SI
SI
discoversearch

We've detected that you're using an ad content blocking browser plug-in or feature. Ads provide a critical source of revenue to the continued operation of Silicon Investor.  We ask that you disable ad blocking while on Silicon Investor in the best interests of our community.  If you are not using an ad blocker but are still receiving this message, make sure your browser's tracking protection is set to the 'standard' level.
Strategies & Market Trends : India Coffee House -- Ignore unavailable to you. Want to Upgrade?


To: JPR who wrote (12467)6/30/2004 2:50:16 PM
From: Thomas M.  Read Replies (1) | Respond to of 12475
 
<<< It's important to bear in mind that there are two quite different Indias.

There is the high tech India in Hyderabad, which Thomas Friedman raves about in his odes to "globalization" -- meaning, the neoliberal version of investor-rights-based international economic integration. I've been there in the scientific research centers too, and what he says is not false. Same with the consumer culture. That's one India. If one takes the trouble to look at Hyderabad, and certainly to go a few miles beyond to the rest of the state of Andhra Pradesh, of which Hyderabad is the capital, one sees a very different India. For a view of that, I'd suggest a look at the July 2 issue of the fine Indian weekly Frontline, which I think is internet-accessible. Its lead story is about the very sharp rise in suicides of peasants in Andhra Pradesh since Congress took office in May, about 300 they estimate. The official reason is drought, but the real reason is that under the neoliberal regime, the state has withdrawn from providing basic services such as water, credit, seed, etc., and poor farmers are being driven to export crops, which vary wildly on international markets. The result is that peasants, tenants, landless rural workers are driven to a cycle of indebtedness at usurious rates, and when they have no more bodily organs to sell, and cannot provide for their families, they take their lives in desperation. The plague extends beyond, but is dramatic in this pearl of India, its exciting high tech center. India is incidentally producing plenty of food, much of it rotting because starving people can't afford to buy it -- though Friedman's friends are doing fine.

You can find more about the background of peasant suicides in Andhra Pradesh in Robert Pollin's excellent book, Contours of Descent-- mainly about the real story of the Clinton economy that also inspires great awe (and in the current period of worship of the PR-created image of Reagan, is attributed to that divine figure. If you're interested in a more general picture, I'd suggest a fine book by the Oxford development economist and India specialist Barbara Harriss-White, India Working, based on her own extensive field work and many other sources. Her book is about the part of the population of India that is in the informal or black economy, outside of official statistics and the starry-eyed gaze of those awed by the successes of "globalization": close to 90% of the population. You can learn more in depth about particular regions in such studies as Jean Dreze and Amartya Sen, Indian Development: Selected Regional Perspectives, for example the study there by Dreze and Gazdar of Uttar Pradesh, a state of about 160 million people with one of the lowest female to male ratios in the world, not because of female infanticide but because of the miserable treatment of women, reminiscent of the Taliban but of no more concern than their fate was under the Taliban until they became an official enemy, and the hideous conditions of life generally. There are exceptions in India, notably Kerala and to an extent West Bengal, which have a somewhat different history, including long period of Communist Party government and influence.

It's possible that Congress will smooth some of the rough edges slightly, but not much. The new Prime Minister is the architect of the neoliberal reforms, and these conditions developed under Congress Party rule. Congress will also presumably try to rein in some of the fanatic Hindu fundamentalism that was encouraged and supported by BJP. But the problems are much deeper. >>>

blog.zmag.org



To: JPR who wrote (12467)3/15/2005 9:05:51 AM
From: JPR  Respond to of 12475
 
Married at 12, mother at 14, divorced at 15
What is being done about it?

Hindu Sunday, Dec 07, 2003
Married at 12, mother at 14

K.K. GOPALAKRISHNAN comments on "Padom Onnu: Oru Vilapam" that focuses on problems faced by teenage Muslim girls in Kerala forced into early marriage.

