Corrections for the "completed" Release 99 continued
==========
6.8 Proposed changes on 25.306
CRs to 25.306
R2-020295 Revised CR 031 to 25.306 on Introduction of interim test marker within UE radio access capabilities <CR 032 Rel-4> (Ericsson)
Himke van der Velde (Ericsson) presented this CR.
Discussion: It was not clear from the text what was meant if the UE was not fully tested. According to GCF the term 'minimum' was better than 'interim'. There should also be a reference to a 3GPP document (it was the intention of TSG-T WG1 to include the current Excel sheet maintained by one company in a TSG-T WG1 TR). It was explained that the bit of the interim test marker would be 'reserved' in Rel-4, so that it was only valid for R'99. In TSG-RAN plenary, there would be joint session with TSG-T to discuss allocation of responsibilities and other open issues. If an alternative could be found for "protocol release indicator" (as Layer 1 was also covered), suggestions were welcome. The CR needed to be split into two to separate the protocol release indicator from the interim test marker.
Decision: An update of the CR was needed. The update would be in R2-020412. The other CR would be CR 033 in R2-020413.
R2-020412 Technically endorsed CR 031r1 to 25.306 on Introduction of interim test marker within UE radio access capabilities <CR 032 Rel-4> (Ericsson)
Denis Fauconnier (Chairman) presented this CR.
Discussion: The category should be C (but this was a request from TSG-RAN plenary). Hans van der Veen (Secretary) would correct this.
Decision: The CR was technically endorsed. R2-020540 would contain the Rel-4 shadow CR.
R2-020540 Technically endorsed CR 031r1 to 25.306 on Introduction of interim test marker within UE radio access capabilities <CR 032 Rel-4> (Ericsson)
Decision: The CR was technically endorsed.
6.9 Proposed changes on 25.321
R2-020347 Discussion document on additional TFCS selection guidelines (Qualcomm)
Hector Vayanos (Qualcomm) presented this document.
Discussion: The UE behaviour should be described correctly. There could be a note in the specification. The proponent commented that padding was not sufficient and proposed additional guidelines. Guidelines were not sufficient to avoid a UE crash though. Specifications in TSG-T WG1 should also be reviewed.
Decision: The document was noted.
CRs to 25.321
R2-020327 Revised CR 102 to 25.321 on Clarification on ciphering <CR 103 Rel-4> (Ericsson)
Johan Torsner (Ericsson) presented this CR.
Discussion: The downlink was already covered in the current specification, but uplink not yet. Some rewording was proposed.
Decision: With these changes, the CR was agreed. The update would be in R2-020451 (R'99) and R2-020452 would contain the Rel-4 shadow CR.
R2-020451 Agreed CR 102r1 to 25.321 on Clarification on ciphering <CR 103 Rel-4> (Ericsson)
R2-020452 Agreed CR 103 [Rel-4 shadow] to 25.321 on Clarification on ciphering (Ericsson)
Decision: The CRs were agreed.
R2-020342 Agreed CR 105 to 25.321 on TDD MAC Layer Subchannel Assignment <CR 106 Rel-4> (InterDigital)
Steve Terry (InterDigital) presented this CR.
Discussion: The change would not be required for 1.28 Mcps TDD, so the shadow CR would be a little different.
Decision: The CR was agreed. R2-020414 would contain the Rel-4 shadow CR.
R2-020414 Agreed CR 106 to 25.321 [Rel-4 shadow] on TDD MAC Layer Subchannel Assignment (InterDigital)
Decision: The CR was agreed.
R2-020343 Revised CR 107 to 25.321 on RACH Transmission Control Clarification <CR 108 Rel-4> (InterDigital)
Steve Terry (InterDigital) presented this CR.
Discussion: There was concern that this was not what had been intended with persistency. Several delegates had different understanding of the MAC operation. The reason for the CR was that if the higher ASC is blocked, lower ASC partitions cannot be used. Concurrent data on the RACH for multiple radio bearers was something that seemed not to have been taken into account in the specifications. After some consideration it was felt that this was in a way an optimisation. If that was the case, it was doubtful it should be done for R'99. Because of in-sequence delivery a revision of the CR was needed in any case if it was decided to do this. It was proposed to put in a note to show the problem, but not make any change.
