SI
SI
discoversearch

We've detected that you're using an ad content blocking browser plug-in or feature. Ads provide a critical source of revenue to the continued operation of Silicon Investor.  We ask that you disable ad blocking while on Silicon Investor in the best interests of our community.  If you are not using an ad blocker but are still receiving this message, make sure your browser's tracking protection is set to the 'standard' level.
Politics : Politics for Pros- moderated -- Ignore unavailable to you. Want to Upgrade?


To: Nadine Carroll who wrote (32085)2/28/2004 12:49:30 AM
From: LindyBill  Respond to of 793587
 
A Time to Dance, and Mourn
By DAVID BROOKS

As you read this on Saturday morning, my elder son, Joshua, will be having his bar mitzvah. We'll be doing what many parents do on these occasions: telling stories about him, worrying about the party this evening.

But it will be hard to miss the larger meaning of the ceremony because Joshua will be having his bar mitzvah in downtown Washington in a newly restored synagogue that hasn't seen a bar mitzvah in over half a century. On the day we rehearsed, there were three Torahs in the ark, none of them used since World War II. One was confiscated by the Nazis at the entrance to Auschwitz. Another was smuggled into Bergen-Belsen.

The third, from which Joshua will read, was written in Wegrow, Poland, and is the only one of the 13 Torahs in that town to survive the Holocaust.

Wegrow (pronounced VEN-gwoov) is about 55 miles northeast of Warsaw. Jews settled there early in the 16th century, and there were 6,000 to 8,000 of them when the Nazi occupation began on Sept. 7, 1939. A few weeks later, on Yom Kippur, SS officers went to the home of the town's rabbi, Mendel Morgenstern, dragged him to the central marketplace and ordered him to undress. They handed him a broom and told him to sweep up the manure in the square and carry it to the town dump in his velvet hat. As the rabbi tried to do that, a soldier drove a bayonet into his abdomen, killing him. His synagogue was immediately closed and ultimately destroyed.

The Nazis set up a Jewish governing body, a "Judenrat," to collect taxes and supply forced-labor teams. News about the concentration camp in nearby Treblinka swept the town, but the roundups in Wegrow didn't begin until the day after Yom Kippur in 1942.

A few families had constructed hiding places in attics and basements, and they could watch through peepholes as their relatives and friends were loaded onto trucks. By that time everyone knew exactly what was going to happen. Some cursed the Germans; some lunged at the soldiers and tried to scratch their eyes.

"I want to live a little longer," one girl told her mother as they stood in line. "No, you will not live because the world has no room for you," her mother answered bitterly.

The roundups lasted for several days. About half the Jews in the town fled to the nearby forest, where almost all were hunted down and shot by German troops. (Poles received two pounds of sugar for every Jew they killed or captured.)

The other Jews waited. One father, furious at the universe, announced that he was going to turn in his family immediately. He was told to hide and think of his children. "If my children remain alive, they will curse me for not having allowed them to die earlier," he answered.

At night, those in hiding could hear Germans celebrating the deportations. By day they watched their former neighbors taking over their stores and businesses.

Some Jews did survive. About a hundred were kept in the town to work, though they were herded into a building on May Day 1943 and burned to death. Others hid in farms and in the forest for the duration of the war. The last survivors included Feivel Bielawski. When the Nazis were driven back, he and his brother returned and sat for days on the front step of their old house. "Freedom did not bring happiness," he wrote in his memoir. "We were sad and depressed and longed to see another Jew." But, of course, there were none.

Feivel Bielawski, who became Phil Biel, died 15 days ago in Minnesota.

Joshua will be reading in a neighborhood brought back from decay, in a synagogue restored to its former self, from a Torah that not only recounts history, but is itself history. There will be an amazing sense of threads' being retied. And there will be reminders that we're mysteriously bound by things that happened before we were born and to people, now dead, whose lives are interwoven with our own. "What their species is for animals and plants, that is history for human beings," the 19th-century historian Johann Droysen observed.

In today's ceremony the Book of Exodus will mingle with the Holocaust, and a child will be recognized as an adult, which means not only following God's commandments, but also taking responsibility for the future, guided by the light thrown by the past.

Copyright 2004 The New York Times Company



To: Nadine Carroll who wrote (32085)2/28/2004 2:59:06 AM
From: LindyBill  Read Replies (2) | Respond to of 793587
 
Arafat storms out of Fatah meeting
By JPOST.COM STAFF

Palestinian Authority Chairman Yasser Arafat stormed out of a meeting of the Fatah revolutionary council Thursday, following a shouting match with security advisor, Nasser Yussef, regarding security reforms, reported IBA news Friday morning.

