed by the escaping refugees. Affectionately called "Father of the Jews," the Capuchin monk was instrumental in saving untold Jewish lives.
Abbe Joseph Folliet, the Catholic chaplain of Jeunesse ouvriere chretienne (JOC), was a vital cog in assisting dozens of refugees crossing the border into Switzerland. Border escorts or guides directed their charges to Abbe Folliet who arranged for them to stay at church sanctuaries in the department of Haute-Savoie, the women at the convent of Chavanod near Annecy, and the men at the Abbaye de Tamie, north of Faverges.

Jesuit Father Pierre Chaillet, hero of the French resistance and the publisher of an underground newspaper, used to haunt the street of Lyons and countryside looking for abandoned children. During one search, he found four children huddling in a cave and led them to a monastery, where several hundred other refugees were being housed. He also rescued 30 Jewish children from French police stations, where they were being held for questioning.

When 19-year-old Betty Dornfest and her mother were being sheltered in a convent in Correze, France, the mother superior made it possible for them to practice their religion. Sister Marie-Gonzague Bredoux provided them with candles and oil from the church which they in turn used to welcome the Sabbath on Friday evenings. When the High Holy Days neared, Mother Marie supplied them with the necessary ingredients and special pots and dishes to prepare their food in the convent's kitchen. According to Mordecai Paldiel, the research chief of Israel's Yad Vashem: "There are few instances (certainly none before the Holocaust period) of Jews helped to practice their religion inside Catholic convents."

Other French clerics and religious who were instrumental in rescuing or sheltering refugees in church institutions:

Monseigneur Paul Remond, the bishop of Nice, supplied a letter of introduction to Moussa Abadi, a Syrian Jew of the OSE child rescue network, that opened the doors to local Catholic institutions when placing Jewish youngsters. The bishop also provided Abadi with a private office within his residence.

Mother Maria of Notre-Dame de Sion in Melun is reported to have saved more than 500 Jewish children by directing them to nearby convents and schools.

Reverend Father Superior Charles Devaux, head of the Fathers of Our Lady Zion, a Catholic missionary organization, is credited with saving more than 400 Jewish Children and 500 adults by finding them shelter with workmen's families and in convents and monasteries.

Shatta and Bouli Simon, indefatigable workers for the Jewish Boy Scouts of France, recalled the cooperation they received from Monseigneur Theas: "I must say that Monseigneur Theas opened for us, as for others, the college de Sorreze, that of Saint Antoine de Padoue near Brive, and other religious secondary establishments, where we were able to place a very large number of young people."

Jean-Gerard Saliege, archbishop of Toulouse, gave Georges Garel of the OSE, a personal letter of introduction and encouraged him to place Jewish children in the church's boarding schools, orphanages, hospitals and youth hostels. Garel later remarked: "From my first contact with him, I knew I was in the presence of a superior person. That man, I can and I must say, had the stuff of a saint."

Joseph Bass, colorful founder of Service Andre, a clandestine network that hid over 1,000 refugees in Le Chambon, also worked with Father Regis de Perceval, who provided the group with quarters in a monastery in Marseille for their operations. To conceal his identity, Bass disguised himself as a Dominican monk, conducted meetings and enlisted the aid of resident monks.

holocaust-heroes.com



To: J_F_Shepard who wrote (138952)4/17/2001 2:24:47 PM
From: Neocon  Respond to of 769667
 
VILLAGES OFFERED UNIQUE HAVEN OF
P R O T E C T I O N A N D S I L E N C E
Le Chambon-sur-Lignon, a remote village on a pine-studded plateau in south central France, was an isolated town of about 2,000 people, which historian Leon Poliakov described in the 1940's as "distrusting all authority, listening only to their conscience - or their pastors."
One pastor they listened to was Andre Trocme, the Protestant pastor of Le Chambon, who with his wife Magda were instrumental in building a rescue network in Le Chambon and neighboring villages that ultimately provided safe havens for 5,000 Jews, many of them children, fleeing Nazi terror.

The refugees began streaming into the village as early as 1940. Some stayed long enough to secure a guide to Switzerland, but many remained, sheltered with families and boardinghouses. They kept pouring in until, as Poliakov said, "in some hamlets, there was not a single farm which did not shelter a Jewish family."