Decision: An update of the CR was needed. The update would be in R2-020415.
R2-020415 Withdrawn CR 107r1 to 25.321 on RACH Transmission Control Clarification <CR 108 Rel-4> (InterDigital)
This document was withdrawn.
R2-020363 Revised CR 109 to 25.321 on Missing DTCH channel type in UE-ID Type Indicator <CR 110 Rel-4> (Motorola)
This document was revised by R2-020420.
R2-020420 Agreed CR 109r1 to 25.321 on Missing DTCH channel type in UE-ID Type Indicator <CR 110 Rel-4> (Motorola)
Wilson Wong (Motorola) presented this CR.
Decision: The CR was agreed. R2-020449 would contain the Rel-4 shadow CR.
R2-020449 Agreed CR 110 to 25.321 [Rel-4 shadow] on Missing DTCH channel type in UE-ID Type Indicator <CR 110 Rel-4> (Motorola)
Decision: The CR was agreed.
R2-020403 Revised CR 111 to 25.321 on Correction on UE Id for DSCH <CR 112 Rel-4> (Nortel Networks)
Tania Le Goff (Nortel Networks) presented this CR.
Discussion: The CR introduced an error that needed to be corrected.
Decision: With these changes, the CR was agreed. The update would be in R2-020453 (R'99) and R2-020454 would contain the Rel-4 shadow CR.
R2-020453 Agreed CR 111r1 to 25.321 on Correction on UE Id for DSCH <CR 112 Rel-4> (Nortel Networks)
R2-020454 Agreed CR 112 to 25.321 [Rel-4 shadow] on Correction on UE Id for DSCH (Nortel Networks)
Decision: The CRs were agreed.
R2-020503 Withdrawn CR 111r2 to 25.321 on Correction on UE Id for DSCH <CR 112 Rel-4> (InterDigital)
This document was withdrawn.
R2-020505 Agreed CR 113 to 25.321 on UE undefined behaviour when padding is required <CR 114 Rel-4> (Qualcomm)
Hector Vayanos (Qualcomm) presented this CR.
Decision: The CR was agreed. R2-020577 would contain the Rel-4 shadow CR.
R2-020577 Agreed CR 114 to 25.321 [Rel-4 shadow] on UE undefined behaviour when padding is required (Qualcomm)
Decision: The CR was agreed.
6.10 Proposed changes on 25.322
CRs to 25.322
R2-020354 Postponed CR 168r2 to 25.322 on Detailed definition of the meaning of inequalities <CR 169 Rel-4> (Philips)
Some comments were made offline and should be taken into account.
Decision: The CR was postponed.
R2-020236 Revised CR 171 to 25.322 on Clarification on MRW SUFI and SDU discard with explicit signalling procedure <CR 172 Rel-4> (ASUSTeK Computer Inc.)
This document was revised by R2-020406.
R2-020406 Revised CR 171r1 to 25.322 on Clarification on MRW SUFI and SDU discard with explicit signalling procedure <CR 172 Rel-4> (ASUSTeK Computer Inc.)
Sam Jiang (ASUSTeK Computer Inc.) presented this CR.
Discussion: The word 'optionally' would be removed.
Decision: With these changes, the CR was agreed. The update would be in R2-020586 (R'99) and R2-020587 would contain the Rel-4 shadow CR.
R2-020586 Agreed CR 171r2 to 25.322 on Clarification on MRW SUFI and SDU discard with explicit signalling procedure <CR 172 Rel-4> (ASUSTeK Computer Inc.)
R2-020587 Agreed CR 172 to 25.322 [Rel-4 shadow] on Clarification on MRW SUFI and SDU discard with explicit signalling procedure (ASUSTeK Computer Inc.)
Decision: The CR was agreed.
R2-020296 Revised CR 175 to 25.322 on SDU discard termination <CR 176 Rel-4> (Ericsson)
Johan Torsner (Ericsson) presented this CR.
Discussion: This corrected an error introduced in the rewriting of the RLC. There were a few comments.
Decision: With these changes, the CR was agreed. The update would be in R2-020584 (R'99) and R2-020585 would contain the Rel-4 shadow CR.
