SI
SI
discoversearch

We've detected that you're using an ad content blocking browser plug-in or feature. Ads provide a critical source of revenue to the continued operation of Silicon Investor.  We ask that you disable ad blocking while on Silicon Investor in the best interests of our community.  If you are not using an ad blocker but are still receiving this message, make sure your browser's tracking protection is set to the 'standard' level.
Politics : Foreign Affairs Discussion Group -- Ignore unavailable to you. Want to Upgrade?


To: Neocon who wrote (153000)11/30/2004 4:14:01 PM
From: Sun Tzu  Read Replies (1) | Respond to of 281500
 
>> I did not see anything about who may have researched or written the report under their aegis.

But that did not stop you from assuming that the board personally wrote the report. Why is your assumption reasonable? In fact, have you ever seen a high powerful board actually write its own reports instead of assigning it to others? And even if they wanted to write it themselves, how would they do it? I can't see the board members going to the Persian Gulf and interviewing the public.

>> Second, they are supposed to advise on technical issues.

And that is exactly what they are doing. The technical issue at hand was how to communicate to the Muslim public and convince them to turn against AQ. The problem they found out was total and utter lack of credibility of US.

>> Third, I have no idea how the advisory board came into being

Nonetheless it is a government organization who produces reports for the powers that be. Therefore somebody must have asked for their opinions and that person had to have been related to this administration.

>> so I can read nothing into its relationship with the current administration.

That is not all you cannot read. You seem to be reading none-existent information according to your bias and ignore all contrary evidence short of God Almighty actually personally calling you for a chat and teleporting you back in time and place.



To: Neocon who wrote (153000)11/30/2004 4:22:07 PM
From: Sun Tzu  Read Replies (1) | Respond to of 281500
 
>> I can read nothing into its relationship with the current administration.


This report is a product of the Defense Science Board (DSB). The DSB is a Federal
Advisory Committee established to provide independent advice to the Secretary of
Defense. Statements, opinions, conclusions, and recommendations in this report do
not necessarily represent the official position of the Department of Defense.



To: Neocon who wrote (153000)11/30/2004 4:30:58 PM
From: Sun Tzu  Read Replies (1) | Respond to of 281500
 
>> Perhaps they could join us on FADG.

Not likely!


The Task Force met with representatives from the National Security Council (NSC), White House Office of Global Communications, Department of State (DOS), Department of Defense (DOD), Broadcasting Board of Governors (BBG), and the private sector (the schedule of meetings, briefings and discussions is contained in Appendix C). Based on extensive interaction with a broad range of sectors in the government, commercial, and academic worlds, as well as a series of highly interactive internal debates, we have reached the following conclusions and recommendations.


Appendix C: Briefings Received by the Task Force

March 31 – April 1, 2004
Dr. Barry Fulton, Public Diplomacy Institute and Research Professor, GWU
Mr. Paul Hanley, Strategic Communications, Office of the CJCS
Mr. Jeff Jones, NSC
Mr. Rob Tappan, Strategic Communications, Coalition Provisional Authority (CPA) in
Iraq
Mr. Jim Wilkinson, Deputy National Security Advisor for Communications

April 20 – April 21, 2004
Ms. Mary Catherine Andrews, White House Office of Global Communications
Mr. Jeremy Curtin, Department of State
Mr. Ryan Henry, Principal Deputy Under Secretary of Defense for Policy (PDUSD(P))
Mr. Peter Kovach, Department of State
Mr. Lloyd Neighbors, Department of State
Mr. Tom O’Connell, Assistant Secretary of Defense, (SO/LIC)
Mr. Steve Schaffer, Department of State
Mr. Frank Ward, Department of State
Ms. Betsy Whitaker, Department of State
Mr. Sam Wunder, Department of State

May 19 – 20, 2004
Mr. Dan Kuehl, National Defense University
Mr. James Farwell, DOD (SO/LIC)
Mr. Mouafac Harb, Al Hurra Network
Mr. Mark Helmke, Senate Foreign Relations Committee
Mr. David Morey, DMG, Inc.
Mr. Joe Norris, Foreign Broadcast Information Service
Dr. Marc Sageman, Private Practice in Forensic and General Psychiatry
Mr. Mike Vlahos, John Hopkins University

June 8, 2004
Mr. James Farwell, DOD (SO/LIC)
Mr. Scott Miller, Core Strategy Group
Mr. Seth Cropsey, International Broadcast Bureau
Mr. Jim Glassman, American Enterprise Institute

June 10, 2004
Mr. John Rendon, The Rendon Group



To: Neocon who wrote (153000)11/30/2004 5:26:29 PM
From: Michael Watkins  Read Replies (1) | Respond to of 281500
 
I'm not going to go through the entire list for you, but ask yourself this: what would the motivation be for the Defense Department to produce a report which invalidates your cherished notions?

