SI
SI
discoversearch

We've detected that you're using an ad content blocking browser plug-in or feature. Ads provide a critical source of revenue to the continued operation of Silicon Investor.  We ask that you disable ad blocking while on Silicon Investor in the best interests of our community.  If you are not using an ad blocker but are still receiving this message, make sure your browser's tracking protection is set to the 'standard' level.
Politics : Foreign Affairs Discussion Group -- Ignore unavailable to you. Want to Upgrade?


To: tekboy who wrote (11765)11/27/2001 10:36:25 PM
From: Frederick Langford  Read Replies (1) | Respond to of 281500
 
Nov 22nd 2001 | KABUL
From The Economist print edition

Chilling evidence in the ruins of Kabul

AMERICAN officials increasingly believe the anthrax attacks since September 11th were not carried out by
people connected to al-Qaeda, but may have been the work of a lone American madman. To avert future attacks,
though, perhaps they should look harder.

They might start, for example, in a nondescript house in the wealthiest district of Kabul, where a Pakistani NGO
called Ummah Tameer-e-Nau (UTN) once had its offices. UTN's president is Bashiruddin Mahmood, one of
Pakistan's leading nuclear scientists and a specialist in plutonium technology. Last month Mr Mahmood was
arrested by the Pakistani authorities and interrogated on his links to the Taliban, with whom he has had frequent
contact for, he insists, humanitarian reasons. Mr Mahmood was released again soon afterwards. The Taliban has
denied any “abnormal” links between Mr Mahmood and Mr bin Laden, and he himself says he has never met the
man.

In public, UTN helped Afghans with flourmills, school textbooks and road-upgrading schemes. But its offices
suggest that this may have been a cover for something far more sinister. According to their neighbours, the
Pakistanis who lived and worked there fled Kabul along with the Taliban, but the evidence they left behind suggests
that they were working on a plan to build an anthrax bomb.

An upstairs room of the house had been used as a workshop. What appeared to be a Russian rocket had been
disassembled, and a canister labelled “helium” had been left on the worktop. On the floor were multiple copies of
documents about anthrax downloaded from the Internet, and details about the American army's vaccination plans
for its troops. The number of copies suggests that seminars were also taking place there.

One of the downloaded documents featured a small picture of the former American defence secretary, William
Cohen, holding a five-pound bag of sugar. It noted that he was doing this “to show the amount of the biological
weapon anthrax that could destroy half the population of Washington, DC.”

On the floor was a small bag of white powder, which this correspondent decided not to inspect. It may have
contained nothing more deadly than icing sugar, but that could be useful for experiments in how to scatter powder
containing anthrax spores from a great height over a city, or to show students how to do this. The living room
contained two boxes of gas masks and filters.

On a desk was a cassette box labelled “Jihad”, with the name of Osama bin Laden hand-written along the spine.
Most chilling of all, however, were the mass of calculations and drawings in felt pen that filled up a white board of
the sort used in classrooms. There were several designs for a long thin balloon, something like a weather balloon,
with lines and arrows indicating a suggested height of 10km (33,000 feet). There was also a sketch of a jet fighter
flying towards the balloon alongside the words: “Your days are limited! Bang.” This, like the documents, was
written in English.

Since UTN was run by one of Pakistan's top scientists, a man with close links to the Taliban and, it is said, close
ideological affinities with Mr bin Laden, the circumstantial evidence points to only one conclusion. Whoever fled
this house when the Taliban fell was working on a plan to build a helium-powered balloon bomb carrying anthrax.
Whether it was detonated with a timer or shot down by a fighter, the result would have been the same: the
showering of deadly airborne anthrax spores over an area as wide as half of New York city or Washington, DC.

After the September 11th attacks, it was generally agreed that western intelligence agencies had failed
through lack of “human intelligence”—men on the ground, as opposed to spy satellites and computers
monitoring phone calls and e-mails. This failure was to be rectified. Yet since the fall of Kabul on
November 13th, journalists have been fanning out across the city. They have stripped houses such as this
one, and others directly connected to the al-Qaeda network, of all sorts of documents and other valuable
evidence. These have included the names and addresses of al-Qaeda contacts in the West. For the West's
intelligence agencies, September 11th was Black Tuesday. There may be no words with which to describe
their failure in the week since the fall of Kabul.

economist.com