To: TobagoJack who wrote (55122 ) 10/30/2004 2:23:04 AM From: elmatador Respond to of 74559 My hat is off for you Jay! <<Americans lost the understanding of freedom and confused it with rights>> First you know that I don't like the nation-state, neither I like governments. 1) I have angered many foreigners by telling about "rights for this and rights for that" they have on their countries. And I think it must already have dawned on you, long time ago, that diplomacy is not one of my strong points. 2) I mentioned, on other conversations, about people who has not known what freedom is, and when they get it, they don't know what to do with it. They just screw up real good. And I have a 21-year experiency living outside Brazil and I know how other foreigners fare out there. 3) I lived and worked most of the time with Germans. That people need laws and regulations, for every simple and small thing and they got and amazing amount of "rights for this and rights for that" (*). Why? Because they don't know what common sense is. For me common sense is something that you don't have to write a contract, you don't have to ask the government to pass a law, and you don't need that bunch of guys who gang up togetherto 'defend' any rights. CONCLUSION: There are limited people around the world, who are limited in terms of gray mass, and they need an apparatus to arrange the world around them in such way that works and make sense for them. But because those countries with 'law and order' and other apparatuses of control, remove freedom from their citizens, and freedom is messy, they perform economically better, because order is good for the economy. And the masses love it. In this respect, Lee Yew of Singapore, US, Germany, Suharto's Indonesia and Mahatir's Malaysia, are no different. Then there are countries with a lot of freedom but they have not had stellar economic progress, 'wirtschaftwunder' but the people there, perhaps, have different priorities and prefer freedom. Among them, are some who prefer economic progress and emigrate. (*) Porsche, the carmaker, is now trying to end a right of 5 minutes break every hour for the asembly line workers have.