To: Jill who wrote (123 ) 10/27/2001 6:34:03 PM From: RocketMan Read Replies (1) | Respond to of 827 Another "shift" in policy--this bug ain't so easy to kill--this 'garden variety' stuff--they're talking 2 or 3 antibiotics at a time: We don't have a lot of experience with treating inhalation anthrax, and it appears the CDC is itself groping for the most effective combination of drugs. This is a very rare disease in nature, the vast majority of those who got it were wool workers, and even there the incidence was pretty low. The vaccine, created in the 50's and approved in the 70's, was only given to a few thousand people, and the DoD faced a lot of controversy with their plans to vaccinate Desert Storm troops. On the antibiotics, I found references to the original study done at Fort Dietrich, involving a number of monkeys who were made to inhale anthrax spores only 1 or a few microns wide (poor monkeys). The purpose of the study was to test the effectiveness of combinations of the vaccine and antibiotics. They divided the monkeys into six groups that got various combinations, either control (a saline placebo), the vaccine by itself, antibiotics alone (three types, penicillin, doxy, or cipro) and a combination of vaccine and antibiotic. After a month, they found that the antibiotics were effective while they were administered, but once they stopped the disease came back in some cases. The anthrax spores are pretty resilient, and can hide out until the medicines are gone (similar to some other diseases). Of the monkeys on penicillin, 30% died after treatment was stopped. For doxy or cipro, 10% died after treatment was stopped. Those on both vaccine and doxy all survived. Keep in mind that this was a controlled study, and treatment was started within 24 hours of exposure, who knows what the death rate would have been with delays. Also, we don't know how those animal studies translate to humans. This tells me that even with antibiotics, and/or if there is a delay between exposure and treatment, a single treatment may still have a substantial death rate after it is stopped. This may be why they are trying a combination of antibiotics, though I don't know if the monkey tests included that. P.S. I wonder if we have any medical people who can comment on this. Maybe it's difficult for them, due to liability issues.