To: Dan3 who wrote (148657 ) 11/17/2001 3:25:21 PM From: wanna_bmw Respond to of 186894 Dan, Re: "Intel has been able to sell its processors for roughly twice the price AMD was charging for the past few years, with Intel's fastest chip always selling for around $1,000. Pricewatch would seem to indicate that Intel has been flooding the market recently, not that they are in shortage" Two comments: First, AMD has confirmed that they will again post a loss for the fourth quarter. Last quarter, they shipped 7.7 million units, and with an ASP of $60, that gave them $467 million in revenue (actual figure from balance sheet, not result from calc). If you are correct, and ASPs are on the rise, one would think that they can at least get back to the days when they had a $75 ASP. If they sell the same record breaking 7.7 million units at $75 ASP, they would be making $110 million more than they did last quarter, which would result in a non-loss. AMD predicts a loss, which should tell you either that they are selling a very small portion of Athlon XP processors (thus not raising ASPs as much), or they are selling less processors over all (thus not hitting record volumes). Therefore, I think that AMD is desperate for breaking even, or at least losing less, and therefore they are pricing their parts higher, but at the loss of market share. Second, Intel's lower prices are the result of their October price cuts, but in retrospect, it seems they have overshot their intentions. Demand became so large, that they ran into short supplies. After realizing this, they couldn't exactly raise prices, so you see the current price drops in place. However, quoting from the top of the list on Pricewatch, as I've mentioned, is a bad idea, since the first page of vendors are usually participants in the "grey market", which always tends to get CPUs at a discount. If you look at the second page of prices on pricewatch, you get a different story. $424 - Pentium 4 2.0GHz $279 - Pentium 4 1.9GHz $264 - Athlon XP 1900 1.6GHZ $228 - Pentium 4 1.8GHz $202 - Athlon XP 1800 1.53GHZ $186 - Pentium 4 1.7GHz $151 - Athlon XP 1700 1.47GHZ $173 - Pentium 4 1.6GHz $123 - Athlon XP 1600 1.40GHZ $159 - Pentium 4 1.5GHz $122 - Athlon XP 1500 1.33GHZ $118 - Pentium 4 1.4GHz $121 - Athlon 1.4GHz $104 - Athlon 1.33GHz If you compare it to Intel's and AMD's official price lists, you'll see that there is clearly not an oversupply issue (Intel is not flooding the market). AMD processors are selling at a small discount, though, but much less than is usual for them. 2 GHz w/ 256k cache (.18) $401 1.90 GHz w/ 256k cache (.18) $273 1.80 GHz w/ 256k cache (.18) $225 1.70 GHz w/ 256k cache (.18) $193 1.60 GHz w/ 256k cache (.18) $163 1.50 GHz w/ 256k cache (.18) $133 1.40 GHz w/ 256k cache (.18) $133 1900+ $269 1800+ $223 1700+ $190 1600+ $160 1500+ $130 Re: "Has enough of the buying public really figured out that P4 performance is (per MHZ) awful and not to be trusted? " Not at all. Almost every OEM or retail vendor I see has AMD's megahertz listed with the system. This should indicate to you that people are very much interested in the megahertz, and are not willing to just display AMD's model numbers by themselves. wbmw