To: J. C. Dithers who wrote (1288 ) 7/25/2001 12:54:14 AM From: daffodil Read Replies (2) | Respond to of 1857 (Gulp) Has anyone here had a gall bladder removed? JC, I think you raise a very interesting question. Your medical team is telling you that your gall bladder is useless. But the question is, "just because we can't identify any reason that the thing is useful, can we therefore conclude that it is useless?" Most of us would recognize that as faulty logic, and therein lies the rub. Years ago, my doctor wanted me to have thyroid surgery. I had nodes that made my doctor nervous. I had all sorts of tests and the technicians doing the tests told me, "oh, these nodes are no problem." Of course, the doctor was upset that they told me that. He couldn't tell me exactly why the nodes were BAD, but but he sent me to The Surgeon. The Surgeon said, "we'll remove these nodes and, of course, we'll take out your parathyroid as well." My immediate reaction was, "what? No way you will!!! I don't know what my parathyroid is or does, but I WANT IT!" I left The Surgeon's office promising to call to schedule the surgery, but I never did. I didn't mind if they took out the offending thyroid, but the innocent parathyroid was the deal killer for me. That was at least 12 years ago and to date all of my thyroid tests are normal and I haven't died yet. So yeah, I'm with you. I studied Comparative Anatomy in college and it's just amazing how all of these little parts work together to create an incredible functional whole being. Just because we don't know what an organ does is no reason to remove it. It's bad logic, bad thinking, and for all we know it may be bad medicine. I hope you get lots of feedback from people who have been through this to help you in your decision as to whether such radical surgery is necessary. I think your approach of using the Internet to gather information is excellent. Doctors hate it when we use this kind of anecdotal evidence to challenge their pronouncements. But there's a lot of wisdom in collective experience. Good luck to you. Please keep us posted, okay? }->---------->>>>