SI
SI
discoversearch

We've detected that you're using an ad content blocking browser plug-in or feature. Ads provide a critical source of revenue to the continued operation of Silicon Investor.  We ask that you disable ad blocking while on Silicon Investor in the best interests of our community.  If you are not using an ad blocker but are still receiving this message, make sure your browser's tracking protection is set to the 'standard' level.
Politics : PRESIDENT GEORGE W. BUSH -- Ignore unavailable to you. Want to Upgrade?


To: DavesM who wrote (458337)9/13/2003 1:47:15 PM
From: Skywatcher  Respond to of 769670
 
Then there's the Bush Government.....
Exploiting the Atrocity
By Paul Krugman
The New York Times

Friday 12 September 2003

In my first column after 9/11, I mentioned something everyone with contacts on Capitol Hill already
knew: that just days after the event, the exploitation of the atrocity for partisan political gain had
already begun.

In response, I received a torrent of outraged mail. At a time when the nation was shocked and
terrified, the thought that our leaders might be that cynical was too much to bear. ``How can I say that
to my young son?'' asked one furious e-mailer.

I wonder what that correspondent thinks now. Is the public - and the news media - finally prepared to
cry foul when cynicism comes wrapped in the flag? America's political future may rest on the answer.

The press has become a lot less shy about pointing out the administration's exploitation of 9/11,
partly because that exploitation has become so crushingly obvious. As The Washington Post pointed
out yesterday, in the past six weeks President Bush has invoked 9/11 not just to defend Iraq policy
and argue for oil drilling in the Arctic, but in response to questions about tax cuts, unemployment,
budget deficits and even campaign finance. Meanwhile, the crudity of the administration's recent
propaganda efforts, from dressing the president up in a flight suit to orchestrating the ludicrously
glamorized TV movie about Mr. Bush on 9/11, have set even supporters' teeth on edge.

And some stunts no longer seem feasible. Maybe it was the pressure of other commitments that
kept Mr. Bush from visiting New York yesterday; but one suspects that his aides no longer think of the
Big Apple as a politically safe place to visit.

Yet it's almost certainly wrong to think that the political exploitation of 9/11 and, more broadly, the
administration's campaign to label critics as unpatriotic are past their peak. It may be harder for the
administration to wrap itself in the flag, but it has more incentive to do so now than ever before. Where
once the administration was motivated by greed, now it's driven by fear.

In the first months after 9/11, the administration's ruthless exploitation of the atrocity was a choice,
not a necessity. The natural instinct of the nation to rally around its leader in times of crisis had
pushed Mr. Bush into the polling stratosphere, and his re-election seemed secure. He could have
governed as the uniter he claimed to be, and would probably still be wildly popular.

But Mr. Bush's advisers were greedy; they saw 9/11 as an opportunity to get everything they wanted,
from another round of tax cuts, to a major weakening of the Clean Air Act, to an invasion of Iraq. And
so they wrapped as much as they could in the flag.

Now it has all gone wrong. The deficit is about to go above half a trillion dollars, the economy is still
losing jobs, the triumph in Iraq has turned to dust and ashes, and Mr. Bush's poll numbers are at or
below their pre-9/11 levels.

Nor can the members of this administration simply lose like gentlemen. For one thing, that's not how
they operate. Furthermore, everything suggests that there are major scandals - involving energy policy,
environmental policy, Iraq contracts and cooked intelligence - that would burst into the light of day if
the current management lost its grip on power. So these people must win, at any cost.

The result, clearly, will be an ugly, bitter campaign - probably the nastiest of modern American
history. Four months ago it seemed that the 2004 campaign would be all slow-mo films of Mr. Bush in
his flight suit. But at this point, it's likely to be pictures of Howard Dean or Wesley Clark that morph
into Saddam Hussein. And Donald Rumsfeld has already rolled out the stab-in-the-back argument: if
you criticize the administration, you're lending aid and comfort to the enemy.

This political ugliness will take its toll on policy, too. The administration's infallibility complex - its
inability to admit ever making a mistake - will get even worse. And I disagree with those who think the
administration can claim infallibility even while practicing policy flexibility: on major issues, such as
taxes or Iraq, any sensible policy would too obviously be an implicit admission that previous policies
had failed.

In other words, if you thought the last two years were bad, just wait: it's about to get worse. A lot
worse.

CC