SI
SI
discoversearch

We've detected that you're using an ad content blocking browser plug-in or feature. Ads provide a critical source of revenue to the continued operation of Silicon Investor.  We ask that you disable ad blocking while on Silicon Investor in the best interests of our community.  If you are not using an ad blocker but are still receiving this message, make sure your browser's tracking protection is set to the 'standard' level.
Politics : PRESIDENT GEORGE W. BUSH -- Ignore unavailable to you. Want to Upgrade?


To: DavesM who wrote (338149)1/5/2003 6:27:10 PM
From: American Spirit  Respond to of 769667
 
No, you're right it was 1968 not 1972. Those 10,000,000 votes were the ones the GOP went after.

Candidate (party) Popular vote
(5 Nov 1968) Electoral vote
(16 Dec 1968)
Richard M. Nixon (Republican) 31,785,480 301
Hubert H. Humphrey (Democratic) 31,275,166 191
George C. Wallace (American Independent) 9,906,473 46
other 244,756 0



To: DavesM who wrote (338149)1/5/2003 6:30:17 PM
From: American Spirit  Respond to of 769667
 
On GOP Southern strategy - history to correct us both:

Southern preferences in 1964
84% of Southern delegates to the Republican Convention agreed with the view that: “the government in Washington should stay out of the question of integrating schools”
82%: the question of voting rights of Negroes should be left to state and local governments.”
Black and Black, p. 130

Short-term, long-term effects
Goldwater repackaged the Republican Party as fundamentally conservative and sympathetic to Southern claims
1964 was an enormous defeat for Republicans, but the new conservative party began to dominate the Electoral College after 1968

1968
Richard Nixon emerges as most electable conservative (challenged by Rockefeller and Reagan)
Strom Thurmond - now Republican – backed Nixon and united the Southern delegation

The Southern Strategy: Civil Rights
The Republicans certainly did not embrace segregation in an effort to attract Southern voters,
But they also did not embrace a federal role in integration
Black and Black label the new position “something in between segregation and integration”

The Southern Strategy: Related issues
Defense
Judicial restraint
Decentralization of governmental power

The White Revolt in the South
A series of conservative candidates -- Republican and third party -- capitalized on Southern opposition to civil rights to attract Southern voters:
Strom Thurmond
Barry Goldwater
George Wallace

Strom Thurmond
1948 incorporation of civil rights plank in Democratic platform motivated Thurmond to run as third party candidate: a Dixiecrat
“..the radical, the subversives, and the Reds” gained complete control of the Democratic Party
“If Massachusetts and other northern states want to encourage [racial] intermingling, let them do it. But we will have none of it here.”

Thurmond in 1948
Thurmond managed to secure 50% of the white vote in the Deep South (see map p. 148 - most successful among whites in states with large African-American population -- see p. 170)
Interpretation of this outcome was uncertain at the time: feeble influence of race (only 50%) or indicator of potency of race as single issue

Barry Goldwater
Goldwater was one of a narrow minority that opposed the Civil Rights Act.
His opposition was rooted in fear of the creation of a "police state" to enforce the provisions of the Act. (no "legislation of morality"; preemince of "states rights")
The Goldwater campaign events in the south in 1964 were labeled as "carnivals of white supremacy" by some observers.

Goldwater in 1964
Goldwater's support in the white south was very broad -- highly-educated and poorly-educated; urban and rural; upper class and lower class.
But Johnson won 99% of the Electoral College votes in the North and a majority of the electoral College votes in the peripheral South

George Wallace
1964: "Stand up for Alabama" opposition to integration of the University of Alabama creates a national stage for Wallace.
Wallace's "llitle man against big government" message was very popular in the South (see p 163 & 160).
This language has been appropriated by contemporary candidate of both political parties.

George Wallace in 1968
As a third party candidate, Wallace received 13% of the national popular vote in 1968 (34% of South, 8% of North).
Wallace had a more narrow appeal, specifically among poorly-educated less affluent Southern whites.

Race and elections
Wallace staked his candidacy on the issue of race and he was not as successful in creating a broad base of support as Goldwater
Race alone was insufficient to attract Southern voters
Note: 1968 Southern electorate contained many more African American registered voters

Sociology of intolerance
Proximity matters (see p. 147)
Racial threat hypothesis: white minorities will actively oppose steps toward racial equality (see Figure 6.4)

The New Southern Campaign
The White Protest was confined, for the most part, to the Deep South.
Peripheral southern states like Texas, North Carolina and Virginia were not sources of support for these candidates.
Issues to unite the South
Republican attention in future elections would focus on the best issues that could unite the South
Attract the Deep South (thoroughly alienated from the Democrats)
And the more suburban and affluent peripheral South.



To: DavesM who wrote (338149)1/5/2003 6:32:21 PM
From: American Spirit  Read Replies (1) | Respond to of 769667
 
Barry Goldwater opposed civil rights, NAACP member???

Goldwater was one of a narrow minority that opposed the Civil Rights Act.
His opposition was rooted in fear of the creation of a "police state" to enforce the provisions of the Act. (no "legislation of morality"; preemince of "states rights")
The Goldwater campaign events in the south in 1964 were labeled as "carnivals of white supremacy" by some observers.