To: Nadine Carroll who wrote (57897 ) 11/19/2002 10:26:27 PM From: Bilow Read Replies (2) | Respond to of 281500 Hi Nadine Carroll; Re: "Yes, Moslems or Christians can get married in Israel. What the article is talking about is the lock the Orthodox Jewish establishment has over Jewish practices, a considerable sore point with the majority of Israeli Jews, who are secular. " I'm still grappling with what I'm learning here. You didn't quite answer one of my questions which was this: "Can a Moslem and a Jewish person get married in Israel? " If I'm not being clear, let me reword it this way: "Is it okay for a Moslem to marry a Jew in Israel? " I know that it can happen in the US. Can it happen in Israel? Has there been a recent law change? From looking for links in the Jerusalem Post, I now want to add another question: "Are marriages between non Jews recognized by the State of Israel? " That is, if two people get married, maybe one a Jew, is their marriage recognized by the State of Israel for tax and various other purposes? All these links (none older than 5 years) are from the Jerusalem Post, but the laws they describe seem like they belong to a Jewish Fundamentalist state, not a secular democracy:Chief rabbis ready to consider civil marriage in some cases The Chief Rabbinate would not object to a system of civil marriage in cases where neither partner is recognized by the rabbinate as Jewish or in which one of the partners is not halachicly able to be married, Sephardi Chief Rabbi Eliahu Bakshi-Doron told MKs yesterday.jpost.com Consular marriages: An unorthdox solution Halacha does not allow a Jew and a non-Jew to marry. And since marriage and divorce are under the sole jurisdiction of the religious authorities, M. and Y. could not marry here.jpost.com FROM A DISTANCE: What religious women want Today, on the Fast of Esther, religious women are gathering outside Ma'asiyahu Prison to make a point: every Jewish woman who marries according the present halachic ceremony acceptable in Orthodox Judaism is a potential prisoner. The current state of Jewish divorce all over the world is a disgrace, and should a husband choose to lock his wife into a marriage she wishes to escape, she might as well be behind bars with a life sentence. jpost.com Melchior backs civil-marriage reform If Barak has his way, the civil marriage reform will extend to all people in Israel, Jews and non-Jews alike. However, the Chief Rabbinate and religious parties would limit it to non-Jews. A senior official in the Chief Rabbinate said it would accept the proposal if the reform applies only to non-Jews, intermarriage, and Jews who cannot be married according to Halacha, such as a kohen (member of the priestly class) marrying a divorcee.Unholy alliance of religion and state "Each state, party to the present covenant undertakes to respect and to ensure to all individuals Š the rights recognized in the present covenant, without distinction of any kind, such as race, color, sex, language, religion, political or other opinion, national or social origin, property, birth or other status" - from Article 2 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR). This month, the United Nations Human Rights Committee will hear Israel's first report on the implementation of this covenant. Israel's representatives are certainly going to face serious challenges when they address this country's conduct in the territories, minority rights, women's rights, and other issues. Israel signed the covenant in August 1991 but while doing so, entered a reservation on matters of personal status. This reservation is designed to save Israel from criticism for imposing religious law in this area, primarily in matters of marriage and divorce. ... It is precisely because Israel chose to enter a reservation in the arena of religion, as did some other countries such as Kuwait and Libya, that it is important to see which values and international obligations are recognized in this field. ... Moreover, both freedom of religion and freedom from religion are violated by the fact that civil as well as non-Orthodox religious marriage is not legally recognized. These are but few examples that arise when one takes full stock of the unholy alliance of religion and state in Israel. ... (The writer is a rabbi and attorney who serves as the executive director of the Movement for Progressive Judaism's Israel Religious Action Center.) jpost.com -- Carl P.S. I really don't know what to say. Is there something in the water that makes people in the Middle East into religious bigots?