R2-020584 Agreed CR 175r1 to 25.322 on SDU discard termination <CR 176 Rel-4> (Ericsson)
R2-020585 Agreed CR 176 to 25.322 [Rel-4 shadow] on SDU discard termination (Ericsson)
Decision: The CRs were agreed.
R2-020349 Withdrawn CR 177 to 25.322 on Avoidance of Data Loss in RLC AM Entities <CR 178 Rel-4> (Nokia)
This document was withdrawn.
R2-020418 Revised CR 179 to 25.322 on Initial value of VT(US) <CR 180 Rel-4> (LG Electronics Inc., NTT DoCoMo)
SeungJune Yi (LG Electronics Inc.) presented this CR.
Discussion: The "may not be 0" should be revised.
Decision: With these changes, the CR was agreed. The update would be in R2-020436 (R'99) and R2-020437 would contain the Rel-4 shadow CR.
R2-020436 Agreed CR 179r1 to 25.322 on Initial value of VT(US) <CR 180 Rel-4> (LG Electronics Inc., NTT DoCoMo)
R2-020437 Agreed CR 180 to 25.322 [Rel-4 shadow] on Initial value of VT(US) (LG Electronics Inc., NTT DoCoMo)
Decision: The CRs were agreed.
6.11 Proposed changes on 25.323
CRs to 25.323
R2-020235 Withdrawn CR 040 to 25.323 on Meaning of version fields for full header packet type in RFC2507 <CR 041 Rel-4> (Huawei)
Ping Zhang (Huawei) presented this CR.
Discussion: The change was not needed. The information could be found in a different manner.
Decision: The CR was withdrawn.
R2-020237 Revised CR 042 to 25.323 on Clarification on PDCP sequence numbering <CR 043 Rel-4> (ASUSTeK Computer Inc.)
This document was revised by R2-020411.
R2-020411 Agreed CR 042r1 to 25.323 on Clarification on PDCP sequence numbering <CR 043 Rel-4> (ASUSTeK Computer Inc.)
Sam Jiang (ASUSTeK Computer Inc.) presented this CR.
Decision: The CR was agreed. R2-020588 would contain the Rel-4 shadow CR.
R2-020588 Agreed CR 043 to 25.323 [Rel-4 shadow] on Clarification on PDCP sequence numbering (ASUSTeK Computer Inc.)
Decision: The CR was agreed.
6.12 Proposed changes on 25.324
R2-020314 Discusson on message encoding (Siemens)
This document was postponed.
CRs to 25.324
R2-020315 Postponed CR 008 to 25.324 on Clarification on message encoding <CR 009 Rel-4> (Siemens)
Decision: The CR was postponed.
6.13 Proposed changes on 25.331
R2-020425 Proposal to make procedural text in RRC more readable (MCC)
Hans van der Veen (Secretary) presented this document.
Discussion: There were ambiguities already in the current specification, which only became more clear by the numbering.
Decision: The document was noted. The proposal was agreed. Hans van der Veen (Secretary) would provide a CR applied to all of RRC for the plenary. That CR (CR 1363 for R'99 in R2-020591 and Rel-4 shadow CR 1364 in R2-020592) was considered agreed. Ravi Kuchibhotla (Motorola) would draft a CR 040 to 25.921 inR2-020537.
R2-020450 Ciphering for TM in case of hard handover (Alcatel)
Patrick Fischer (Alcatel) presented this document.
Decision: The document was noted. For hard handover case latest sent START value would be used. This would be included in the LS to be sent to TSG-SA WG3.
R2-020401 Ciphering of TM RBs at timing re-initialised hard handover (Ericsson)
Based on the discussion on R2-020450, this document was no longer needed.
CRs to 25.331
R2-020254 Withdrawn CR 1226 to 25.331 on Clarification of UE behaviour upon reception of reconfiguration messages <CR 1227 Rel-4> (Siemens)
This document was withdrawn.
R2-020258 Revised CR 1228 to 25.331 on Constant value range correction for DPCH and PUSCH in TDD mode <CR 1229 Rel-4> (IP Wireless)
Tim Speight (IP Wireless) presented this CR.
Discussion: The proposal as it was affected FDD and was not isolated impact. It should be corrected, but with isolated impact, by using the offset.
