To: The Philosopher who wrote (15825 ) 6/6/2001 4:09:09 PM From: Solon Respond to of 82486 Rekax. My post was not contentious. I was merely referring to the fact that tou's apply equally to all threads. As to the fact that moderated threads allow members beneath admin to set certain standards without wasting admin's time--which is to say, they may moderate disruptive and undesirable people off or back on the thread in the interests of the participants--well, people are entitled to differ on the merits of this. Keep in mind that individuals were already allowed to moderate whose posts appear to them on the threads they frequent. But as it is, it's arbitrary and capricious, and there is no appeal procedure It is only as arbitrary and capricious as the moderator is arbitrary and capricious. So it may, or it may not be those things. There is an appeal procedure. Banned members may be unbanned. There are the considerations of peer pressure and respect which serve to constrain the arbitrary possibilities of the moderator. Certainly, a moderator can moderate in unfair ways. Likewize any member may act in unfair ways. If you are seeking justice, you are on the wrong planet. Our membership allows us to start moderated threads. It is therefore considered ethical and legal by the owners of the community. Why should some members be prevented from enjoying what they have paid for? For instance, when someone is being stalked all over SI, say by a mental midget, and is having her/his enjoyment of membership thus violated--why should the only recourse for that person be to painstakingly gather evidence, and to be always vulnerable to the time when the mental midget is once again given a password? Why should whole groups of people be subjected to the sniping of a pea brain? I don't buy it, and neither did SI. I can respect your opinion; I just don't agree with it. Personally, I think permanent removal from a thread except as a last resort is small minded, but in a virtual community where homesteading is available to all, I can buy it. If I am moderated off a thread there is either a good or a bad reason. If it is a bad reason, then I am content to avoid their company.