To: fingolfen who wrote (150149 ) 11/28/2001 4:07:09 PM From: GVTucker Read Replies (1) | Respond to of 186894 fingolfen, RE: I've seen quoted comments, but I haven't seen his "report." Nor do I understand how he is collecting data and analyzing that data to generate the report. Without those facts, my skepticism remains. Do you have any more information? One big reason why I posted this on the board is that I wanted to know if his use of the data is right. That is debatable. The other very large key here is the source of the data. All Chen refers to is his "industry sources". One big reason why I'm taking this a little more seriously than I normally would take an analyst's opinion is because he was accurate and early in earlier statements about a very strong October, using this raw material indicator. Here's the introductory paragraph to the report. I'd just as soon not transcribe the whole thing, and I'd imagine that JP Morgan would rather I not, too.Our industry sources indicate that Intel's demand for both raw wafers and photoresist peaked in September and dropped off in October and November. [bold face theirs] Recall that raw wafer and photoresist demand can be a leading indicator of the company's output by roughly four to six weeks, because it typically takes an average of four to six weeks for the wafers to flow through the fabs and complete the manufacturing process. Thus, the decline in raw wafer and photoresist demand in October and November indicates weak shipments are likely in November and December. This is very different from average seasonal behavior, which is characterized by a 25% sequential decline in October, 7% sequential increase in November, and 13% increase in December.