Decision: An update of the CR was needed. The update would be in R2-020455.
R2-020455 Agreed CR 1228r1 to 25.331 on Constant value range correction for DPCH and PUSCH in TDD mode <CR 1229 Rel-4> (IP Wireless)
Tim Speight (IP Wireless) presented this CR.
Decision: The CR was agreed. R2-020541 would contain the Rel-4 shadow CR.
R2-020541 Agreed CR 1228r2 to 25.331 on Constant value range correction for DPCH and PUSCH in TDD mode <CR 1229 Rel-4> (IP Wireless)
Decision: The CR was agreed.
R2-020259 Agreed CR 1230 to 25.331 on Corrections to open loop power control for TDD and RB information parameters for SHCCH <CR 1231 Rel-4> (IP Wireless)
Tim Speight (IP Wireless) presented this CR.
Decision: The CR was agreed. R2-020456 would contain the Rel-4 shadow CR.
R2-020456 Agreed CR 1231 to 25.331 [Rel-4 shadow] on Corrections to open loop power control for TDD and RB information parameters for SHCCH (IP Wireless)
Decision: The CR was agreed.
R2-020260 Revised CR 1232 to 25.331 on Removal of unnecessary replication of TFCS ID in Physical Shared Channel Allocation message <CR 1233 Rel-4> (IP Wireless)
Tim Speight (IP Wireless) presented this CR.
Discussion: There was one very unlikely case that needed to be removed.
Decision: With this change, the CR was agreed. The update would be in R2-020457 (R'99) and R2-020458 would contain the Rel-4 shadow CR.
R2-020457 Agreed CR 1232r1 to 25.331 on Removal of unnecessary replication of TFCS ID in Physical Shared Channel Allocation message <CR 1233 Rel-4> (IP Wireless)
R2-020458 Agreed CR 1233 to 25.331 [Rel-4] on Removal of unnecessary replication of TFCS ID in Physical Shared Channel Allocation message (IP Wireless)
Decision: The CRs were agreed.
R2-020264 Revised CR 1235 to 25.331 on Removal of SSDT from R99 <no CR Rel-4 needed> (Nortel Networks)
Claudiu Mihailescu (Nortel Networks) presented this CR.
Discussion: It was commented that the behaviour should be left unspecified to avoid penalising UEs that had already implemented SSDT. Some of the changes were not needed. The best would be to say that UTRAN should not send the information and leave most of the text as is. More comments were made that would be taken into account.
Decision: An update of the CR was needed. The update would be in R2-020459.
R2-020459 Agreed CR 1235r1 to 25.331 on Removal of SSDT from R99 <no CR Rel-4 needed> (Nortel Networks)
Denis Fauconnier (Nortel Networks) presented this CR.
Decision: The CR was agreed. There was no need for a shadow CR for Rel-4!
R2-020265 Agreed CR 1236 to 25.331 on Correction to TF selection when using UL RLC TM <CR 1237 Rel-4> (Nortel Networks)
Claudiu Mihailescu (Nortel Networks) presented this CR.
Discussion: There was some discussion whether there should be a Rel-4 shadow CR (there should be).
Decision: The CR was agreed. R2-020460 would contain the Rel-4 shadow CR.
R2-020460 Agreed CR 1237 to 25.331 on Correction to TF selection when using UL RLC TM <CR 1237 Rel-4> (Nortel Networks)
Decision: The CR was agreed.
R2-020266 Revised CR 1238 to 25.331 on Correction to the UE behaviour at reception of the IE Downlink counter synchronisation info <CR 1239 Rel-4> (Nortel Networks)
This document was revised by R2-020368.
R2-020368 Revised CR 1238r1 to 25.331 on Correction to the UE behaviour at reception of the IE Downlink counter synchronisation info <CR 1239 Rel-4> (Nortel Networks)
Tania Le Goff (Nortel Networks) presented this CR.
Discussion: There were a number of comments that would be taken into account.
Decision: An update of the CR was needed. The update would be in R2-020441.
R2-020441 Revised CR 1238r2 to 25.331 on Correction to the UE behaviour in case of SRNS relocation <CR 1239 Rel-4> (Nortel Networks, Alcatel)
Tania Le Goff (Nortel Networks) presented this CR.
