SI
SI
discoversearch

We've detected that you're using an ad content blocking browser plug-in or feature. Ads provide a critical source of revenue to the continued operation of Silicon Investor.  We ask that you disable ad blocking while on Silicon Investor in the best interests of our community.  If you are not using an ad blocker but are still receiving this message, make sure your browser's tracking protection is set to the 'standard' level.
Politics : Foreign Affairs Discussion Group -- Ignore unavailable to you. Want to Upgrade?


To: frankw1900 who wrote (89993)4/4/2003 3:20:35 PM
From: gamesmistress  Read Replies (1) | Respond to of 281500
 
And it's one, two, three strikes he's out...

French PM: U.S. Made Triple Mistake Starting Iraq War
Thu Apr 3, 6:34 PM ET

By Jon Boyle

PARIS (Reuters) - French Prime Minister Jean-Pierre Raffarin said on Thursday the United States had made a moral, political and strategic mistake by launching war in Iraq (news - web sites), risking further damage to already strained ties with Washington.

Raffarin told France 3 television that Paris wanted U.S. and British forces to prevail but offered blunt criticism of the U.S. policies that led to the conflict.

There was no immediate reaction from the White House.

"The Americans made a triple mistake: first of all a moral mistake, and I think we have to say this: there was an alternative to war. We could have disarmed Iraq differently."

That was clear by Washington's failure to secure a U.N. resolution authorizing military action should Iraq fail to destroy its alleged weapons of mass destruction, he said.

"Also, (they made) a political mistake, because we know very well the difficulties of this region of the world," he added. "We see how serious the Israeli-Palestinian conflict is, and at any moment it can set the world ablaze. It's a serious political error to start trouble in this region.

"And then, there is a strategic mistake: that today one country can lead the world," he said, arguing that Europe should be one of the major poles of influence in the world.

Raffarin's blunt assessment of U.S. policy appeared at odds with efforts earlier in the week to play down differences with the United States. The French authorities had expressed concern over the anti-U.S. tone of protests against the Iraq war.

On Monday Raffarin urged the nation to remember the United States was a long-standing ally and that Iraqi President Saddam Hussein (news - web sites) was a dictator.

"Just because we're against this war doesn't mean we want dictatorship to defeat democracy," he said then. "We are in the democratic camp. The Americans are not enemies."

In Thursday's interview the French prime minister, who traditionally leaves major foreign policy issues to President Jacques Chirac, dismissed suggestions France wanted anything other than a victory of U.S.-British forces.

"I say clearly, there can be no hesitation for France. We cannot be on the side of dictators....We are obviously not in favor of a victory of a dictatorship."

After being savaged as "surrender monkeys" by parts of the U.S. media, and vague threats of a U.S. consumer boycott of French goods, Paris has launched a determined campaign to avoid portrayal as a Saddam sympathizer.

Last week the foreign ministry protested loudly over reports in some British and U.S. media that French Foreign Minister Dominique de Villepin had refused to publicly state Paris wished a victory of Anglo-American forces fighting in Iraq.

Chirac on Thursday also sought to ease strains caused by France's opposition to the war being fought by British and U.S. troops in Iraq.

He sent a letter of apology to Britain's Queen Elizabeth over the defacing last week of British World War One military graves in northern France with anti-British slogans linked to the fighting in Iraq.

"Know that at a time when your soldiers are engaged in combat, the thoughts of the French are naturally with them," he said. The gesture was welcomed by Downing Street.



To: frankw1900 who wrote (89993)4/4/2003 3:22:11 PM
From: kumar  Respond to of 281500
 
It apparently was an Iraqi appalled at her treatment who told Coalition forces where she was.

news.bbc.co.uk



To: frankw1900 who wrote (89993)4/4/2003 6:41:34 PM
From: Ish  Read Replies (1) | Respond to of 281500
 
He was more than appalled and the US owes him the greatest thanks for getting Ms Lynch home alive. If you want to read what happened here's the story.

Message 18795437

MARINE COMBAT HEADQUARTERS, Iraq, April 3 -- Mohammed, a gregarious 32-year-old Iraqi lawyer, went by the hospital in Nasiriyah one day last week to visit his wife, who worked there as a nurse, when he noticed the ominous presence of security agents.

Curious, he asked around, and a doctor friend told him an American soldier was being held there. Something made him want to go see. The doctor took him to a first-floor emergency wing where he pointed out the soldier through a glass interior window -- a young woman lying in a bed, bandaged and covered in a white blanket.