Yussef questioned Palestinian security forces ability to function efficiently without reforms.

"You traitor, spy, shut your mouth, you have no right to talk," Arafat was quoted as shouting to Yousef before hurling a microphone at him.

Yousef chucked a pen at the veteran Palestinian leader before other members of the Revolutionary Council intervened and calmed down the two septuagenarians, the official said.

Arafat and Yousef have clashed several times in the past, most recently when the Palestinian leader prevented Yousef from serving as security chief in Prime Minister Ahmed Qurei's government.

Council members said after a morning session Friday that Arafat had reiterated their reform demands, but they were uncertain anything more would come of them.

"This meeting enforced Arafat's power as the leader," council member Amin Maqbol said. "He adopted the reforms that were in our minds, but the question is whether these reforms will be implemented on the ground after the meeting ends."

'The message was that Fatah had resolved its internal crisis'

Council member Ahmed Ghneim said the meeting had two messages: That Fatah had resolved its internal crisis, and that the movement supports peace efforts.

Yousef - along with other members of Fatah and the Palestinian Authority - has long called for reforms in the security forces.

Arafat has been stalling and opposing reforms, including a recent demand by the European Union that some 25,000 security officers be paid directly to their bank accounts.

Currently, cash is given to officers who then distribute the money among their employees.

The 126-member Fatah revolutionary council, Fatah's second highest body, is supposed to meet every three months. Wednesday, it convened for the first time in three years for a three-day meeting in an effort to solve the crisis resulting from the recent resignation of scores of activists.

They resigned over what they said is widespread corruption among the old guard and armed street patrols by para-militaries.



To: Nadine Carroll who wrote (32085)2/28/2004 9:45:42 AM
From: LindyBill  Respond to of 793587
 
Column One: Surrealism vs Reality

Caroline Glick Feb. 27, 2004
JPost

The events of this week, which opened with eight Israeli terror victims being buried at the same time as Israel was placed on trial at The Hague for trying to defend itself from terror, have about as much in common with reality as a painting by Salvador Dali.

There is something surreal in the spectacle of thousands of Israelis and our supporters marching through the streets of a Dutch city holding pictures of our terror victims as Israel is libeled in a show trial produced and directed by our murderers.

There is something surreal about the picture of gowned judges marching into a courtroom to hear arguments about how a law is broken when Israel attempts to prevent more of its citizens from being murdered by terrorist armies.

There is something surreal about the televised footage of Avi Ohayon – whose two small sons Ohad and Matan and ex-wife Revital were gunned down in their home by a Fatah terrorist – begging cameramen to take his picture with their photographs.

And there is something grotesque about the fact that the British and Swedish governments are paying the salaries of the Palestinian "lawyers" who stand before a kangaroo court and claim that Israel is breaking a law, any law, in trying to prevent more children and mothers from sharing this fate.

Given the surrealism of the show at The Hague, it is difficult to take the proceedings seriously.
How can we be expected to believe that such an evil, crude and disgusting lie can actually have any impact on our lives? But of course it does impact us.

The International Court of Justice will no doubt soon hand down an opinion saying that Israel is wrong to defend itself against the wanton murder of its citizens, killed for the crime of being Jews.

In the aftermath of the ICJ's expected opinion, Israel will come under ever-increasing international pressure to allow in foreign troops who will be tasked with protecting our murderers from our defenders.

How have we arrived at this point? How is it that after three and a half years of absorbing massacre after massacre that Israel now finds itself on trial?

The answer to this question is found in part in the latest State Department Human Rights Report. Released Wednesday, the report finds both Israel and the Palestinian Authority guilty of countless human rights abuses. Of course, it is balanced.

Of course, it duly notes that the PA security services have themselves conducted terror attacks against Israeli civilians. Yet aside from condemning every action Israel has taken to combat terrorism and thereby equating actions aimed at protecting Israeli citizens with terrorism, the report does something even more offensive.

The report very sensitively gives the names of a dozen or so Palestinian children who died during Israeli assaults against Palestinian terrorists who used these children for cover.

Yet, grotesquely, while the names of Palestinian children are listed, the report provides not one name of any Israeli victim of Palestinian terrorism. Not the Ohayon children, not 14-year-old Abigail Litle who was murdered on a bus on her way home from school and not the names of hundreds of other Israeli men, women and children who were murdered last year.

