To: the-phoenix who wrote (40135 ) 7/15/2001 5:08:00 PM From: eichler Respond to of 100058 Phoenix, Good observations of the 60 min comp chart and implication of the stochastic crossed down.home.earthlink.net In the above 60 min snapshot, I made a couple of lines highlighting pertinent features. The box on stochastics shows a recent similar event to the present discussion where price gapped up and stochastics remained overbought for some time while signaling repeated bad sell signals.home.earthlink.net This view of the 15 minute shows the conflicting story of stochastics just firing off a BUY signal, even though the 60 min is on sell. There is no rule that says the signal can't be invalidated just as I pointed out on the 60 min chart that a sell signal can't also be invalidated. There is an apparent conflict that will definitely resolve one way or the other...ggg (duh)home.earthlink.net Finally, in answer to your question "What rally?", here is the current view of the daily. Of note to me is the fresh buy signals on ADX, STO, MA. My answer to "what rally?" is what is to the right of the recent broken ST downtrend line. Those two white candles; white marubozu followed by spinning top. THAT rally! GGG This post is intended for the purposes of discussing the TA features of the current situation for the comp, not as a missive arguing your current opinion. While I disagree with your opinion, I still respect it and thanks to your detailed post can easily see what exactly you are considering. Appreciate your post and I will be only too willing to abandon my current bullishness should the chart discrepancies resolve contrary to my expectations. I think the jury is still out on this one though...due to announce their verdict Monday, methinks. Best regards, Eichler