From RedHerring.com:
"So our advice to investors would be to stay away. There are plenty of technology stocks that are due to bounce back as the outlook for the sector improves. Comdisco, however, is not one of them."
redherring.com
Comdisco dances around the idea of selling By Lisa Meyer Red Herring May 7, 2001
Comdisco's (NYSE: CDO) conference call on Thursday was short -- but not in the least bit sweet.
The company, which rode the Internet wave on a strategy of receiving warrants for startup companies to which it leased equipment, gave the sour facts, but no future guidance. There wasn't even a chance for anybody to ask questions. That's too bad, because speculation is increasing about the ailing Illinois-based technology services company, which has failed to offer any forward-looking commentary for about six weeks.
Comdisco hired investment bank Goldman Sachs and consultants McKinsey & Company last month to help review its "strategic alternatives" -- corporate jargon that often means a company is for sale. And considering that Comdisco shuttered its digital subscriber line (DSL) subsidiary, Prism Communication Services, in October and exited the network services business in January, it's reasonable to suspect that more assets will be sold -- perhaps even the whole company.
It will not be easy for Comdisco to survive on its own. Due to problems with its balance sheet, the company's bonds have plunged to junk-bond status. That makes it infinitely more difficult for Comdisco to raise new money from the public debt markets. As a result, the company recently drew $880 million from loans to help meet about $825 million in commercial bond obligations. During its second quarter, Comdisco reported a net loss of $54 million, or 35 cents per share -- a far cry from its net earnings of $43 million, or 26 cents per share, for the year-earlier period.
"It has become apparent during this review that growth and profits of our core business have been severely challenged by costs and availability of funds, as well as structural costs," Comdisco's new CEO, Norman Blake, said during the conference call.
Due to these current liquidity problems, Comdisco announced on Thursday that it was suspending the payment of quarterly dividends to shareholders. Not a good sign. So how did everything go wrong for Comdisco?
A GLORIOUS PAST, A MUDDLED FUTURE Not too long ago, Comdisco basked in the wealth of the technology boom, sporting a stock price of $53 on the Nasdaq's heyday of March 10, 2000. On Friday, the stock was worth just $2.96 a share, a 94 percent decline from its peak.
It is not surprising that Comdisco's fortunes rose in tandem with other technology stocks, because part of the company's business model included investing in venture capital-backed companies. Formed in 1987, Comdisco Ventures provides leases, loans, and direct equity financing to emerging companies. The leases of equipment and loans are sweetened with warrants that compensate Comdisco for offering these services at lower costs. For a majority of the company's investments, the loans and leases are paid back quickly. But 10 to 13 percent of Comdisco's investments are direct equity stakes in companies, according to A.G. Edwards analyst Mark Jordan.
"It's not a bad business, but it can't be the dominant source of revenue for a company, because the market is cyclical," says Mr. Jordan. "Comdisco ran into trouble because it made its venture business too large relative to the size of the company's other earnings segments."
When you look at a list of a few of Comdisco's customers during the last three years, it's easy to understand why the company is in trouble: Ariba (Nasdaq: ARBA), Ask Jeeves (Nasdaq: ASKJ), Copper Mountain Networks (Nasdaq: CMTN), Corvis (Nasdaq: CORV), and NorthPoint Communications (OTC: NPNTQ). These companies all have their own tales of economic woe. And since Comdisco lends to and invests in technology firms, the sector's problems hit the company especially hard.
"As the technology sector declined, we saw a significant number of our customers declare bankruptcy or shut down their operations during the quarter," Comdisco's CFO John Vosicky said in the conference call. "As a result of that, we wrote off $100 million in receivables." Mr. Vosicky added that in reaction to this deterioration, Comdisco added $206 million in reserves during the quarter, bringing the total up to $210 million. In January, Comdisco suspended new commitments in this business.
WHAT NOW? Now Comdisco is faced with the high likelihood that it will have to sell off even more of its assets or put the whole company on the auction block. Despite its current troubles, not all of its business segments are suffering. Its services, or disaster-recovery, unit and its equipment-licensing business are stable.
For the services division, Comdisco brags of such customers as Hewlett-Packard (NYSE: HWP), Sun Microsystems (Nasdaq: SUNW), and Hitachi Data Systems (NYSE: HIT). As part of the licensing business, Comdisco buys, sells, and leases new as well as used PCs, workstations, servers, printers, and other desktop-related equipment. According to Mr. Vosicky, licensing earned $11 million and services earned $7 million this quarter before taxes.
Mr. Jordan predicts that Comdisco will try to sell parts of or all of its licensing division and focus on services. The most likely bidders for the licensing division would be competitors like IBM (NYSE: IBM) and General Electric (NYSE: GE). And if the company were to try to sell the services business, IBM and SunGard Data Systems (NYSE: SDS) would be natural fits.
Although Comdisco said it had $534 million in cash at the end of its latest quarter, it's unclear how long that will keep the company afloat. And even though it may succeed in selling some -- if not all -- of its assets, it seems unlikely that anybody would pay a big premium. So our advice to investors would be to stay away. There are plenty of technology stocks that are due to bounce back as the outlook for the sector improves. Comdisco, however, is not one of them. |