To: Maurice Winn who wrote (27952 ) 1/27/2003 4:32:56 AM From: marek_wojna Respond to of 74559 Maurice, you are facing conflict of interest now. Which one you'll put now on the higher altar? Bush or Greenspan? You cannot serve two gods, IMO Jay is right on the subject calling you to save save yourself and your soul. << THE BUSH ECONOMIC PLAN BUSH ECONOMIC PLAN See full coverage of the president's economic package and its reception on Capitol Hill and beyond. Plus, extensive coverage of what the plan could mean for individual investors, at Tax-Free Returns. advertisement Dividend-Tax Cut Plan Draws More Fire From Friends, Foes Daschle Calls Plan 'Dead On Arrival'; Greenspan Plays Down Economic Effect By SHAILAGH MURRAY Staff Reporter of THE WALL STREET JOURNAL WASHINGTON -- Opposition to President Bush's dividend-tax cut intensified on Capitol Hill, as Senate Democratic Leader Tom Daschle declared it "dead on arrival" and Federal Reserve Chairman Alan Greenspan played down its short-term stimulative effect on the economy. Speaking privately to a group of senators Thursday, Mr. Greenspan said the U.S. economy is recovering without additional fiscal stimulus. In any case, he said Mr. Bush's proposed $670 billion of tax cuts would provide the economy with little near-term effect, according to people familiar with the meeting, which was set up by Sen. John Breaux (D., La.) to hear Mr. Greenspan's views on the economy and government fiscal policy. Members of the bipartisan group said they concluded from the session that the central-bank chairman wants Congress to pass a much smaller stimulus package, or none at all. Mr. Daschle didn't attend Thursday's meeting. But one senior Democratic aide said Mr. Greenspan's comments, relayed to the South Dakotan by other senators, were a factor in his dismissal of the tax cut Sunday. "The stock-dividend approach is dead on arrival," Mr. Daschle told the CBS program "Face the Nation." He said "adequate support" had built "in opposition to the president's plan -- both on the Republican and Democratic side" -- to assure that it won't survive in its current form. Eliminating taxes on stock dividends is the centerpiece of an economic plan that Mr. Bush will pitch Tuesday night in his State of the Union address. He defended the tax cut during his Saturday radio address, saying it would "lay the foundation for future prosperity by encouraging investment and helping Americans to prepare for the new jobs a growing economy will bring." Asked whether he thought the dividends proposal was dead, Sen. Mitch McConnell (R., Ky.), the second-ranking Senate Republican, responded with a lukewarm, "I don't think so." Speaking on the NBC news program "Meet the Press" Sunday, Mr. McConnell called the president's stimulus package "an overall effort to reinvigorate the stock market and to get the economy growing again. Clearly, the president is asking the Congress to act, and act, I believe, we will." If the dividends proposal does survive, indications now are that it is likely to be scaled back. Republican legislative aides are trying to gauge market effects of various changes to the plan. They also are examining possible ripple effects within the corporate-tax code, along with how much revenue a dividend-tax cut could cost state and local governments selling tax-exempt bonds that would be disadvantaged by Mr. Bush's proposal. On initial examination, they said, cutting taxes paid on corporate dividends by just 50% appears to relieve much of the negative impact on municipal bonds created by full repeal, aides said. Meanwhile, Republican skepticism of the dividend cut appears to be growing. "Surely you could come up with a better stimulus than that," said Sen. Pete Domenici (R., N.M.). Many House and Senate Republicans would prefer to shorten depreciation schedules to stir business investment. Democrats and Republicans both support a bigger write-off for small businesses through an expensing increase. Another bipartisan priority is altering the alternative minimum tax -- a flat tax that kicks in once deductions reach a certain level -- before it ensnares millions of middle-class taxpayers. In a speech Friday to the City Club in Cleveland, Mr. Daschle proposed a one-year, $141 billion stimulus plan that would provide a $300 rebate to all working adults, provide cash-strapped states with $40 billion of fiscal relief and give small-businesses a 50% tax credit to help them maintain employee health plans. The Democratic leader called the dividend-tax cut the Bush package's "biggest flaw."