Discussion: There were several comments. The cover sheet couldbe improved.
Decision: With these changes, the CR was agreed. The update would be in R2-020542 (R'99) and R2-020543 would contain the Rel-4 shadow CR.
R2-020542 Agreed CR 1238r3 to 25.331 on Correction to the UE behaviour in case of SRNS relocation <CR 1239 Rel-4> (Nortel Networks, Alcatel)
R2-020543 Agreed CR 1239 to 25.331 [Rel-4 shadow] on Correction to the UE behaviour in case of SRNS relocation (Nortel Networks, Alcatel)
Decision: The CRs were agreed.
R2-020267 Agreed CR 1240 to 25.331 on Header Compression protocols re-initialisation during SRNS Relocation <CR 1241 Rel-4> (Nortel Networks)
Tania Le Goff (Nortel Networks) presented this CR.
Decision: The CR was agreed. R2-020544 would contain the Rel-4 shadow CR.
R2-020544 Agreed CR 1241 to 25.331 [Rel-4 shadow] on Header Compression protocols re-initialisation during SRNS Relocation (Nortel Networks)
Decision: The CR was agreed.
R2-020268 Revised CR 1242 to 25.331 on Misalignments between tabular and ASN.1 related to UE Positioning <CR 1243 Rel-4> (Nortel Networks)
This document was revised by R2-020421.
R2-020421 Agreed CR 1242r1 to 25.331 on Misalignments between tabular and ASN.1 related to UE Positioning <CR 1243 Rel-4> (Nortel Networks)
Claudiu Mihailescu (Nortel Networks) presented this CR.
Decision: The CR was agreed. R2-020545 would contain the Rel-4 shadow CR.
R2-020545 Agreed CR 1243 to 25.331 [Rel-4 shadow] on Misalignments between tabular and ASN.1 related to UE Positioning <CR 1243 Rel-4> (Nortel Networks)
Decision: The CR was agreed.
R2-020271 Agreed CR 1244 to 25.331 on Corrections to comments in ASN.1 <CR 1245 Rel-4> (Nokia)
Tim Norris (Nokia) presented this CR.
Discussion: The existing CRs should also follow this approach.
Decision: The CR was agreed. R2-020461 would contain the Rel-4 shadow CR.
R2-020461 Agreed CR 1245 to 25.331 [Rel-4 shadow] on Corrections to comments in ASN.1 (Nokia)
Decision: The CR was agreed.
R2-020272 Agreed CR 1246 to 25.331 on Correction to restarting of T308 <CR 1247 Rel-4> (Nokia)
Tim Norris (Nokia) presented this CR.
Decision: The CR was agreed. R2-020462 would contain the Rel-4 shadow CR.
R2-020462 Agreed CR 1247 to 25.331 [Rel-4 shadow] on Correction to restarting of T308 (Nokia)
Decision: The CR was agreed.
R2-020273 Revised CR 1248 to 25.331 on Clarification of the use of T309 during inter-RAT cell reselections <CR 1249 Rel-4> (Nokia)
Tim Norris (Nokia) presented this CR.
Discussion: There were several comments.
Decision: An update of the CR was needed. The update would be in R2-020464.
R2-020464 Replaced CR 1248r1 to 25.331 on Clarification of the use of T309 during inter-RAT cell reselections <CR 1249 Rel-4> (Nokia)
Tim Norris (Nokia) presented this CR.
Discussion: There were some editorial changes needed.
Decision: With these changes, the CR was agreed. The update would be in R2-020560 (R'99) and R2-020561 would contain the Rel-4 shadow CR.
R2-020560 Agreed CR 1248r2 to 25.331 on Clarification of the use of T309 during inter-RAT cell reselections <CR 1249 Rel-4> (Nokia)
R2-020561 Agreed CR 1249 to 25.331 [Rel-4 shadow] on Clarification of the use of T309 during inter-RAT cell reselections (Nokia)
Decision: The CRs were agreed.
R2-020274 Agreed CR 1250 to 25.331 on Measurement Corrections <CR 1251 Rel-4> (Nokia)
Thomas Balon (Nokia) presented this CR.
