SI
SI
discoversearch

We've detected that you're using an ad content blocking browser plug-in or feature. Ads provide a critical source of revenue to the continued operation of Silicon Investor.  We ask that you disable ad blocking while on Silicon Investor in the best interests of our community.  If you are not using an ad blocker but are still receiving this message, make sure your browser's tracking protection is set to the 'standard' level.
Technology Stocks : Intel Corporation (INTC) -- Ignore unavailable to you. Want to Upgrade?


To: Mary Cluney who wrote (143493)9/16/2001 2:40:27 PM
From: tcmay  Read Replies (2) | Respond to of 186894
 
You make the usual errors:

* wishful thinking, that things will be as we _wish_ them to be, not as they actually _are_

* magical thinking, that if people believe incorrect thoughts, in your opinion, they must have helped _cause_ bad events

* "if everyone thought that way, think of what would happen!"

(Note that the only people who got out of the top floors of either tower were those who ignored the P.A. system to "avoid panic, stay where you are, the fire department has things under control." I watch a young woman named Linda Perry describe how her husband, Rick Perry, was on one of the top floors in the second tower to be hit. She was talking to him on his cellphone, and he was thinking about leaving the building. The P.A. system told them to remain calm, not to panic, to stay at their desks. Linda said some of his colleagues were saying "I'm outta here!" and they fled down the elevators and stairwells. Ten minutes later, his own tower was hit, and he told his wife on the cellphone that smoke was coming in under the doors...then, silence, as the tower collapsed.)

It is "magical thinking" to think that those who discuss the logical effects of this attack on soft targets are somehow culpable. Jingoism in the worst way.

And it is foolish to think that people should go out next week and buy stocks for more than their market value, and prospects in the coming recession, support. That is the financial equivalent of "don't panic, stay at your desks, help is on the way."

Game-theoretically, it always makes sense for the leaders to urge calm, to urge the sheeple to buy stocks and to go out and buy SUVs and other luxury items to keep the consumage economy humming.

So, stay at your desks, support America by buying a big-screen t.v., go deeper in debt, wait for the fire department, be loyal.

As for your insults, your claims that my post was "incendiary," you can't handle the truth.

--Tim May



To: Mary Cluney who wrote (143493)9/17/2001 7:55:01 AM
From: Amy J  Read Replies (3) | Respond to of 186894
 
Mary, RE: "Bin Laden would have to find a few thousand people who are willing to commit suicide"

Maybe this comment is a clue to the "why".

"Why" are so many people willing to commit suicide here? This wasn't just one crazy person, this was an entire group of people, a symptomatic problem. What is wrong with our foreign policy that an entire group of people would feel so hopeless in life and commit suicide and kill others?

Maybe the answer is something along the lines of educating people, giving them purpose, and giving them hope.

The enemy to terrorist Bin Laden could be ensuring that the people in this world have hope.

Education and jobs give people hope to create a better life, a future, a better lifestyle.

(I used to think that funding countries overseas was a potentially risky thing for the US to do to itself, but I now may make a 180 degree change in opinion. Maybe that's what is needed. Investment to create opportunities that drives economies so people have hope.)

Maybe terrorists are like street thugs that come out if they don't have hope and aren't kept busy being productively employed.

Regards,
Amy J