Release 99 corrections - continued:
==========
6.6 Proposed changes on 25.304
R2-030246 Proposed CR to 25.304 [R99] on correction to cell selection/reselection ASUSTeK
R2-030247 Proposed CR to 25.304 [Rel-4 shadow] on correction to cell selection/reselection ASUSTeK
R2-030248 Proposed CR to 25.304 [Rel-5 shadow] on correction to cell selection/reselection ASUSTeK
This document was presented by Rex Chen from ASUSTeK.
Discussion:
The change did not appear to be needed. 25.133 already defines it.
Decision: The document was noted.
6.7 Proposed changes on 25.305
R2-030634 Agreed CR 084 to 25.305 [Rel-4] on Update to figure 5.1, LMU terminology Nokia
R2-030635 Agreed CR 085 to 25.305 [Rel-5 shadow] on Update to figure 5.1, LMU terminology Nokia
Those CRs were included in the LS R2-030620. They were agreed following the presentation of this LS (See Clause 11).
6.8 Proposed changes on 25.306
R2-030520 Proposed CR 058 to 25.306 [R'99] on Variable Tx/Rx frequency separation in 1800 and 1900 band Ericsson
R2-030521 Proposed CR 059 to 25.306 [Rel-4 shadow] on Variable Tx/Rx frequency separation in 1800 and 1900 band Ericsson
R2-030522 Proposed CR 060 to 25.306 [Rel-5 shadow] on Variable Tx/Rx frequency separation in 1800 and 1900 band Ericsson
This document was presented by Joakim Bergstrom from Ericsson.
Discussion:
Decision: The CRs were agreed into R2-030563, R2-030564 and R2-030565 (CR numbers with revision 1).
6.9 Proposed changes on 25.321
R2-030507 Proposed CR to 25.321 on Setting of Ciphering activation time for TM bearers Nortel
This document was presented by Tania Godard from Nortel.
Discussion:
Decision: We will come-back on it.
Agreed in CR 164, 165 and 166. R2-030599, R2-030600 and R2-030601.
R2-030571 Proposed CR to 25.321 [R99] on TFC Control Implementation Qualcomm
This document was presented by Hector Vayanos from Qualcomm.
Discussion:
More time is neeeded.
Decision: The CRs will be subject of an email agreement R2-030607, R2-030608 and R2-030609. CR numbers 167, 168 and 169. Deadline by Wednessday.
6.10 Proposed changes on 25.322
R2-030204 Proposed CR to 25.322 [R99] on Correction to VT(MRW) definition LG Electronics Inc.
R2-030205 Proposed CR to 25.322 [Rel-4 shadow] on Correction to VT(MRW) definition LG Electronics Inc.
R2-030206 Proposed CR to 25.322 [Rel-5 shadow] on Correction to VT(MRW) definition LG Electronics Inc.
This document was presented by SeungJune Yi from LG Electronics.
Discussion:
The consequences if not approved, in their current state, do not provide any information.
“Transmission” should be used instead of “retransmission”.
Decision: The CR will be updated in R2-030433 (RLC proposed CR).
R2-030433 Proposed CR to 25.322 [R99] on Correction to VT(MRW) definition LG Electronics Inc.
This document was presented by SeungJune Yi from LG Electronics.
Discussion:
The consequences if not approved need to be improved.
Decision: The CR was agreed into R2-030509, R2-030510 and R2-030511. CR numbers 214, 215 and 216.
6.11 Proposed changes on 25.323
There was no input under this agenda item.
6.12 Proposed changes on 25.324
R2-030493 Proposed CR 014 to 25.324 on Cell Broadcast data parameters Ericsson
R2-030494 Proposed CR 015 to 25.324 on Cell Broadcast data parameters Ericsson
R2-030495 Proposed CR 016 to 25.324 on Cell Broadcast data parameters Ericsson
This document was presented by Anders from Ericsson.
Those CRs are linked with the LS to T2 in R2-030492.
Discussion:
The square brackets were used to show the optionality (see table 8.2.1.1).
Decision: The CRs were agreed into R2-030573, R2-030574 and R2-030575.
