SI
SI
discoversearch

We've detected that you're using an ad content blocking browser plug-in or feature. Ads provide a critical source of revenue to the continued operation of Silicon Investor.  We ask that you disable ad blocking while on Silicon Investor in the best interests of our community.  If you are not using an ad blocker but are still receiving this message, make sure your browser's tracking protection is set to the 'standard' level.
Politics : Foreign Affairs Discussion Group -- Ignore unavailable to you. Want to Upgrade?


To: Ilaine who wrote (17432)1/28/2002 1:38:43 PM
From: Math Junkie  Read Replies (2) | Respond to of 281500
 
"IOW, the one thing that angers the Palestinians the most is Jewish settlements in the West Bank - and this has been the case for a couple of decades. So why do they continue?"

Good question. I'm really looking forward to seeing some answers to that.



To: Ilaine who wrote (17432)1/28/2002 1:43:14 PM
From: Ilaine  Read Replies (4) | Respond to of 281500
 
Interesting Israeli web site devoted to publicizing human rights abuses by Israelis against Palestinians in the occupied territories.

btselem.org

It's apparently credible, as I found it via the Mitchell Report.
usinfo.state.gov

Principle findings from one report:

"The principle findings of B'Tselem's report are as follows:

Israel uses excessive and disproportionate force in dispersing
demonstrations of unarmed Palestinians;

Israel did not develop non-lethal methods to disperse demonstrations
or train its soldiers to confront such demonstrations. This in spite of the
fact that Israel was prepared for the events of the past few weeks. As a
result, soldiers only had at their disposal rubber-coated metal bullets and
live ammunition, which caused many Palestinian casualties, and many
injuries to medical teams and journalists.

Collective punishment, in the form of Israel's severe restrictions on
Palestinians' movement in the Occupied Territories, makes life
unbearable for hundreds of thousands with no justification. These
restrictions are also imposed on medical teams and ambulances.

Curfew is imposed on tens of thousands of people for the convenience
of settlers (in Hebron, Hawara and Silat a-Daher), constituting blatant
discrimination. Such a severe injury to a large population, for the welfare
of another population, represents a grave human rights violation.

Over the past few weeks there have been many incidents of settler
attacks on Palestinians. In some of these incidents, IDF soldiers were
present but did nothing to protect Palestinians, as they are obliged to do
as the occupying force. This phenomenon is not new, and B'Tselem has
warned in the past that Israeli authorities do not take sufficient measures
to end this phenomenon.

The Palestinian Authority does not make serious efforts to prevent
children from participating in demonstrations, in spite of the grave
danger.

The Palestinian Authority does almost nothing to prevent Palestinians
from attacking Israeli civilians. The establishment of settlements is a
violation of international law and therefore illegal; however, this does not
justify attacks on settlers or on settlements. Intentional attacks on
civilians are absolutely prohibited, regardless of the circumstances.

The Palestinian Authority does not prevent armed Palestinians from
shooting from within populated areas, thereby exposing its civilian
population to the IDF's response.

Both Israel and the Palestinian Authority prevent journalists from freely
covering the events, thereby restricting freedom of speech. This is done
in various ways, including physical attacks and property damage.

In light of B'Tselem's findings, and the scope of the events, B'Tselem
calls for the establishment of an independent and professional,
international commission of inquiry to examine these events. Only such a
commission can conduct a serious investigation of all human rights
violations that have taken place in the past weeks."

btselem.org

Here is one that details how Israeli law enforcement looks the other way when Israeli settlers attack Palestinians:

"Since the beginning of the al-Aqsa intifada, Palestinian civilians have
attacked Israelis throughout the Occupied Territories. Most of these
attacks involved gunfire and/or stone throwing at vehicles and homes.
Intentionally harming civilians is a flagrant violation of international law
and is absolutely prohibited, whatever the circumstances. Although the
settlements violate international law, this does not affect the status and
rights of civilians living there and does not turn them into a legitimate
target for attack. However, acts of violence against Settlers do not
legitimize acts of revenge against innocent Palestinians.

Many of these incidents occurred in broad daylight, sometimes in front of
television cameras. In most cases, the settlers attacked by the tens or
hundreds. Since these attacks follow a distinct pattern, they are
completely predictable. These facts make the inability of Israeli law
enforcement authorities to prevent and control Settler violence of this
kind all the more grave.

These acts of violence occur in the context of the failure of Israeli law
enforcement, which treats settler violence with complacency and
forgiveness. This attitude is among the factors that enable the violence to
continue. Israel also ignores its responsibility, as the occupier of the
Occupied Territories, to protect the safety and well-being of the
population under its control. The testimonies and data collected by
B'Tselem in recent years indicate that Israeli leniency extends to all
aspects and stages of an incident: from the lack of intervention of soldiers
and police present when the attacks take place, through superficial and
incomplete investigations, to light sentences and pardons of the few
settlers convicted of assaulting Palestinians.

For years, officials have severely criticized the bodies charged with law
enforcement in the Occupied Territories: The Karp commission in1982,
the state commission of inquiry investigating the massacre in the Cave of
the Patriarchs in 1994, and recently The State Comptroller, whose
September 2001 report states that Police work in the matter is severely
deficient. In response to a report published by B'Tselem in the matter in
March, Minister Efraim Sneh, said that the system does not deal harshly
enough with rioting settlers.

The fact that top officials are aware of the lack of law enforcement on
violent settlers and still no real change is made in law enforcement policy
shows a blatant disregard of Palestinian lives and property."
btselem.org



To: Ilaine who wrote (17432)1/29/2002 6:41:32 AM
From: SirRealist  Read Replies (1) | Respond to of 281500
 
Very good material; very good questions, CB. It is precisely why the distinction of a higher moral ground remains elusive.