To: Mama Bear who wrote (72781 ) 7/19/2001 6:53:54 PM From: Ben Wa Read Replies (1) | Respond to of 122087 to respond to each point from the Mensa reject of the Libertarian party: 1. Immigration creates jobs because immigrants start businesses - Dasbach's statment says nothing about the level of immigration in numbers, or the type of people who come into the country. Taking his first statement at face value, if immigration creates jobs and jobs are good, then we should import each individual living in all other nations and house the entire world's population in our country. Why? Because with a population of billions in the US, we will have more jobs. His statement shows unbelievably incomplete logic. Any attempt to modulate his blanket statement regarding the level of immigration opens up his other beliefs to massive scrutiny. 2. Immigrants start businesses that employ people - Current law allows for legal immigration. Perhaps the brain dead twerp is unaware of that. 3. "Record low unemployment coexisting with immigration indicates that immigrants create jobs" - On which planet is this guy referring to? His statement is a play on one of the oldest tricks in the political book which is as follows: Made a true statement that everyone agrees on and follow it up with an opinion but claim that because "A" is true, then "B" must be true. But in this case, the guy can't even get that right - record low unemployment? Tell that to the people who just got canned at Motorola. LOL 4. The thrust of his arguement is that the well-being of our nation should be only measured by an increase in nominal GNP. This concept although never true, became outdated when our primate ancestors began to use the thumb for increased dexterity. He ignores quality of life issues, ecological issues, housing issues, etc. 5. Another of his points makes me think that this guy must have rubberized sheets on his bed. Immigrants provide immeasurable cultural benefits. "What would America be like without sushi, pizza, wiener schnitzel, burritos or any of the other foods brought to our shores by immigrants?" Dasbach asked. "Or imagine radio stations and concert halls devoid of salsa, flamenco, techno, or classical music, all of which originated in other nations. Or try telling sports fans that baseball would be the same without Sammy Sosa, tennis would as exciting without Monica Seles, or basketball would be as much fun without Dikmbe Mutombo." Again - our laws provide for legal immigration. He also fails to address the fact that singling out Mexicans for legal status is bizarre. Couldn't somebody have illegally come into our nation from El Salvador so why are they being discriminated against? Finally, I think if he is personally willing to write the checks to pay for the dramatic increase in social services that will be necessary, then we should let them all in.