Inside the room with her was an imposing Iraqi man, clad all in black. Mohammed watched as the man slapped the American woman with his open palm, then again with the back of his hand. In that instant, Mohammed recalled today, he resolved to do something. After the man in black left, Mohammed sneaked in to see the young woman.

"Don't worry, don't worry," he told her. He was going for help.

As he recounted the events today, that decision set in motion one of the most dramatic moments in the first two weeks of the war in Iraq. Five days later, after Mohammed located U.S. Marines and told them what he knew, Black Hawk helicopters swooped in under cover of darkness, touching down next to the six-story hospital, and a team of heavily-armed commandos stormed the building. With hand-scrawled maps from Mohammed and his wife, the commandos quickly found the injured Pfc. Jessica Lynch and spirited her away to safety.

Mohamed said he decided to save the 19-year-old soldier because he could not bear to see her beaten in the hospital. "My heart is cut," he recalled of his reaction when he saw her. "I decided to go to the Americans and tell them about this story."

Mohammed and his family were flown to this crude desert camp by helicopter today to stay the night before being taken to a refugee center in the southern port city of Umm Qasr. They were allowed to clean up in a makeshift "shower" fashioned out of a giant cardboard box and then given clothes to wear -- an MTV shirt for Mohammed's wife, Iman, and an oversized military T-shirt for his 6-year-old daughter. When Mohammed mentioned that he would love an American flag, the Marines rushed to find one.

"He's sort of an inspiration to all of us," said Lt. Col. Rick Long, who hosted the family in his trailer for a dinner of Meals Ready to Eat tonight.

If not for his help, the Marines said, they might never have been able to rescue Lynch. "The information was dead-on," said Col. Bill Durrett, who was helping process their refugee status to keep them safe from reprisals.

Lynch was part of a convoy from the Army's 507th Ordnance Maintenance Company that made a wrong turn at the city of Nasiriyah on the banks of the Euphrates River on March 23 when it was ambushed by Iraqi paramilitary fighters. The U.S. invasion force was being attacked by Saddam's Fedayeen, a militia formed by President Saddam Hussein's son Uday.

Several of the soldiers were killed in the attack, and Lynch returned fire, according to the account given by U.S. officials. Lynch's family said today that she was not shot or stabbed, as early intelligence reports had indicated. Five soldiers were captured in the attack, while seven are still listed as missing in action.

In a German hospital, Lynch underwent back surgery today to repair a fracture that was pinching a nerve. She is suffering two broken legs and a broken arm. She spoke by telephone with her parents in Palestine, W. Va.

Mohammed, whose last name is being withheld at the request of the Marines, set off the chain of events that led to Lynch's rescue. . Mohammed was born in Najaf, a holy city to Shiite Muslims like him. He displays an easy smile and is quick to say "welcome." He studied law and a little English in Basra in southeastern Iraq and became an attorney. He and his wife did what they could to make a decent life for themselves and their daughter; they had a house and a Russian-made car. But, as Mohammed told it, they longed for the day Hussein would fall.

So when he saw some Fedayeen in the hospital, he concluded they were up to no good. He said he knew some of them personally. Asked about them, he simply shook his head. "Very bad," he said, switching back and forth from English to Arabic. "Very, very, very, very bad. There's no kindness in my heart for them." Mohammed recalled that, after the war began, he watched them drag a dead woman's body through the street, apparently killed because she waved at a U.S. helicopter.

When he first saw Lynch that day, he said the Iraqis were talking about amputating her leg, which had been injured during or after the attack. Mohammed said he urged his doctor friend to stop the amputation. When he went in to see Lynch, he said, she mistook him for a doctor.

"A person is a human being regardless of nationality," he explained today. "Believe me, I love Americans."

The same day he saw Lynch he said in an account vouched for by the Marines, Mohammed set out by foot to find the Americans. The Marines had been trying to secure a route on the eastern side of Nasiriyah to keep critical supply convoys flowing over a pair of bridges that took them across the Euphrates. Mohammed said he walked six miles out of the town center before he came across some Marines.

He said he approached them with his hands raised.

"What do you want?" a Marine asked.

"I have important information about woman soldier in hospital," he replied.

Mohammed was taking a chance, not only in defying Iraqi authorities but in approaching the Marines. Saddam's Fedayeen and their allies had been dressing in civilian clothes to get close to U.S. troops, sometimes even faking surrender, only to open fire at short range. U.S. troops have also fired on civilians at checkpoints.