To: Biomaven who wrote (1149 ) 1/7/2004 1:32:13 PM From: Henry Niman Read Replies (1) | Respond to of 4232 Below the official Chinese news agency acknowledges that the second patient with SARS symptoms has SARS antibodies, but no longer has a fever. This second case some remarkably like the confirmed case. It will be interesting to see if any sequence data can be obtained from the second patient. The key question raised by these two unlinked cases which happened at about the same time, is how may SARS CoV infected people are there with even milder symptoms? Last season the case fatality rate rose as did the mutations. The reliable of the reports have some question marks, but last year there were only 5 reported deaths among the first 305 cases, yielding a case fatality rate of 1.6%. By the time the epidemic emerged from the Metropole Hotel and spread internationally, the rate rose 10 fold. It was even higher in Mainland China and Taiwan, but then at the end of the epidemic, the rates reported by mainland China and Taiwan plummeted, to bring the worldwide rate below 10%. Moreover, after the fact Taiwan went back and reclassified 1/2 of the cases that were SARS CoV positive and called them SARS-CoV "related" and this dropped their case fatality rate even more. In fact they lowered it so much that the rate was lower for the SARS CoV positive suspect cases than the SARS CoV negative - they managed to show that SARS CoV infections saved lives! In any event, regardless of the reliability of case fatality reports, the SARS CoV clearly accumulated mutations. There were 27 early mutations and the earliest isolated, GZ01, only had 2. Likewise another early isolate, GZ43, only had 4. By the time SARS emerged from the Metropole Hotel, all linked isolates (as well as all isolates outside of mainland China) had all 27 positions mutated (which was in addition to 23 mutations found in all human isolates). This year the first sequence of the S gene is identical to a civet isolate. However, the isolate is more "humanized" indicating it already has some of the human mutations that were not found in animal isolates last year. Last year most of the mutations arose in February, March, and April. This year the earliest isolates seem to have more mutations than last season at this time. I'm sure that this year both patients and sequences will be closely monitored..www1.chinadaily.com.cn No symptoms from 2nd suspected case ( 2004-01-07 23:54) (China Daily) The second suspected case of SARS, a female restaurant employee, has had no fever symptoms for eight consecutive days, local medical experts said yesterday. The patient was exposed to the public for the first time by authorities on January 5. She had tested positive for severe acute respiratory syndrome (SARS) antibody on her first test, said Guangzhou Respiratory Disease Research Institute Director Zhong Nanshan on Monday in Hong Kong. More tests were to be conducted to decide whether she was in fact a suspected SARS case or not, Zhong added. Tests have been conducted everyday, but the results remain unknown, said a source in provincial medical circles.