What attracted the refugees to Le Chambon? Writing years later, Magda Trocme explained: "Because we were in the mountains, because it was a Protestant place, because someone had spoken, perhaps, of a minister who at that time had funny ideas, who was a conscientious objector."

The Trocmes weren't alone is assisting the refugees. CIMADE, the Protestant relief agency, headed by Madeleine Barot, set up a family residence at the Hotel Coteau Fleuri, on the outskirts of the village. The Quakers, in cooperation with Pastor Trocme, established a boardinghouse for young children. And Secours suisse launched two farm-schools for older children of the refugees. In addition, nearby Catholic convents and monasteries also participated in the rescue effort.

But this clandestine activity didn't escape the attention of the French police. Early one morning in August, 1942, the police arrived in the village with three empty buses, and demanded that Pastor Trocme provide them with the names of the hidden Jews.

Trocme replied, "No, I cannot. First, I do not know their names - they often changed their names - and I don't know who they are. And second, these Jews, they are my brothers." The police searched the village for three days, but arrested only one refugee, an Austrian who subsequently was released because he was only half Jewish.

It was months later that Trocme was arrested and spent several weeks in a Vichy detention camp.

Recalling the rescue activity years later, Magda Trocme said: "The first thing is that we must not think that we were the only ones who helped during those times. Little by little, now that we speak of these things, we realize that other people did lot of things too."

OTHER VILLAGES IN OTHER COUNTRIES: Although Le Chambon justifiably looms large in the pantheon of hospitable villages that welcomed refugees, other villages in France and in other countries also provided a protective environment and a safe haven during the Holocaust years:

THIMORY, a French village of 350 inhabitants near Orleans, offered a shield of protection for a 20-year-old Auschwitz survivor identified only as Moschkovitch, and his family. They lived openly in the village, using their own name. He recalled: "All the people of Thimory knew that we were Jews, from the mayor and the school teacher to the last farmer, and including the sister of the priest. . . We were never denounced although there were many people there, not to say a majority, who thought well of Petain and his Vichy government."

NICOLE DAVID was a hidden child with a Catholic family in Belgium when she was six years old. In 1942, her father arranged for her to hide with him in Besine, a Belgian village of 150 residents. "The village was hiding at least 30 Jews," she wrote later. "Eudor Clobert, the mayor; and the priest, whose name I can't remember; and Maurice Pochet, who kept the village shop; saved many lives, providing Jews with false papers, food and communications. The whole village was very good."

THE CITIZENS OF SECCHIANO, a close-knit village in central Italy, banded together to shelter Wolf and Esther Fullenbaum and their four-year-old daughter, Carlotta. Their presence was common knowledge and even a source of pride among the 600 villagers. Housed on the second floor of a schoolhouse, the refugee family received food and supplies from storekeepers and neighbors. Even though the village priest was arrested for hiding other refugees, not one citizen ever betrayed the Fullenbaums, who remained in Secchiano for more than a year and survived the war.

RUTH RUBENSTEIN, another hidden child who spent some time in a Catholic convent in Belgium, was later placed with the DeMarneffs, a Belgian couple who had no children. "They lived in a village near Brussels and were very nice and kind to me," she recalled. "The DeMarneffs passed me off as a niece from Italy. Later I learned that the whole village knew I was Jewish and they all protected me."

GISELA KONOPKA, originally from Berlin, Germany, joined the anti-Nazi underground when she was a college student. She later married and with her husband escaped into France and strayed into Montauban, a village in northern France. "Montauban was like a miracle," she remembered. "Catholics, Protestants, the entire village opened its homes, gave us false papers, rations, all the things you needed. . . We ate blackberries and suet and bread, and the farmers gave us milk."

Commenting on this cocoon of goodness that the refugees found in towns and villages, Lucien Steinberg, French historian and researcher, observed: "I would like to emphasize that the majority of the Jews saved in France do not owe their rescue to Jewish organizations. The various Jewish bodies which worked with such great dedication managed to save only a few tens of thousands, while the others were saved mostly thanks to the assistance of the French population. In many cases, groups of Jews lived in small villages. Everyone of the Jews was convinced that no one in that area knew their true identity; after the war it turned out that everyone knew that they were Jews."

holocaust-heroes.com