SI
SI
discoversearch

We've detected that you're using an ad content blocking browser plug-in or feature. Ads provide a critical source of revenue to the continued operation of Silicon Investor.  We ask that you disable ad blocking while on Silicon Investor in the best interests of our community.  If you are not using an ad blocker but are still receiving this message, make sure your browser's tracking protection is set to the 'standard' level.
Politics : Stockman Scott's Political Debate Porch -- Ignore unavailable to you. Want to Upgrade?


To: lurqer who wrote (21205)6/28/2003 12:21:16 PM
From: stockman_scott  Read Replies (2) | Respond to of 89467
 
We went to war under false circumstances

_______________________________________

By NORMAN READ
GUEST COLUMNIST
Seattle Post-Intelligencer
Friday, June 27, 2003
seattlepi.nwsource.com

There's been a subtle change in the White House message lately. George W. Bush has begun speaking about being certain we'll find an Iraqi weapons program.

Finding Iraqi weapons of mass destruction proved to be difficult for a couple of reasons. They haven't existed in any threatening quantity in the past few years. The incompetent attempts by the Bush government to facilitate the manufacture of evidence for their existence have been a failure.

The Bush government's PR strategy is admirable in that it is breathtakingly bold. It depends to a high degree on adaptability, and it shows a high dependence on flexibility. These are the qualities that made the successful early armored thrusts of the German army so distinctive in World War II.

Rather than construct set-piece PR campaigns, the Bush government notion is to throw a number of tactics at the wall, see what sticks and go with that. If the facts aren't there, it doesn't matter. Shout them down. If confronted with obvious evidence that the facts don't support their assertions, throw the assertions themselves into the memory hole and attempt to change the original assertions.

Those of us with functioning memories can go all the way back to fall of 2002 and remember that the Bush government repeatedly stated that Iraq was an imminent threat to the United States because of its weapons of mass destruction and only war could end its threat to these shores.

It was repeatedly stated that we had plenty of evidence, and that the threat was so great that the United States had to use violence immediately to destroy it.

But now, those of us who had dared doubt that a desperately poor third world country, under constant attack by the world's greatest military power would choose to invade the U.S. home territory or attack it with chemical weapons, have been proved correct.

The Axis of Good has proven incompetent at manufacturing believable evidence (the Nigerian nuclear documents and British Prime Minister Tony Blair's plagiarized "dossiers").

However, the Bush government has proven very competent at infuriating its own intelligence service, thus ensuring a steady supply of embarrassing leaks.

So what to do? It's simple. It's nuance. It's adaptive. The first strategy is to announce, with the means of the television and the right-wing talk radio echo chambers, that weapons of mass destruction were never that big a deal. This war was all about liberation. We're the Axis of Good -- we free oppressed people. It's just what we do.

Unfortunately for that particular marketing campaign, the Iraqi people have an unusual way of showing their gratitude. It's almost as though every ambush, every rocket-propelled grenade, every sullen look from the street says, "You are invaders. Get out of our country."

So that's not going to work, and we're back to answering questions about the non-existence of weapons of mass destruction.

The Bush government chooses to handle it with nuance. Manufacturing physical evidence can be tricky. Experts can be brought in and show that items have been faked. How much more elegant to change the emphasis slightly. We'll find a weapons of mass destruction program.

Turns out that's easy to do, because all anyone has to do is find a few poor, scared scientists and bureaucrats and offer them the right combinations of threats and money. It's even easier when the administration controls the printing presses that churn out Iraqi dinar (even if they do still bear Saddam's portrait).

Suddenly, there can be piles of testimony that "prove" that Iraq under Saddam had a weapons of mass destruction program. There's just one problem: That's not the reason the U.S. taxpayers and the Congress were told that they were going to invade a sovereign nation. Ninety billion dollars later, there are 10,000 to 20,000 people who are now dead as a result.

There was no imminent threat. Which means we went to war under false circumstances. Which means we were lied to -- repeatedly. In a true constitutional government, lying is, and should be, an impeachable offense.

Are we up to it?

_____________________________________

Norman Read lives in Seattle. Submissions for Our Place in the World, of up to 800 words, can be e-mailed to editpage@seattlepi.com; faxed to 206-448-8184 or mailed to the Seattle Post-Intelligencer, P.O. Box 1909, Seattle, WA 98111-1909.



To: lurqer who wrote (21205)6/28/2003 12:24:36 PM
From: T L Comiskey  Respond to of 89467
 
Two Missing U.S. Soldiers Found Dead
32 minutes ago

By PAUL HAVEN, Associated Press Writer

BAGHDAD, Iraq - The bodies of two U.S. soldiers missing for days were discovered early Saturday northwest of Baghdad, as the toll rises past 200 for Americans killed since war started in Iraq (news - web sites).



News of their killings came amid a torrent of guerrilla-style attacks and sabotage that has marred U.S. efforts to re-establish order since Saddam Hussein (news - web sites)'s ouster. About a third of U.S. troops killed in the Iraqi conflict have died in attacks or accidents since major combat was declared over May 1.