6.13 Proposed changes on 25.331
R2-030100 Withdrawn CR to 25.331 [Rel-4 shadow] on Corrections to Channelisation Code TFCI Mapping for TDD Interdigital
R2-030101 Withdrawn CR to 25.331 [Rel-5 shadow] on Corrections to Channelisation Code TFCI Mapping for TDD Interdigital
R2-030109 Withdrawn CR to 25.331 [R99] on Corrections to Channelisation Code TFCI Mapping for TDD Interdigital
Those documents were withdrawn before presentation.
R2-030123 Proposed CR to 25.331 [R99] on ASN.1 of the SRNS relocation Info Nortel Networks
R2-030124 Proposed CR to 25.331 [Rel-4 shadow] on ASN.1 of the SRNS relocation Info Nortel Networks
R2-030125 Proposed CR to 25.331 [Rel-5 shadow] on ASN.1 of the SRNS relocation Info Nortel Networks
This document was presented by Tania Godard from Nortel Networks.
Discussion:
Decision:
The CRs were agreed into CR numbers 1811, 1812 and 1813. Tdocs in R2-030434, R2-030435 and R2-030436.
R2-030127 Proposed CR to 25.331 [R99] on Correction to procedural text for Physical Shared Channel Allocation (TDD only) IPWireless
R2-030128 Proposed CR to 25.331 [Rel-4 shadow] on Correction to procedural text for Physical Shared Channel Allocation (TDD only) IPWireless
R2-030129 Proposed CR to 25.331 [Rel-5 shadow] on Correction to procedural text for Physical Shared Channel Allocation (TDD only) IPWireless
This document was presented by Tim Speigh from IPWireless.
Discussion:
One point needs to be added.
Decision: The CRs were agreed into R2-030437, R2-030438 and R2-030439. CR numbers in 1814, 1815 and 1816.
R2-030135 Proposed CR to 25.331 [R99] on CM and state transition related to measurements, additional measurements, virtual active set and periodic measurements Ericsson
R2-030136 Proposed CR to 25.331 [Rel-4 shadow] on CM and state transition related to measurements, additional measurements, virtual active set and periodic measurements Ericsson
R2-030137 Proposed CR to 25.331 [Rel-5 shadow] on CM and state transition related to measurements, additional measurements, virtual active set and periodic measurements Ericsson
This document was presented by Gert-Jan van Lieshout from Ericsson.
Discussion:
The first point will be reworded.
3 companies supported the reading of the SIB11, 4 companies supported not reading it. If the ambiguity stays, measurements on RACH are not possible.
Could we have a “should” (for the reading of the SIB11) in the R’99, so that both behaviours are allowed for the R’99? Hence, the recommended implementation would be to read the SIB11.
For the SIB11, there will be an additional sentence (with a shall for the three releases).
The grouping of the CRs was challenged.
For the first measurement report (6.1), we will have a “should” for the R’99 (and a “shall” for later releases). (should/shall not be sent later than…). Subsequent measurements shall be sent every…
Question: Is the measurement control sent on dedicated and BCCH ?
Answer: Yes.
Point 7: Agreed.
Point 8: Agreed.
Point 9: Agreed.
Decision: The CRs were revised into CRs 1817, 1818 and 1819. R2-030440, R2-030441 and R2-030442.
R2-030440 Proposed CR 1817 to 25.331 [R99] on CM and state transition related to measurements, additional measurements, virtual active set and periodic measurements Ericsson
R2-030441 Proposed CR 1818 to 25.331 [Rel-4 shadow] on CM and state transition related to measurements, additional measurements, virtual active set and periodic measurements Ericsson
R2-030442 Proposed CR 1819 to 25.331 [Rel-5 shadow] on CM and state transition related to measurements, additional measurements, virtual active set and periodic measurements Ericsson
Those CRs were presented by Gert-Jan van Lieshout from Ericsson.
Discussion:
Comments on the first sending of the report message for the R’99.
This will be taken out of the CR, and isolated into another CR.
Decision: The CRs were revised into R2-030515, R2-030516 and R2-030517.
The part under discussion will go into R2-030518.
R2-030515 Proposed CR 1817Rev1 to 25.331 [R99] on CM and state transition related to measurements, additional measurements, virtual active set and periodic measurements Ericsson
R2-030516 Proposed CR 1818Rev1 to 25.331 [Rel-4 shadow] on CM and state transition related to measurements, additional measurements, virtual active set and periodic measurements Ericsson
R2-030517 Proposed CR 1819Rev1 to 25.331 [Rel-5 shadow] on CM and state transition related to measurements, additional measurements, virtual active set and periodic measurements Ericsson
Those CRs were presented by Gert-Jan van Lieshout from Ericsson.
