To: Karen Lawrence who wrote (2444 ) 2/7/2002 1:47:24 AM From: Mephisto Respond to of 5185 Taxing Enron's code of ethics Editorials oregonlive.com 02/06/02 The daily question with Enron isn't whether it stretched and bent every law to its limits, but which one and how far. The latest twist revolves around whether any of the $357 million set aside for federal taxes by Portland General Electric was sent by its parent Enron to the federal government. Oregon ratepayers who are angry about high electricity rates now have some evidence that not everything about those rates came from the gyrations of a free market. A watchdog group's analysis of Enron's financial reports couldn't find evidence of any tax payments for the past four years. Enron disputes that characterization, saying it paid $171 million in taxes between 1998 and 2000. Even if Enron's version is true, at least half of the money earmarked for PGE's taxes, and paid by Oregon ratepayers, ended up in Enron's pockets. That ought to raise hackles at the Oregon Public Utility Commission. Oregon may be able to solve this by rewriting its regulations regarding subsidiary utility companies such as PGE. When parent companies manage to save money by playing local profits off against losses elsewhere, local ratepayers ought to share in the savings. It won't be as simple as it sounds, of course, because regulators must also try to shield local ratepayers from cost increases generated by parent companies. In the meantime, though, the PUC should pursue the ratepayers' interests in this particular case, either by pressing PGE for a refund or by considering the issue in the context of approving the proposed merger between PGE and Northwest Natural. The PUC is holding hearings for public comment on the proposed merger today at the Salem Public Library, 585 Liberty St. and Thursday at the Midland branch of the Multnomah County Library at 805 S.E. 122nd Ave. in Portland. Both meetings begin at 7 p.m. The commisson should expect an earful. In the aftermath of the Enron scandal, widespread speculation about market manipulation has Oregon ratepayers questioning whether the last round of rate increases was justified. That's a good question -- and one the PUC should be asking itself. And if consumers don't start getting some satisfactory answers, the calls for unraveling energy deregulation could get a lot louder. oregonlive.com