To: Wizard who wrote (13301 ) 8/7/2002 3:08:34 PM From: stockman_scott Respond to of 57684 Even in paradise, business barons end up jousting By Peter Delevett Mercury News Posted on Wed, Aug. 07, 2002 siliconvalley.com Ever wonder what Silicon Valley's rich do with all their money? Well, in at least one instance, they fly to Hawaii, build enormous mansions -- and sue each other. Gather round for a morality tale that's got tech tongues wagging. It all started when Sanford ``Sandy'' Robertson, perhaps the valley's most lauded investment banker, plunked down $3 million a few years back for an acre of oceanfront on the island of Hawaii. Robertson's plot was part of an exclusive enclave being carved out of the Rockefeller family's old Mauna Kea Resort. Before the late-1990s dot-com bubble burst, the resort's owners began auctioning off a handful of lots to the rich and famous. Besides Robertson -- who took public such valley heavyweights as Sun Microsystems and National Semiconductor -- homeowners in the area include Bob Wayman, Hewlett-Packard's chief financial officer; Jack Gifford, head of chip maker Maxim Integrated Products; and a gaggle of venture capitalists, including Norm Fogelsong of Institutional Venture Partners. ``It's a little bit Silicon Valley West,'' explains one homeowner. Robertson planned to build a cozy weekend getaway -- some 6,000 square feet, with five bedrooms, seven bathrooms, two swimming pools and a four-car garage. Estimated price tag: $10 million. And Robertson hired renowned Mexican architect Ricardo Legoretto, who designed San Jose's Tech Museum, to draw up the plans. The best-laid plans But though Robertson's dream digs got a thumbs up from Mauna Kea's design committee, the house was panned by Gifford and Fogelsong, who own lots on either side. So last summer, before Robertson broke ground, the duo sued, claiming Robertson's blueprint violated Mauna Kea's aesthetic guidelines. Among their beefs: The house would have a flat, not peaked, roof and would be painted burnt yellow instead of earth tones. Small stuff, seemingly. The suit was dismissed earlier this year after an arbitration panel ruled in Robertson's favor. Work on his home is under way. ``It's an unbelievable story of hubris gone bad,'' says one leading venture capitalist. ``Do you sue your neighbor because you don't like the house they're going to build?'' Another person says the three combatants have known each other for years and done deals together. Maybe the sudden hostility was due to a few too many mai tais. Gifford didn't return calls, and Robertson and Fogelsong both declined to comment. ``The terms of the settlement must remain confidential,'' sniffed Fogelsong, an early investor in Compaq Computer. Someone close to Robertson estimates he spent more than $700,000 on legal fees to defend himself. He's now suing Mauna Kea Properties to recoup those fees. (Mauna Kea officials were unavailable to comment.) And he counter-sued Gifford, who he claimed had also violated design guidelines, and won that case in arbitration. No hard feelings? Robertson's confidant says he has patched things up with Gifford, one of the valley's highest-paid executives, who recently completed his own $9 million home in Mauna Kea. Things are said to be chillier with Fogelsong, who in his suit said his Hawaiian home and lot would cost more than $10 million. But Fogelsong offered an odd olive branch. Shortly after the suit was dismissed, he asked Robertson to invest in a $100 million deal his venture firm was putting together, two people familiar with the situation say. Robertson declined, perhaps not surprisingly. But you've got to admire Fogelsong's chutzpah. ``The rich are different from you and me,'' F. Scott Fitzgerald wrote. Maybe some have so much money -- and are so used to getting what they want -- that they have to resort to lawyers instead of talking things out with their neighbors. -------------------------------------------------------- Peter Delevett's column appears Sunday and Wednesday. If you've got a scoop, e-mail pdelevett@sjmercury. com or call (408) 271-3638.