SI
SI
discoversearch

We've detected that you're using an ad content blocking browser plug-in or feature. Ads provide a critical source of revenue to the continued operation of Silicon Investor.  We ask that you disable ad blocking while on Silicon Investor in the best interests of our community.  If you are not using an ad blocker but are still receiving this message, make sure your browser's tracking protection is set to the 'standard' level.
Politics : Formerly About Advanced Micro Devices -- Ignore unavailable to you. Want to Upgrade?


To: tejek who wrote (149213)8/7/2002 4:43:59 PM
From: Tenchusatsu  Read Replies (1) | Respond to of 1579676
 
Ted, <You say a decent sized minority supports affirmative action. I would have to disagree. 52% of the US population is made up of women.......>

Classic "divide-n-conquer." I'll bet the white woman who thought she lost her job to a black woman would not be for affirmative action.

And don't even get me started on how hard-working Asians get the shaft ...

Tenchusatsu



To: tejek who wrote (149213)8/7/2002 6:05:09 PM
From: TimF  Read Replies (1) | Respond to of 1579676
 
Tim, at the time the poll was taken those issues apparently were considered liberal. My contention is most, if not all of them, would be considered mainstream now. For an example we both agree that a majority believe in abortion.

The percentage that supports legal abortion now is about the same as the percentage that supported it then. At both times there is/was a majority for it but not a huge one. At both times being for legalized abortion is the liberal position (it doesn't become not liberal when you get 50+ % support). At both times any large group that supports it at a rate of about 90% would be considered liberal (in the absence of information that would indicate otherwise). Registered democrats as a group don't support legalized abortion 9 to 1. So on at least this issue the press is (or at least was in the early eighties) much more liberal as a group then the members of the Democratic Party are.

You say a decent sized minority supports affirmative action. I would have to disagree.

kaet.asu.edu

delawareonline.com

washingtonpost.com

(see #19 at the above url its about affirmitive action but most of the poll is not)

"Three out of four Americans surveyed said they opposed
affirmative action programs that give preference to
minorities to make up for past discrimination, and a
virtually identical proportion felt the same way about
programs for women, according to the survey. And more
than two out of three said those programs should be
changed – or eliminated.

The survey found that affirmative action, like most
racial issues, sharply divides whites and blacks. And
within communities of color, a debate about affirmative
action also rages: Nearly half of all African Americans
interviewed said they opposed affirmative action
programs giving preference to minorities. "

washingtonpost.com

52% of the US population is made up of
women.......what proportion do you think is opposed to A.A.?


A majority of women are against preferences based on race or sex. The majority is smaller then that for men but it is still a majority

I'm guessing but I would suspect that 30-35% of the population is
made up of people of color......how many of them do you think oppose A.A.?


I think about 14% of the population is black. A majority of black people support affirmitive action but not an overwhelming majority. I don't think I have stats for hispanics but I'm pretty sure that you are not talking an overwhelming majority of hispanics support it. My guess (and this is only an educated guess) is that a majority of Asians oppose affirmitive action.

Do you think all white men are opposed to A.A.?

Not all, but a very large majority of them are opposed to prefrences.

Well, that can't be right.....at least 10-15% of them are gay?

That figure is too high, esp with an "at least" in front of it. Besides some gay people oppose prefrences.

I believe the majority of registered voters are Dems.


True but the difference is not large and the number of actual voters for the parties in presidential and congressional races has been about even. Democrats are more likely to vote for Republicans then Republicans are to vote for Democrats. There is still a small but not insignificant minority of Democrats that are mostly conservative, but identify themselves as democrats because of family history or union ties, or whatever. The amount of Republicans that are Republican just because there parents and their parents parents where Republican seems to be lower.

it wasn't a majority but it was closer than I expected....the low 40's I think. And the poll said more and more Americans see a link between third world poverty and our way of life.

I'd like to see the wording on the poll. In any case the idea is pretty nonsensical. The biggest reason for third world poverty is the deficits of the governments and laws of third world countries. Other reasons include things like local overpopulation (in places like Bangladesh) and wars (although war could be considered to frequently be the results of the awful governments I talked about as the first reason.

While the views of the journalists do diverge to some degree from the population in general, its not by a whole bunch.

On at least some issues it is by a whole lot, and on a number of other issues it may not be so big but its noticeable. One issue where the bias is really noticeable not just in opinion polls of journalists but in their articles and TV news pieces is gun control.

Tim