By naming Palestinian victims while not giving names of Israeli victims, the State Department report follows in the path of the general climate that has gripped us for the past 40 months. This general climate is characterized by the dehumanization of Israelis and Jews by the international community.

This dehumanization prevents anyone from ever seeing the victimization of Israelis. By balancing condemnations of Palestinian terrorism with condemnations of Jewish communities in Judea, Samaria and Gaza, our critics, even those among us, are cheapening the value of our lives.

By arguing that Israel abuses human rights when it defends itself against an enemy which has declared its aim as genocide, the State Department, like the UN, the EU, the foreign media and international human rights organizations, is creating a false reality where Israel is not fighting a war against an enemy bent on its physical destruction. Rather, Israel is simply being mean.

As if the perfidy of its human rights report wasn't enough of a jolt for us, the next day the State Department also saw fit to criticize the IDF operation Wednesday in Ramallah where our forces seized some NIS 40 million in terror funds.

Dali himself would have been impressed with State Department Spokesman Richard Boucher when he claimed that the operations were "destabilizing to the Palestinian banking system" given the fact that the PA itself uses its banking system to transfer funds to terrorists.

Unfortunately, the surrealism of our current plight doesn't end at The Hague or at the State Department. And it doesn't begin there either. It begins here, in Israel.

As the terror victims marched in front of the Hague to defend Israel's right to build the security fence, Shin Bet director Avi Dichter was at the Knesset explaining that the fence we care so deeply about will not long protect us.

Dichter said on Tuesday that the Palestinians are now seeking to upgrade their arsenals in order to carry out attacks that will render the fence irrelevant. Both the PA security forces and the terrorist cells, Dichter said, are improving their artillery capabilities in order to launch shells over the fence. In addition, they are seeking to attain chemical weapons.

And then there is the terror financing. Our forces went to the banks in Ramallah on Wednesday to dry up terrorist bank accounts and this is all for the good. But our government is the main financier of the terrorists.

Israel transfers some NIS 130 million to the PA in tax revenues every month arguing that the money isn't going to terrorists. Yet we know that PA budgetary funds finance terror.

Dichter himself acknowledged that ten percent of the PA budget is transferred to Arafat's office. And Arafat, he said, is directly involved in financing terrorism.

And the surrealism doesn't end here either. Last week Ma'ariv reported that to date, security forces have prevented nine attempts by Palestinians to take down jetliners taking off or landing at Ben Gurion Airport.

Israel has argued strenuously before the Bush Administration that to protect the flights from rocket and missile attacks it is necessary to construct the security fence far enough away from the airport to keep it out of rocket and artillery range. This involves extending the fence several kilometers north and east of the 1949 armistice lines. It seems to make sense.

And yet, The Washington Post reported on Thursday that Prime Minister Ariel Sharon "appears ready to abandon a proposed second fence around Ben-Gurion Airport."

Then there is Sharon's newest emissary to Washington – not Dov Weisglass or Foreign Minister Silvan Shalom – but Labor head MK Shimon Peres.
At the beginning of the week, Peres, fresh from a political powwow with Sharon, turned up in Washington for talks with US Secretary of State Colin Powell and National Security Advisor Condoleezza Rice.

Addressing a gathering of Washington peaceniks later, Peres said Monday that Israel has no moral right to Judea and Samaria. In his words, transferring one hundred percent of Judea, Samaria and Gaza to the Palestinians, "is not a political decision, it is a moral decision."

So here then we have it from none other than the head of the loyal opposition and the man who Sharon apparently now sees as a possible coalition partner if the National Union and the NRP bolt his government.

In the analysis of Peres, all of Israel's detractors are right. It is immoral for us to be defending ourselves. It is immoral for us to stake our claim to territory against the Palestinian claims. It is immoral for us to refuse to finance a PA that is so immersed in terror there is no way to give it money it without contributing to the finance of our own murder.

It isn't the security fence that stood for trial this week at the Hague. It is Israel's very legitimacy that now stands before an international tribunal.

So at the end of the day it doesn't matter that the fence will not defend us. It doesn't matter that we get criticized for seizing terrorist funds that we ourselves are providing.

What matters is that we ourselves contribute through our apologetics for our need to defend ourselves to the dehumanization of our people and the cheapening of our lives.

This article can also be read at jpost.com



To: Nadine Carroll who wrote (32085)2/28/2004 1:36:22 PM
From: J_F_Shepard  Respond to of 793587
 
Never said that....so let's keep this discussion going on the basis of what we do say, not how we think we distort the other guys writings.... Many acts of heroism go unrecognized, we all know that.....

Gotta finish this later...