To: Tenchusatsu who wrote (181318 ) 1/22/2004 7:36:53 AM From: Road Walker Read Replies (4) | Respond to of 1574002 Ten, re: Do you feel ethical sending someone who never chose to be in the military into a war that you don't support? That's exactly what you are asking for just to make your political point. It's not a political point, it's an ethical and pragmatic point. On the ethical side, it is the country that is going to war; we are going to war. And the we is inclusive of all US citizens. Without the draft, you essentially have a mercenary armed services, made up of those that like armed services life (or are not trained for other options). You are paying a guy with your taxes (or in this administrations case with your deficits) to take your place on the battlefield. It's a mercenary army, not a citizens army. On the pragmatic side, if there was a significant chance that you might have to spend the next year of your life in Iraq figuring a way to survive, intact; well it brings home the reality of the sacrifice of the war. It clarifies the issue, the sacrifice, the trade-off for the presumed benefit. Your proxy in Iraq may have already lost his or her life, or suffered grave physical or emotional injury. Because of the devastation of war, in this case 500+ US folks dead, many thousands injured, ~15,000 Iraqi's dead, God knows how many injured, the decision to go to war should always be the very last, desperate option. In a Democracy the life of every citizen has equal value to the Democracy. The draft is a great equalizer, and a great way for everyone to sacrifice for their country on an equal basis. If called tomorrow, would you go? Would you want to go as your patriotic duty? Would you still support the war? I don't want you to answer those questions to me, but you should answer them to yourself. If the answer is "no" to either question, then you ought to rethink your support of the war. John