To: HG who wrote (16097 ) 3/5/2003 8:50:22 PM From: 49thMIMOMander Respond to of 25898 Agree, as many others, on that uncomfortable-laugh relief. Belongs to "social pain" class. However, the basis for "laughter" is "pain" when that "pain" is relieved. To feel "the pain" on also has to "identify" with whatever experiences the pain, classic examples "Chaplin tripping on a banana peel", and two possibilites for the relief - Chaplin gets up, no real damage done - wasn't me, it was some poor looser Another classic example is "using the wrong fork at a dinner", some of the mroe american are "stiff party until everyone falls into the pool", or "throw food on each other". All within the tradition of "classic medieval upper-lower class" humor, but not really about "slaves". However, US "minstrel" stuff also includes that aspect, but my point is - "guilt" is a form of "pain" only through "identification" Other forms of "social pains" is "fear" of stuff like being "faulty" (stupid, stuttering, short,long,fat,thin,etc,etc..) However, both pain from upper-lower-class, master-slave,etc depends on the capability to "identifiy" to feel the pain of "the real object of the pain" --- Well, the really basic "pains" have to do with "poo-poo" and sex... wrong time or wrong place or for some in almost any way... Sorry, listnening to the "Way and Means committee", difficult to concentrate, but anyway, there is this (first) basic book on humor by Freud, and Hollywood is one of the present experts on it. Much of the stuff is obviously connected to "those times", somewhat difficult to understand now, but, IMO, more basic, or meaningful than the "anthropologic stuff" (although they are very close, in some variations of both) However, that "guilt" is, IMO, just an intermediate byproduct. (few laughs at Chaplin tripping on a banana peel because of "guilt"?? well, except for a feeling of guilt for laughing the first time, or another time??) Ilmarinen Another reason for reading that Freud stuff, one can have double and triple-fun.. ANyway, the LOL-people are funny...