To: Jim McMannis who wrote (19911 ) 10/13/2004 4:12:58 PM From: Elroy Jetson Respond to of 110194 Under-reporting inflation makes a sick economy look good on paper. Inflation does not indicate a strong economy, usually quite the contrary. It's also true that you can have a very strong economy with no inflation, or even deflation. When you're locked inside the Monetarist fun-house, like our economy is, it can become confusing. According to a Monetarist, rising commodity prices means the economy is too strong and needs higher interest rates to cool off. In our current global economy rising commodity prices indicate the the Chinese economy is very strong and is increasing their use of commodities dramatically beyond their historical rate of use. It also indicates the high level of speculation because interest rates are too low and money is too available. Here in America, the economy is very weak due to excessive debt. The Fed's only solution is to increase the debt load of consumers, business and government, even more to keep demand up. They call this "increasing the money supply." Ideally, the Fed wants to keep internal prices in the US constant while the excess money supply steadily decreases the value of the US Dollar. This gives every business a profit-cut and every worker a pay-cut allowing us to export our way out if debt. But certain imported items bring inflation home in spite of their best efforts, oil is the best example. If the government did not under-report inflation, three problems would occur: First the reported Growth Rate of the economy would shrink by the amount by which they were under-reporting inflation, down to what the growth rate really is. The amount of under-reported inflation shows up in the national accounts as "productivity" so the productivity miracle of the past ten years would evaporate, lowering investor confidence; Second, if inflation is really 4% or 5% the current Fed Rate of 1.75% is negative, inappropriate and even scary. If inflation was reported correctly, the Fed could not pump debt money into the economy as fast as they can now and the real weakness would become obvious; If the Fed believes they need to keep pushing money into circulation they need to hide under a reported inflation rate lower than the real one. Third, if the CPI reported actual inflation, contracts indexed to the CPI will push inflation through the economy more thoroughly (materials suppliers, Social Security, labor contracts. Under-reporting inflation is a con job which makes a staggering economy look just fine - unless you understand a little about economics, but that's a relatively small group.