To: Kayaker who wrote (324 ) 4/30/2004 11:54:25 AM From: Jeffrey S. Mitchell Respond to of 6035 If someone is using their real name as their alias and then for whatever reason they wish to become anonymous, should that not be respected? That depends. There are plenty of company insiders that used to post on their own thread on SI. It's invaluable to be able to go back and re-read their posts before they were "smart enough" to use aliases. As for individuals, I'm not sure. Case in point: me. I use my real name. First off, should I be treated any differently than anyone else, even a company CEO? If the answer is yes, do I even have any "rights"? Once I post something on SI, doesn't SI now own the right to perpetuate it for as long as they deem fit? In other words, whatever concession they make would be nothing more than a favor for me. Rather than discuss a host of scenarios, this would be my policy: 1. If someone is new to SI, uses their own name, and suddenly realizes they made a mistake doing so, I'd allow them to change to an alias with no official mention of it (i.e. any record of it in their profile or via a people search). 2. If someone is not new to SI, uses their own name (like me), and suddenly realizes they made a mistake doing so, I'd tell them to simply make a public farewell and stop posting using that account. I'd then allow them to open a brand new account under an alias. The old account stays intact "as is" (i.e. with their real name still attached). If someone tries to out them, that's their problem. 3. If someone uses one alias and wants to switch to another, I'd allow that every six months and I'd maintain a log of past aliases -- with dates -- in their profile. I wouldn't let them start a new account unless they had a compelling reason to do so. - Jeff