Sgt. 1st Class Gladimir Philippe, 37, of Linden, N.J., and Pfc. Kevin Ott, 27, of Columbus, Ohio, were reported missing Wednesday from the town of Balad, 25 miles north of Baghdad.

Soldiers on the ground and using Apache attack helicopters had scoured the area, and U.S. interrogators were questionning at least six men arrested in the soldiers' disappearance.

Their bodies were found 20 miles northwest of the capital early Saturday, U.S. Central Command spokesman Lt. Cmdr. Nicholas Balice said in Tampa, Florida.

"We have always anticipated and were prepared for what we term as pockets of resistance," Balice said.

"We anticipate that we'll be dealing with the situation for some time. But our soldiers are trained, they're prepared, and they're over there knowing that this is the mission they have at hand."

At least 61 U.S. troops have died since the official end of fighting in Iraq — at least 23 of them in attacks.

In the latest violence, attackers lobbed a grenade at a U.S. convoy making its way through the predominantly Shiite Thawra neighborhood of northeast Baghdad just after 11 p.m. Friday. One American soldier was killed, and four soldiers and a civilian Iraqi interpreter were injured, military spokesman Sgt. Patrick Compton said.

Also Friday, a soldier shopping in a market was shot in the neck and critically wounded, part of the violence that has put American troops increasingly on edge. That same day, an 11-year-old Iraqi boy was gunned down by American troops who mistook him for a gunman.

The persistent drumbeat of attacks and ever-harsher U.S. crackdowns has sparked frustration on both sides.

Saboteurs also have been attacking Baghdad's power grid and oil pipelines, foiling coalition efforts to restore basic services like water and electricity as temperatures climb as high as 117 degrees.

On Saturday, a cloud of black smoke billowed from one of Baghdad's largest textbook printing plants, and coalition forces arrested two men in the incident.

"We think it was an act of arson," said Lt. Col. James Otwell, a civil affairs liaison working with the Iraqi fire department.

Until recently, almost all violence against occupying forces occurred in Sunni areas north and west of Baghdad, where Saddam Hussein mined support. But attacks this week have spread into the Shiite majority south.

On Saturday, British soldiers moved back into Majar al-Kabir, a predominantly Shiite southern town where clashes earlier this week that left six soldiers dead. A group of Shiite clerics and prominent town officials greeted the soldiers in a ceremony aimed at putting the acrimony in the past.

"We are not here for retribution. We are here to re-establish communications and get the (rebuilding) process back on the road," said Capt. Guy Winter, of Dover, England, who made initial contact with the Iraqi delegation.



The daily bloodshed has overshadowed progress made since the end of the war. Iraq's vital oil industry has resumed, if only at a fraction of its prewar output, and will be pumping much-needed dollars into state coffers. Police and court systems are also coming back on line, providing hope for improved law and order despite persistent crime.

Even something as simple as an evening concert is seen as a victory in occupied Baghdad, where bandits roam unlit nighttime streets and residents live largely by candlelight.

Iraq's National Symphony Orchestra held its first concert Friday since Saddam's ouster, performing a patriotic song that predates the former dictator and was rarely played during his brutal, 35-year reign. Saddam didn't like the song, "My Nation," which contains no mention of him or his Baath party.

Many Iraqis present had tears in their eyes. U.S. soldiers, some sitting with their guns, clapped after the performance, and L. Paul Bremer, the top U.S. official in Iraq, stood in respect. "My nation ... My nation ... Am I going to see you safe, blessed, victorious and esteemed?" the Iraqi audience sang as the orchestra played.

Still, the killing and wounding of Iraqi civilians has heightened distress over the U.S. occupation — resentment felt by Iraqis who welcomed the fall of Saddam as well as by Saddam loyalists blamed for violence against U.S. forces.

Some Iraqi civilians have died in anti-American attacks, such as two national electricity workers killed Thursday when ambushers threw grenades at a U.S.-led convoy.

The soldiers wounded in the convoy attack late Friday were evacuated to a combat support hospital, the military said. No arrests were made and no further details were immediately available.

Also Friday, insurgents fired rocket-propelled grenades at U.S. troops in Fallujah, 30 miles west of Baghdad, and a U.S. patrol exchanged fire with attackers near Habaniyah, just west of Fallujah. The incidents caused no damage or injuries.

Soldiers at a checkpoint Friday arrested four Iraqi men after finding rocket-propelled grenades, small arms and grenades in their vehicle, the military said.

The daily grind of ambushes has hampered U.S. efforts at reconstruction.

"These are guys who want us to fail. They'd rather see their country burn than have it succeed," said Maj. Scott Slaten, of the Army's 1st Armored Division. He said the attacks won't stop coalition troops, "but it does slow us down a little because we have to focus more effort on security."

____

EDITOR'S NOTE: AP correspondent Chris Tomlinson in Habaniyah contributed to this report.



To: lurqer who wrote (21205)6/28/2003 1:51:32 PM
From: stockman_scott  Read Replies (2) | Respond to of 89467
 
Message 19069705