Decision: The CR was agreed. R2-020465 would contain the Rel-4 shadow CR.
R2-020465 Agreed CR 1251 to 25.331 [Rel-4 shadow] on Measurement Corrections
Decision: The CR was agreed.
R2-020275 Revised CR 1252 to 25.331 on Existence of TFCI bits <CR 1253 Rel-4> (Nokia)
Juha Mikola (Nokia) presented this CR.
Discussion: This change was not needed, but a note would be added.
Decision: With these changes, the CR was agreed. The update would be in R2-020466 (R'99) and R2-020467 would contain the Rel-4 shadow CR.
R2-020466 Agreed CR 1252r1 to 25.331 on Existence of TFCI bits <CR 1253 Rel-4> (Nokia)
R2-020467 Agreed CR 1253 to 25.331 [Rel-4 shadow] on Existence of TFCI bits (Nokia)
Decision: The CRs were agreed.
R2-020285 Revised CR 1257 to 25.331 on Corrections of inconsistency between procedural description, tabular and ASN.1 <CR 1258 Rel-4> (Motorola)
Wilson Wong (Motorola) presented this CR.
Discussion: The change needed to be done in 13.7 also. The isolated impact statement needed to be updated.
Decision: With these changes, the CR was agreed. The update would be in R2-020468 (R'99) and R2-020469 would contain the Rel-4 shadow CR.
R2-020468 Agreed CR 1257r1 to 25.331 on Corrections of inconsistency between procedural description, tabular and ASN.1 <CR 1258 Rel-4> (Motorola)
R2-020469 Agreed CR 1258 to 25.331 [Rel-4 shadow] on Corrections of inconsistency between procedural description, tabular and ASN.1 (Motorola)
Decision: The CRs were agreed.
R2-020286 Revised CR 1259 to 25.331 on Corrections to Expiration Time Factor and Expiration Time formula for SIB 7 and SIB 14 <CR 1260 Rel-4> (Motorola)
Wilson Wong (Motorola) presented this CR.
Discussion: The ASN.1 needed to be modified (carefully).
Decision: With these changes, the CR was agreed. The update would be in R2-020471 (R'99) and R2-020472 would contain the Rel-4 shadow CR.
R2-020471 Agreed CR 1259r1 to 25.331 on Corrections to Expiration Time Factor and Expiration Time formula for SIB 7 and SIB 14 <CR 1260 Rel-4> (Motorola)
R2-020472 Agreed CR 1260 to 25.331 [Rel-4 shadow] on Corrections to Expiration Time Factor and Expiration Time formula for SIB 7 and SIB 14 (Motorola)
Decision: The CRs were agreed.
R2-020287 Revised CR 1261 to 25.331 on Corrections to Reporting Cell Status <CR 1262 Rel-4> (Motorola)
Wilson Wong (Motorola) presented this CR.
Discussion: There were some comments, so there was a need for an update.
Decision: An update of the CR was needed. The update would be in R2-020473.
R2-020473 Agreed CR 1261r1 to 25.331 on Corrections to Reporting Cell Status <CR 1262 Rel-4> (Motorola)
Wilson Wong (Motorola) presented this CR.
Decision: The CR was agreed. R2-020562 would contain the Rel-4 shadow CR.
R2-020562 Agreed CR 1262 to 25.331 [Rel-4 shadow] on Corrections to Reporting Cell Status (Motorola)
Decision: The CR was agreed.
R2-020290 Withdrawn CR 1263 to 25.331 on Security at CN domain switch <CR 1264 Rel-4> (Alcatel)
Patrick Fischer (Alcatel) presented this CR.
Discussion: This document was a follow-up of R2-020288. There were several comments on optionality versus mandatoriness. If the IE was always sent, it would be sent twice very often, as normally this procedure would follow RRC CONNECTION SETUP immediately. However, it might be easier anyway. The revised CR would be merged into the big security CR. There were several comments. It was assumed that there would be ciphering on both domains, or none at all.
Decision: With these changes, the CR was agreed. However, the revised CR would be merged into the big security CR (CR 1282/CR 1283) and therefore this CR was withdrawn.
R2-020291 Withdrawn CR 1265 to 25.331 on SRNS relocation in CELL_DCH <CR 1266 Rel-4> (Alcatel)
This document was withdrawn.
