To: AllansAlias who wrote (72068 ) 4/25/2003 12:51:47 AM From: The Freep Respond to of 209892 <<Do people actually consider this triple top in the Dow to be a shorting opportunity?! >> Allan -- I think that's a little too simple. As Mish's post linked, there were other things going on at the same time: Naz and Sox making double tops with Jan, the BKX against that 800, the SOX apparently completing a bearish Gartley, many folks had the S+P completing a wee E on a wedge (though I couldn't quite tell how it was counted) around 915-920, GE tested Shack's channel, volume was decreasing on the rise, things like Les's scans indicating a top of some kind soon (even if just a day or two of selling before more up), the VIX at silly low RSI levels AND suffering from 12 straigh lower closes at one point, and so on. I would agree that in and of itself, a triple top is not a great short. But if one wanted to start adding, on the idea that some day we will reverse and plunge to new lows, it seems like it wasn't a bad time (note: I am VERY mildly short and probably won't be by the EOD tomorrow. It was scalping stuff, some closed already). The thing is, while I respect the big C... and still give it odds of happening... my contrary brain said that it seemed most likely we wouldn't make it through all that the first time. You know, give bears hope, scare the bulls, then proceed. We'll see if it happens, cuz there was nothing today to scare the bulls. I also right now am fervently embracing your middle bite strategy for my bigger trades. There will be tons of room if we're going to new lows... and if we are going to break out, there might even be a middle to play there. Anything else seems dangerous to moi. the freep