To: Elizabeth Andrews who wrote (10777 ) 3/24/2004 11:05:11 AM From: Steve Lokness Respond to of 110194 Elizabeth; Interesting comments even if some of them sound as if they were drafted by Greenspan. I will be so bold as to take issue with a few of them. 1) <<today’s wars do not suck up a disproportionate amount of commodities except cash>> The Iraq war is a tiny war compared to what we have previously called "wars" and yet it has had major influences on commodities. The example I have used is that OSB the product used in virtually all buildings today has gone from 5 to 18. The reason most often given is that the government suddenly came into the market (not caring what they paid) and bought trainloads of the stuff to use as temporary throw away buildings in Iraq. If you don't think the government played a MAJOR role in this commodity, then what caused the increase? 2) <<The housing bubble is media babble>> This comment sounds as if it was right from the mouth of Greenspan!! If people lose money in Yahoo, while it might hurt, it is not disastrous. If people suddenly wake up one morning and find their adjustable rate mortgage has jumped to a rate they cannot afford - THEY LOOOSE THEIR HOME! 3) <<the public right now is choosing housing because it is probably cheaper than owning the stock market as a store of wealth. It is no more complicated than that.>> More Greenspan bizarre thinking!! This is really just a continuation of the last thought and yet is is so dangerous that I repeat! People are doing just exactly what you say and are placing huge bets on second (or THIRD) homes, refinancing to buy SUV's or WalMart junk, or additions onto their existing homes. If this doesn't scare you, it should!!! Why? The same thing will happen to housing that happened to Yahoo in the example you provided. (Did you set me up for this thinking or do you really NOT understand the consequences of decreasing home values?) If Yahoo crashes, everyone still have their Yahoo stock which afterall is just an investment. If HOUSING crashes, bankruptcies mushroom and all of those businesses so dependant on a healthy building industry (ALL THOSE JOBS WHICH CANNOT BE OUTSOURCED!!) also go bust. But this time it is even more significant!!!! because housing via refinancing has been keeping personal spending roaring as they fill up their pockets with cash from their home equity!! Greenspan is absolutely nuts on this one! The physcological damage this would do to our economy is huge and could take a very very long time to recover from. 4) <<The problems will occur if the Fed starts contracting the money supply, which they aren’t about to do.>> And this is the problem - they can't raise rates because of what it will do to the housing industry and they can't leave them where they are because of the roaring inflation as witnessed most significantly in the housing industry. Elizabeth, the housing (mortgage) bubble has the potential to make the last bubble look tiny in comparison. Watch housing - not silver or gold - for the answer to where we go from here. Steve