Discussion:
Decision: The CRs were agreed (as they were).
R2-030518 Proposed CR to 25.331 [R99] on Mandatory reading of SIB11/12 before RACH access Ericsson
This CR were presented by Gert-Jan van Lieshout from Ericsson.
Discussion:
This needs discussions with RAN WG4.
The impact analysis needs to be updated.
Decision: The CR will be revised into R2-030576. It will be presented on Friday.
R2-030576 Proposed CR to 25.331 [R99] on Mandatory reading of SIB11/12 before RACH access Ericsson
This CR were presented by Gert-Jan van Lieshout from Ericsson.
Discussion:
The change since the previous verison is the coversheet. There are three main areas for the reading of those SIBs.
There is an agreement on the analysis.
Decision: Will be sent on the reflector for email agreement.
R2-030138 Proposed CR to 25.331 [R99] on Physical channel failure and radio link re-establishment Ericsson
R2-030139 Proposed CR to 25.331 [Rel-4 shadow] on Physical channel failure and radio link re-establishment Ericsson
R2-030140 Proposed CR to 25.331 [Rel-5 shadow] on Physical channel failure and radio link re-establishment Ericsson
This document was presented by Gert-Jan van Lieshout from Ericsson.
Discussion:
Physical channel failure: What is the need for changing the definition ?
Answer: Subclause 8.5.4 can only happen during the establishment phase.
How could subclause 8.5.4 be applied at all to procedure B ?
The note will be kept, but reworded.
RB mapping:
The Call Re-establishment functionality does not work if the UE does not implement it.
After the invalid configuration in CELL_FACH, the UE behaviour is not specified today.
But by using the RB mapping info, this can be avoided.
The barring could be replaced by a local release (with a “should” for the UE in the R’99).
Which SRBs have to be checked ? RB4 could be included, so that we know that it can be used. Then, all the SRBs would have to be checked.
Decision: The CRs were revised into R2-030443, R2-030444, and R2-030445. CR numbers 1820, 1821 and 1822.
R2-030443 Proposed CR 1820 to 25.331 [R99] on Physical channel failure and radio link re-establishment Ericsson
R2-030444 Proposed CR 1821 to 25.331 [Rel-4 shadow] on Physical channel failure and radio link re-establishment Ericsson
R2-030445 Proposed CR 1822 to 25.331 [Rel-5 shadow] on Physical channel failure and radio link re-establishment Ericsson
This document was presented by Himke van der Velde from Ericsson.
Discussion:
Decision: The CRs were agreed (as they were).
R2-030143 Proposed CR to 25.331 [R'99] Correction concerning bit numbering convention Ericsson
R2-030144 Proposed CR to 25.331 [Rel-4 shadow] Correction concerning bit numbering convention Ericsson
R2-030145 Proposed CR to 25.331 [Rel-5 shadow] Correction concerning bit numbering convention Ericsson
This document was presented by Himke van der Velde from Ericsson.
Discussion:
Decision: The CRs were agreed into R2-030446, R2-030447, and R2-030448. CR numbers 1823, 1824 and 1825.
R2-030146 Proposed CR to 25.331 [R'99] on Variable Tx/Rx frequency separation in 1800 and 1900 band Ericsson
R2-030147 Proposed CR to 25.331 [Rel-4 shadow] on Variable Tx/Rx frequency separation in 1800 and 1900 band Ericsson
R2-030148 Proposed CR to 25.331 [Rel-5 shadow] on Variable Tx/Rx frequency separation in 1800 and 1900 band Ericsson
This document was presented by Joakim Bergstrom from Ericsson.
Discussion:
Could we not keep the same ASN.1 value ? Otherwise, this would change the ASN.1 source file.
Is 25.306 aligned with this change ?
Decision: The CR was agreed into R2-030449, R2-030450 and R2-030451. CR numbers 1826, 1827 and 1828. This leaded to the need to update TS 25.306. The CRs on 25.306 are in R2-030520, R2-030521, and R2-030522. CR numbers 058, 059 and 060.
