SI
SI
discoversearch

We've detected that you're using an ad content blocking browser plug-in or feature. Ads provide a critical source of revenue to the continued operation of Silicon Investor.  We ask that you disable ad blocking while on Silicon Investor in the best interests of our community.  If you are not using an ad blocker but are still receiving this message, make sure your browser's tracking protection is set to the 'standard' level.
Politics : Foreign Affairs Discussion Group -- Ignore unavailable to you. Want to Upgrade?


To: lorne who wrote (96930)4/30/2003 1:02:18 PM
From: FaultLine  Read Replies (1) | Respond to of 281500
 
Hello lorne;

How about this one. Is it welcome? or will it also come under censorship.

Your question would have been more credible if you had PM'ed the material to me first. Under the circumstances, I'll read it a little later this morning and post my thoughts.

As for your other questions:

What's OK? Reading a few hundred posts, especially the early ones, should give one a clear understanding of what we, those who share a common vision of our educational goals here, generally consider worthwhile.

Censorship: The censorship rules/posting guidelines (whatever...) on the Foreign Affairs Discussion Group are stricter in several ways than on other moderated forums one may have frequented. After 97,000 posts in 18 months and 500 bookmarks, things seem to be working about as well as one could expect I suppose.

Sources: There are too many good sources to list but if you stick to researching the major think tanks, the best foreign affairs journals, the major metro papers (NYT, WPost, LATimes, etc.), most any foreign paper (if presented within a context of why this is important to us), certain blogs (entertaining dot-connecting but otherwise rarely useful IMO), and the major foreign policy authors/wonks, you will be just fine.

We routinely vet new sources. An earlier examination of your reference demonstrated that certain political and religious axes were being ground by this website owner; this is unsuitable material for FADG. In general, highly politically oriented material has proven to be our greatest source of discord and thread bloat. Since there are so many more suitable sources for our educational needs, it's obvious where the real pay-off is...

If you have any suitability issues in the future, please feel free to PM the material to me and we can discuss its potential usefulness to the FADG poster/lurker community.

We each share a responsibility to the 500 others who are allocating time from their busy schedules to read our contributions. I take it seriously.

Thank you for your contributions,
--ken/fl



To: lorne who wrote (96930)4/30/2003 1:12:23 PM
From: FaultLine  Respond to of 281500
 
Hello lorne;

Concerning:
>>http://www.muslimedia.com/ARCHIVES/oaw01/franc-algr.htm
>> France and Algeria unconcerned by revelations of French atrocities.

1. The piece clearly reflects a certain point-of-view. Describing that bias, or world-view, up-front, and suggesting how we could perhaps get a less slanted picture of reality, is always useful.

2. Since no one is discussing this topic right now, you clearly wish to put it on the table. Presenting us with a clearer picture of why this topic merits our attention -- who are the major players (and their motivations ), a little historical summary leading up to this point, and what, in your opinion, are the credible sources of information on this topic -- that would be very much appreciated and in the spirit of our educational goals.

Thank you for your questions,
--fl



To: lorne who wrote (96930)4/30/2003 1:33:52 PM
From: epsteinbd  Respond to of 281500
 
Nothing new here. TV debates including Le Pen (as torturer) took place ten years ago at prime time.
SDECE(FR CIA) heads wrote theirs memoirs in the eighties and said it all.

I've often asked the Algerians adults, a bit provocatively, how come the don't hate the French for the million Arab deaths (against fifty thousand French, soldiers, colonialists and shoemakers.)

And they don't hate. They forgave. They moved on...