SI
SI
discoversearch

We've detected that you're using an ad content blocking browser plug-in or feature. Ads provide a critical source of revenue to the continued operation of Silicon Investor.  We ask that you disable ad blocking while on Silicon Investor in the best interests of our community.  If you are not using an ad blocker but are still receiving this message, make sure your browser's tracking protection is set to the 'standard' level.
Politics : The Donkey's Inn -- Ignore unavailable to you. Want to Upgrade?


To: Mephisto who wrote (4262)7/26/2002 4:24:00 PM
From: Mephisto  Respond to of 15516
 
Of babies and butchers : Sharon's bomb explodes in his face

Leader
Guardian

Thursday July 25, 2002

This is a tale of babies and butchers. One baby is, or was, Dina
Matar, aged two months, killed by Israel's air strike in Gaza. Her
tiny corpse, paraded obscenely through the streets on Tuesday,
is offered up as a symbol of Palestinian suffering. It provides a
harrowing image, reproduced around the world. It will not be
quickly forgotten or forgiven. It does Israel's cause incalculable
damage. Far less visible is the corpse of the baby without a
name. He was born prematurely to Yehudit Weinberg after she
was critically injured in a Palestinian attack on a civilian bus in
the West Bank on July 16. The baby lived a mere nine hours.
But he, too, should not be forgotten. His murder was just as
awful, just as reprehensible. It besmirches the name of
Palestine.

In this story of infanticidal tit-for-tat, the butchers are not hard to
identify. The West Bank attack was claimed by, among others,
Hamas. The head of Hamas's military wing was Salah Shehada,
target of Monday's Israeli strike. Israel links him, with reason, to
a string of atrocities including last year's Tel Aviv disco bombing
(21 dead) and last March's Netanya hotel massacre (29 dead).
Shehada was a dedicated enemy of peace, an apparently
remorseless killer whose methods undermined and betrayed the
very quest for which he fought. He was a butcher of innocents.
Even so, Shehada should not have been assassinated. One day
he might have been made to answer for his crimes - and,
perhaps, to repent his role in the death of Yehudit Weinberg's
baby.

The man principally to blame for the carnage that attended
Shehada's killing is Ariel Sharon. Israel's prime minister long
ago declared his determination to hunt down the perpetrators of
terrorist attacks. He hailed Monday's hit as a "great success"
despite the civilian toll of 14 dead and 160 wounded. It was Mr
Sharon, with defence minister Binyamin Ben-Eliezer, who
personally authorised the strike and, specifically, the means
employed- an F-16 armed with a one-ton bomb. And it was Mr
Sharon who initially opposed issuing an apology or even an
expression of regret as the scale of civilian casualties became
clear.

Mr Sharon's office subsequently tried to shift the blame,
claiming army intelligence had said there were no civilians in the
area. Yesterday, amid a fierce outcry in Israel as well as
internationally, Mr Sharon's officials were reportedly arguing that
"doveish" Shimon Peres and other cabinet members approved
Shehada's assassination and knew how, although not when, it
would be done. Such wriggling is contemptible. The prime
minister's personal, primary culpability is plain. Even by his low
standards, Mr Sharon went too far in Gaza on Monday, just as
he did with his repellent demolition of lives and homes in Jenin
camp last April, just as he did in Beirut back in 1982. In ordering
an air strike on a block of flats in a crowded residential area,
Israel's unworthy leader acted recklessly and with an
irresponsible, callous disregard for the consequences. This, too,
was a premeditated butchery of innocents. This was why Dina
Matar died.

Mr Sharon's lethal lack of judgment is well-known. But another,
sinister explanation of his behaviour is possible. Saudi,
European and Palestinian sources credibly suggest Hamas and
similar groups were close to a landmark statement ending the
suicide bombings in return for withdrawal and a halt to
assassinations. Israeli officials dismiss this contention as, after
Gaza, they must. Others however will not. Deliberate sabotage
of the peace process may soon be added to the Sharon
charge-sheet. Perhaps he, unlike Shehada, will one day get
time to repent.


guardian.co.uk