THE premiere of "Padom Onnu: Oru Vilapam" (Lesson One: A Wail), T.V Chandran's latest film, saw protests from a group of Islamic periodicals of Kerala. The date of release was postponed more than once for two reasons: theatre owners were afraid of getting involved in a sensitive issue dealing with the minority community. The other was a suspicion of the film's commercial viability.

But, at the recently concluded International Film Festival of Dacca, the film bagged the gold medal for best film and attracted much attention in a predominantly Muslim country. The general feeling of serious film-viewers in Bangladesh was that "it is our story" and there was a demand to exhibit it in "our villages".

Shoukath Aryadan, the son of a politician and ex-minister, produced the film. Recently, Shoukath spoke about several threatening calls suspected to be from a notorious Islamic fundamental group, adding "the honour it earned from a Muslim country like Bangladesh shows that my film is not anti-Islamic."

"Padom Onnu: Oru Vilapam" tells of the woes of Muslim girls in the interior villages of Malappuram, a district in Kerala dominated by Muslims.

Young girls around 12 to 14 years are married off to elderly men as their second, third or fourth wife, thus violating their fundamental rights for education and freedom. The local school is the platform for the bride-seekers to choose their brides, which happens in some Muslim centred villages.

The main consideration of such weddings is the dowry that either enables the groom to go to the Gulf in search of better pastures or raise funds to return the earlier wife's dowry during a divorce.

Divorce in the community is as common as a wedding, drawing a new theory that almost every wedding is followed by a divorce. The teenage wife is never asked for an opinion either for marriage or divorce.

Poor girls, divorced within months of their wedding, return home often in a pregnant state. Mothers when barely 14 or 15 they live in poverty as single parents.

The film develops through the story of Shahina (well known actress Meera Jasmine), an unusually intelligent 14-year-old. Shahina is the only daughter of Safiya (noted Mohiniattam exponent Pallavi Krishnan), a divorced single woman in her late twenties who struggles to make a living by selling snacks in local eateries.

When Safiya realises that her daughter also has to go through such a grind, the shock kills her and Shahina is one more in the number of teenage mothers.

Through several anecdotes, director T.V.Chandran, who penned the script, unveils the general situation. Chandran, known for his advocacy of women's issues, also shows the silent protest of the Muslim women.

At one point, when the teenage Shahina frees herself from the clutches of her husband, Razak, (Irshad) by scuffing on his face, his first wife applies medicine on the scratches. On seeing this, his mother, (Roselyn), comments, "Where else would one see the first wife applying medicine on the scratches from the second wife?"

When Razak tells her of his decision to divorce the adamant Shahina — this after raping her by giving a sedative through his first wife — the mother responds, "Aren't you the seed of a father wedded four times?"

SUDHEER

T.V. Chandran
Safiya dares to send divorced Shahina to school. Even Safiya is shocked when there is a proposal that her divorced daughter become the fourth wife of Hajiar, the most important man in the locality. Safiya reminds her brother and the village broker, who approach her with the proposal sans any dowry, that the Hajiar is older than her own father but this falls on deaf ears.

Another significant character is the teacher of the village school, Kasim master, (Babu Annur) always saddened by his students' sudden disappearance due to marriage. Kasim questions the marriage of under age girls and proclaims it to be against Islam and is blamed by the Hajiar for lack of progress in his views. Kasim is blamed for Shahina's pregnancy, as Razak claims during divorce that he has not touched her. The villagers point to Kasim, who gave her private lessons to compensate for the break in her schooling.

Chandran and cinematographer Jayan have visualised some of the best scenes of contemporary Indian cinema, through "Padom Onnu: Oru Vilapam". The tragic theme of the film exposes the travails of a community in a fully literate State like Kerala.

However, unlike Chandran's other works like "Mankamma" or "Susanna", the character of Shahina does not leave a deep impression on the viewer. Perhaps the thematically vibrant topic subdued this.

There are a few arresting moments in the film. The daily trudge of the teenage Shahinas to the river is haunting.

The last shot where innocent children cry and play on the riverbank while their unfortunate pubescent mothers bathe and wash is an unforgettable wail.

Printer friendly page
Send this article to Friends by E-Mail