R2-020292 Revised CR 1267 to 25.331 on Correction to inter frequency measurements <CR 1268 Rel-4> (Alcatel)
Patrick Fischer (Alcatel) presented this CR.
Discussion: There was a need for additional clarification on the measurement events as it turned out there were different views of what had been meant when the text in the specification on the measurements had been originally written.
Decision: An update of the CR was needed. The update would be in R2-020470.
R2-020470 Revised CR 1267r1 to 25.331 on Correction to inter frequency measurements <CR 1268 Rel-4> (Alcatel)
Patrick Fischer (Alcatel) presented this CR.
Discussion: There was still concern from a few companies. They were taken into account.
Decision: With these changes, the CR was agreed. The update would be in R2-020547 (R'99) and R2-020548 would contain the Rel-4 shadow CR.
R2-020547 Agreed CR 1267r2 to 25.331 on Correction to inter frequency measurements <CR 1268 Rel-4> (Alcatel)
R2-020548 Agreed CR 1268 to 25.331 [Rel-4 shadow] on Correction to inter frequency measurements (Alcatel)
Decision: The CRs were agreed.
R2-020297 Withdrawn CR 1269 to 25.331 on Removal of Power control Algorithm 2 (emulated) from R'99 only <No CR Rel-4 needed> (Qualcomm)
This document was withdrawn (based on the LS from TSG-T WG1 (R2-020423/T1R020060r1)).
R2-020298 Revised CR 1270 to 25.331 on Actions at reception of system information block type 1 <CR 1271> (Ericsson)
Anders Berggren (Ericsson) presented this CR.
Discussion: There was a CR from Motorola (R2-020337, CR 1314) covering some of the same changes plus an additional change. What was already in the CR could be agreed. There would be a merge. It was commented that the wording of the isolated impact analysis was appreciated.
Decision: With these changes, the CR was agreed. The update would be in R2-020474 (R'99) and R2-020475 would contain the Rel-4 shadow CR.
R2-020474 Agreed CR 1270r1 to 25.331 on Actions at reception of system information block type 1 <CR 1271> (Ericsson)
R2-020475 Agreed CR 1271 to 25.331 [Rel-4 shadow] on Actions at reception of system information block type 1 (Ericsson)
Decision: The CRs were agreed.
R2-020299 Revised CR 1272 to 25.331 on Tx diversity and no diversity in the same active set <CR 1273 Rel-4> (Qualcomm)
This document was revised by R2-020382.
R2-020382 Revised CR 1272r1 to 25.331 on Tx diversity and no diversity in the same active set <CR 1273 Rel-4> (Qualcomm)
Francesco Grilli (Qualcomm) presented this CR.
Discussion: The cover sheet needed to be updated (including impact analysis).
Decision: With these changes, the CR was agreed. The update would be in R2-020476 (R'99) and R2-020477 would contain the Rel-4 shadow CR.
R2-020476 Agreed CR 1272r2 to 25.331 on Tx diversity and no diversity in the same active set <CR 1273 Rel-4> (Qualcomm)
R2-020477 Agreed CR 1273 to 25.331 [Rel-4 shadow] on Tx diversity and no diversity in the same active set (Qualcomm)
Decision: The CRs were agreed.
R2-020300 Revised CR 1274 to 25.331 on Correction to cell update <CR 1275 Rel-4> (Ericsson)
Joakim Bergström (Ericsson) presented this CR.
Discussion: One indent was wrong.
Decision: With these changes, the CR was agreed. The update would be in R2-020478 (R'99) and R2-020479 would contain the Rel-4 shadow CR.
R2-020478 Agreed CR 1274r1 to 25.331 on Correction to cell update <CR 1275 Rel-4> (Ericsson)
R2-020479 Agreed CR 1275 to 25.331 [Rel-4 shadow] on Correction to cell update (Ericsson)
Decision: The CRs were agreed.
R2-020301 Agreed CR 1276 to 25.331 on Successful and unsuccessful procedures <CR 1277 Rel-4> (Qualcomm)
Francesco Grilli (Qualcomm) presented this CR.
Decision: The CR was agreed. R2-020480 would contain the Rel-4 shadow CR.
