To: Gary H who wrote (85990 ) 5/28/2002 6:44:34 AM From: long-gone Respond to of 116830 So if "round-trip" trading drives up price through an increased number of trades, forward sales of a commodity(gold?) resulting in a lower number of trades would necessarily drive prices lower. Why isn't Gray Davis (Gov. -CA) looking into rumor bullion banks were forcing miners into forward sales? Round-Trip Trading of Calif. Power Probed Tue May 21, 4:57 PM ET By Chris Baltimore WASHINGTON (Reuters) - U.S. energy regulators trying to get to the bottom of California's electricity crisis on Tuesday ordered 150 energy firms to file sworn statements disclosing whether they made sham trades to inflate revenue. The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (news - web sites) pinpointed the practice of so-called "wash" trades or "round-trip" trades, used by companies to falsely boost sales volumes without risk by simultaneously buying and reselling wholesale electricity. The trading strategy is not explicitly illegal for off-exchange transactions. The Securities and Exchange Commission (news - web sites) has launched a probe of the impact of wash trading on corporate balance sheets. Energy firms Reliant Resources Inc., CMS Energy Corp and Williams Cos. Inc have already admitted to using wash trades. The three companies are among scores of power suppliers California accuses of deliberately inflating wholesale electricity prices during the state's crisis in late 2000 and early 2001. The state has demanded refunds of about $9 billion in a case pending before FERC. The companies have denied wrongdoing in California, which was rocked by a series of blackouts, a tenfold rise in wholesale power prices and the bankruptcy of California's largest utility. SWORN STATEMENT REQUIRED Donald Gelinas, FERC's associate director of markets, said the agency wants to know whether all power suppliers involved in the Western market in 2000 and 2001 executed wash trades. Companies must file a sworn statement by May 31 indicating whether they did. "If you so admit, provide transaction by transaction details for all such transactions your company engaged in," Gelinas said in the order. Names of traders who executed them as well as copies of e-mails, memos and telephone logs must also be submitted. FERC's new, sweeping order covers all electricity sellers that did business in Western markets in 2000 and 2001. Among the 150 companies told to provide information were Calpine Corp , Cinergy , Duke Energy , Constellation Energy , Royal Dutch/Shell Group's Coral Energy, PacifiCorp , and Powerex, a unit of Canada's BC Hydro. FERC also threatened to revoke a firm's right to buy and sell power in the wholesale market if it failed to cooperate. The same companies must also respond by Wednesday to a separate FERC request issued earlier this month for information about other questionable trading strategies used by giant Enron Corp. to boost its California profits. The recent disclosures of wash trades by Reliant, CMS and Williams were a blow to share prices in a sector already hit hard by the collapse of Enron. Reliant's wash trades artificially boosted its revenues by 10 percent over three years, and at CMS by $4.4 billion over 18 months. Williams said its trades had no effect on revenues. TRADES USED STRATEGY TO SET PRICES? Experts said it was unclear if wash trades were widespread or directly contributed to California's power crisis. Some companies may have used the strategy to try to make prices rise, said Severin Borenstein, director of the University of California's Energy Institute. For example, two firms might agree to sell each other power in a wash trade at $170 per megawatt. "Well, then I may be able to go somebody else and say: 'Look, there are all these trades taking place at $170, that's what the price is'," he said. Steve Fetter, president of the energy advisory firm Regulation UnFettered, based in Rumson, New Jersey, said the wash trades were probably "gamesmanship" between firms in the highly competitive power market. "Now that it's public, it won't happen any more," Fetter said. "The trading volumes we see going forward will have a certain amount of validity that clearly they did not have based on past information." The FERC, which reluctantly imposed price caps on wholesale power in 10 Western states last summer, has been under pressure from California lawmakers for a year to take tough action. Two Senate committees last week held hearings into Enron's role in the energy shortages of a year ago. Sen. Byron Dorgan, head of a Senate Commerce panel, urged the Bush administration to appoint a special counsel to probe West Coast power trades. In three internal Enron documents released by the FERC on May 6, the company out complex trading schemes with names like "Death Star" and "Fat Boy" that were intended to exploit the electricity grid and create phantom demand in California. Last week, California Gov. Gray Davis (news - web sites) urged FERC to expand its probe of sham trades to include Dynegy and Reliant. Davis, a Democrat who is running for re-election in November, has long blamed energy firms for exacerbating the state's power crisis. story.news.yahoo.com