R2-030156 Proposed CR to 25.331 [R99] on Correction to Inter-RAT Measurement Report Motorola
R2-030157 Proposed CR to 25.331 [Rel-4 shadow] on Correction to Inter-RAT Measurement Report Motorola
R2-030158 Proposed CR to 25.331 [Rel-5 shadow] on Correction to Inter-RAT Measurement Report Motorola
This document was presented by Richard Burbidge from Motorola.
Discussion:
There was another proposal.
Decision: The CR will be updated in R2-030453.
R2-030453 Proposed CR to 25.331 [R99] on Correction to Inter-RAT Measurement Report Motorola
This document was presented by Richard Burbidge from Motorola.
The “should” is meant to be changed to a “shall” for the Rel-4.
There is an indentation error.
Discussion:
Decision: The CR was agreed into R2-030577, R2-030578 and R2-030579. CR numbers 1882, 1883 and 1884.
R2-030159 Proposed CR to 25.331 [R99] on Correction to signalling of transport block size for DSCH Motorola
R2-030160 Proposed CR to 25.331 [Rel-4 shadow] on Correction to signalling of transport block size for DSCH Motorola
R2-030161 Proposed CR to 25.331 [Rel-5 shadow] on Correction to signalling of transport block size for DSCH Motorola
This document was presented by Richard Burbidge from Motorola.
Discussion:
The problem is only applicable to FDD, so the CR should be updated accordingly.
Decision: The CR was revised into R2-030454.
R2-030454 Proposed CR to 25.331 [R99] on Correction to signalling of transport block size for DSCH Motorola
This document was presented by Richard Burbidge from Motorola.
Discussion:
Decision: The CR were agreed into R2-030580, R2-030581 and R2-030582. CR number in 1885, 1886 and 1887.
R2-030162 Proposed CR to 25.331 [R99] on Correction on GPS navigation model update mechanism Nokia
R2-030163 Proposed CR to 25.331 [Rel-4 shadow] on Correction on GPS navigation model update mechanism Nokia
R2-030164 Proposed CR to 25.331 [Rel-5 shadow] on Correction on GPS navigation model update mechanism Nokia
This document was presented by Juha Mikola from Nokia.
Discussion:
This broadcast SI is not applicable to GERAN.
Decision: We will come-back on it.
Will be subject of an email approval. End: End of next week.
R2-030165 Proposed CR to 25.331 [R99] on Additional measurement reporting list Nokia
R2-030166 Proposed CR to 25.331 [Rel-4 shadow] on Additional measurement reporting list Nokia
R2-030167 Proposed CR to 25.331 [Rel-5 shadow] on Additional measurement reporting list Nokia
This document was presented by Luis Barreto from Nokia.
Discussion:
The number of measurements per type could be limited to one.
Decision: The CRs were revised into R2-030455, R2-030456, and R2-030457. CR numbers: 1829, 1830 and 1831.
R2-030455 Proposed CR 1829 to 25.331 [R99] on Additional measurement reporting list Nokia
R2-030456 Proposed CR 1830 to 25.331 [Rel-4 shadow] on Additional measurement reporting list Nokia
R2-030457 Proposed CR 1831 to 25.331 [Rel-5 shadow] on Additional measurement reporting list Nokia
This document was presented by Luis Barreto from Nokia.
Discussion:
Decision: The CRs were agreed (as they were).
R2-030168 Proposed CR to 25.331 [R99] on Handling of security parameters when SIM is present Nokia
R2-030169 Proposed CR to 25.331 [Rel-4 shadow] on Handling of security parameters when SIM is present Nokia
R2-030170 Proposed CR to 25.331 [Rel-5 shadow] on Handling of security parameters when SIM is present Nokia
This document was presented by Luis Barreto from Nokia.
Discussion:
Subclause 8.3.7.4: the deletion was challenged.
Question: Does the change justify a R’99 change ?
What is wrong without the CR ?
A “should” for the R’99 will be used instead.
How are the start values handled in GERAN ?
Decision: The CR will be revised into R2-030458.
R2-030458 Proposed CR to 25.331 [R99] on Handling of security parameters when SIM is present Nokia
This document was revised before presentation into R2-030557.
R2-030557 Proposed CR to 25.331 [R99] on Handling of security parameters when SIM is present Nokia
This document was presented by Luis Barreto from Nokia.
Discussion:
The last action added should be the first one that the UE does.
Decision: This will be merged with the Motorola CR (R2-030483). |