R2-020480 Agreed CR 1277 to 25.331 [Rel-4 shadow] on Successful and unsuccessful procedures (Qualcomm)
Decision: The CR was agreed.
R2-020302 Revised CR 1278 to 25.331 on Measurements <CR 1279 Rel-4> (Ericsson)
Anders Berggren (Ericsson) presented this CR.
Discussion: There was concern that part of the proposal could be seen as additional feature. Mixing the measurement control with RACH reporting was a bit strange. It was also commented that there had been understanding with WG4 not to have reporting in CELL_FACH state. According to RRC, measurement reports could be received in CELL_FACH state, to be stored to be used when there was a switch to the CELL_DCH state. As a result of the discussion, it was found that the terminology used currently needed to be aligned.
Decision: An update of the CR was needed. The update would be in R2-020482.
R2-020482 Agreed CR 1278r1 to 25.331 on Measurements <CR 1279 Rel-4> (Ericsson)
Anders Berggren (Ericsson) presented this CR.
Decision: The CR was agreed. R2-020563 would contain the Rel-4 shadow CR.
R2-020563 Agreed CR 1279 to 25.331 [Rel-4 shadow] on Measurements (Ericsson)
Decision: The CR was agreed.
R2-020303 Revised CR 1280 to 25.331 on Clarifications on Event 1D <CR 1281 Rel-4> (Qualcomm)
This document was revised by R2-020383.
R2-020383 Revised CR 1280r1 to 25.331 on Clarifications on Event 1D <CR 1281 Rel-4> (Qualcomm)
Francesco Grilli (Qualcomm) presented this CR.
Discussion: There was confusion over the use of this event.
Decision: An update of the CR was needed. The update would be in R2-020483.
R2-020483 Agreed CR 1280r2 to 25.331 on Clarifications on Event 1D <CR 1281 Rel-4> (Qualcomm)
Francesco Grilli (Qualcomm) presented this CR.
Decision: The CR was agreed. R2-020564 would contain the Rel-4 shadow CR.
R2-020564 Agreed CR 1281 to 25.331 [Rel-4 shadow] on Clarifications on Event 1D (Qualcomm)
Decision: The CR was agreed.
R2-020304 Revised CR 1282 to 25.331 on Security clarifications <CR 1283 Rel-4> (Ericsson)
This document was revised by R2-020393.
R2-020393 Revised CR 1282r1 to 25.331 on Security clarifications <CR 1283 Rel-4> (Ericsson)
Johan Torsner (Ericsson) presented this CR.
Discussion: The update of this CR would include the revision of CR 1263. There were comments on the removal of activation times. They were needed for SRNS relocation. Removing MODIFY was OK, but the behaviour for START messages needed to be kept. In 8.5.8 the text seemed to imply ciphering in Layer 1, and the original text was felt to be clearer. Some of the new text was better, so the text could be improved.
Decision: An update of the CR was needed. The update would be in R2-020442.
R2-020442 Revised CR 1282r2 to 25.331 on Security clarifications <CR 1283 Rel-4> (Ericsson)
Johan Torsner (Ericsson) presented this CR.
Discussion: There had been offline comments to be taken into account. The ASN.1 change was not included. What was already there was agreed. Any further comments should be given directly to be included for the revision.
Decision: An update of the CR was needed. The update would be in R2-020538.
R2-020538 Revised CR 1282r3 to 25.331 on Security clarifications <CR 1283 Rel-4> (Alcatel, Ericsson, Nortel Networks, Motorola)
Johan Torsner (Ericsson) presented this CR.
Decision: The CR was agreed, but the final version would be in R2-020582 to allow for identified errors. R2-020583 would contain the Rel-4 shadow CR. An e-mail discussion was opened allowing people to identify potential errors in the CR by Wednesday 27 February midnight Pacific time.
R2-020582 Agreed CR 1282r3 to 25.331 on Security clarifications <CR 1283 Rel-4> (Alcatel, Ericsson, Nortel Networks, Motorola)
R2-020583 Agreed CR 1283 to 25.331 [Rel-4 shadow] on Security clarifications (Alcatel, Ericsson, Nortel Networks, Motorola)
Decision: The CRs were agreed. |
