To: epicure who wrote (5977 ) 3/31/2002 10:02:50 AM From: J. C. Dithers Read Replies (2) | Respond to of 21057 I'm not seeing the proof that brings us to the thus. There is no proof, and never will be. Let me put it this way:You , X, already believe something that is absolutely incredible: Once upon a time, 12 billion years ago, there was NOTHING (close you eyes, block your ears ...imagine NOTHING). Then there was a really HUGE bang. BAMMMMMM!!!!! Somehow a constant amount of matter and energy came to be, although no one knows how. It was so tiny at first that you could have held what came to be the earth, all the planets, stars, galaxies ...everything that is .... right in the palm of your hand, if you had been there. BAMMMMM!!!! It grew immense in just a flash and flew off in all directions at once! Right now, right outside your window, it's still flying off in all directions at the speed of light, and no one knows where it's going. You are going with it, and no knows where!! Isn't THAT an incredible story? Does it sound rational and logical? Yet I'm sure you believe it. Is it because "scientists" tell you so? (And not all scientists do). Aren't these the same scientists who would have told you in the year 1200 that the earth was flat? That the earth was the center of the universe? Would you have believed those things because the scientists said so? I believe my fable of the Big Bang (right now, anyway) because even though it sounds utterly incredible, my reason and logic tell me that the universe had to come about somehow, and I'll accept that particular account by the scientists (which in itself constitutes a kind of "faith," since I can neither prove nor truly understand this theory for myself). Since I go one step further than you in my own reason and logic, and add the idea of a creator (as many scientists do), it is consistent for me to seek some explanation or accounting of the nature of that creator. That accounting may also be incredible, but no more so than the first story. That is about the best I can do to explain the chain of my reasoning. There is no way any of us can explain our existence without accepting the incredible, because our existence IS incredible. Your own explanations are different than mine, but neither of us is being illogical of irrational in choosing to believe what we do. If there is some different truth that neither of us has yet discovered, it also must of necessity be profoundly incredible. There simply cannot be a credible truth, given the inadequacy of our intellects to comprehend our existence.