Silicon Investor (SI) -- The First Internet Community

STOCKTALK

We've detected that you're using an ad content blocking browser plug-in or feature. Ads provide a critical source of revenue to the continued operation of Silicon Investor. We ask that you disable ad blocking while on Silicon Investor in the best interests of our community. If you are not using an ad blocker but are still receiving this message, make sure your browser's tracking protection is set to the 'standard' level.

Pastimes : Crazy Fools Chasing Crazy CyberNews -- Ignore unavailable to you. Want to Upgrade?

To: ms.smartest.person who wrote (2237)	12/30/2002 11:58:35 PM
From: ms.smartest.person	Read Replies (1) \| Respond to of 5140

Around the markets: Herd mentality gathers force among analysts Mark Hulbert NYT Monday, December 30, 2002 Many Wall Street analysts have complained about Coca-Cola's recent decision to stop helping them prepare their quarterly or yearly earnings forecasts. Instead, they should be calling on other companies to follow Coke's lead. If all corporations stopped feeding earnings forecasts to brokerage firms, analysts would have to rely on their own research. Serious, independent analysis might flourish. A new study suggests how rare such analysis is these days. The study, by Eric Zitzewitz, an assistant professor of strategic management at the Stanford University Graduate School of Business, documents that an increase in what he called "herding" behavior occurred among analysts after August 2000, when new disclosure rules from the Securities and Exchange Commission took effect. Under those rules, called Regulation FD for "fair disclosure," the commission prohibits companies from revealing materially important information to analysts in private conversations. It requires them to communicate such information to all investors at once, in a news release or a conference call. The study found that after companies could no longer freely leak information to favored analysts, those analysts began acting more as a herd. For his study, Zitzewitz examined all earnings forecasts in the database of the Institutional Brokers Estimates System, now part of Thomson First Call, for the period from Jan. 1, 1993, more than seven years before Regulation FD took effect, to June 30, 2001, almost a year after the new rules. Over the entire period, that database contained more than 680,000 earnings forecasts from more than 6,000 analysts at more than 4,000 companies. A telling variable is the number of "multiforecast days" - meaning days when more than one analyst following a particular company issues or revises his forecast. Before Regulation FD, the study found, 30 percent of analyst forecasts for a given company came on multiforecast days. Over the 11 months after that rules took effect, that portion grew to 50 percent, and analysts increasingly just redistributed the kind of corporate earnings guidance that Coca- Cola has announced that it will stop making. To determine whether an analyst's forecast was repetitive, Zitzewitz looked at a number of factors. They are described in his study, which is available at: papers.ssrn.com delivery.cfm/SSRN_ID305219_code020414670.pdf?abstractid=305219. One of the more revealing factors was the extent to which a forecast diverged from the consensus estimate. The study found that on those increasingly rare occasions after Regulation FD when an analyst issued a report on his own, his opinions seldom veered much from received opinion. Over all, Zitzewitz concluded that herd behavior approximately doubled after Regulation FD. Before the rules, according to the study, about 65 percent of new earnings information reached investors from forecasts of analysts acting alone. Under the new rules, that portion dropped to 27 percent. While all of this shows that little independent analysis is being conducted on Wall Street, it does not mean that much deep thinking went into analysts' reports before Regulation FD. To the contrary, the settlement of almost $1.5 billion reached this month between securities regulators and 10 big Wall Street firms makes clear that analysts and corporations have been working hand in hand for many years to distribute self-serving earnings forecasts that they hoped would propel stock prices higher. Coca-Cola says it wants to encourage analysts and investors to focus on the company's long-term performance, not on its ability to meet short-term earnings targets. Under pressure from both institutional clients and individual investors, analysts undoubtedly will keep churning out short-term forecasts. But they will have to work harder to produce them. - Mark Hulbert (NYT) Hulbert is editor of The Hulbert Financial Digest, a newsletter based in Annandale, Virginia. Copyright © 2002 The International Herald Tribune iht.com