Secondly, since you are always keen to give Rumsfeld and Gang the benefit of doubt - above and beyond any sensible application, then you MUST assume that the Defense Department would not staff a strategic board with morons that oppose your world view.

Appendix B: Strategic Communication Task Force Membership

Chairman Mr. Vince Vitto C.S. Draper Laboratory
- Committee on Science and Technology for Countering Terrorism

Executive Secretary Mr. Mark Ellis OUSD

Members

Dr. Anita Jones University of Virginia
- Lawrence R. Quarles Professor of Engineering and Applied Science
- "Challenges for the Future," Military Operations Research Society's Phalanx Magazine, March 1996.
- "Engineering in the Fast Lane", The Bridge, National Academy Press, Vol. 25 No. 4, September 1995.
- "Where Economic Security and National Security Intersect," Army Research, Development and Acquisition Bulletin, July-August 1994.

Mr. Bran Ferren Applied Minds, Inc.
(seems an odd pick until you note his connections)

disinfopedia.org

Currently held positions include National Security Agency Advisory Board, National Reconnaissance Office Technical Advisory Group, Army Science Board Member, Defense Science Board member, Chief of Naval Operations Executive Committee, Senate Select Committee on Intelligence Technical Advisory Group, Securities and Exchange Commission Advisory Committee on Technology, Federal Communications Commission Technological Advisory Committee, National Imagery and Mapping Agency Advisory Forum

Mr. Bruce Gregory George Washington University
smpa.gwu.edu

Director and Research Professor, Public Diplomacy Institute
Expertise

Public diplomacy, media and national security, strategic international communication, national security strategy and process, U.S. international broadcasting

Mr. Dan Kuehl National Defense University

Dr. Joe Markowitz Consultant
- Intelligence in Support of the War Against Terrorism (Co-Chairs: Dr. Joe Markowitz and ADM Bill Studeman) This study, co-sponsored by USD(AT&L), ASD(C3I), and DCI will identify capabilities, technologies and approaches for strengthening intelligence in support of the war against terrorism. (CDR Hughes)
- Managing Foreign Intelligence by
Focusing on Ends vice Means
(Co-
Chairs:
Dr. Craig Fields and Dr. Joe Markowitz) This study, co-sponsored by USD(AT&L) and the Assistant Secretary of
Defense (C3I), will address alternative ways of managing US foreign intelligence endeavors in support of national security, by focusing not on the means by which intelligence information is collected, but rather the ends it is to serve. The Final Report is in Draft. (CDR Waugh)

Mr. David Morey DMG, Inc.

David Morey, founder, President, and Chief Executive Officer of DMG, Inc., and partner in Core Strategy Group, is one of the leading strategic communications consultants in America. Prior to establishing DMG, Inc. and Core Strategy Group, he was Director of International Affairs and Special Advisor to the Chairman at J.E. Seagram & Sons, Inc. He is currently Adjunct Professor of International Affairs at Columbia University, specializing in media and politics. Recently, Mr. Morey served as a Chairman of the Council on Foreign Relations' Task Force on Public Diplomacy.

Mr. Robert Nesbit The Mitre Corporation

Dr. Michael Vlahos Johns Hopkins University
Michael Vlahos is currently a senior member of the Joint Warfare Analysis Department at Johns Hopkins University's Applied Physics Laboratory in Maryland.

His research into the war on terror led to the 2001 book, Terror’s Mask: Insurgency Within Islam, now a text in the Navy War College Strategy Department and the University of Chicago Islamic Studies Department.

Mr. Vlahos is a former fellow at the Progress & Freedom Foundation and the Center for Naval Analysis and headed the Center for the Study of Foreign Affairs at the U.S. State Department.

Previously, he served as the director of the Securities Studies Program at the Johns Hopkins School of Advanced International Studies.

He has authored several books published by Johns Hopkins/SAIS and the U.S. State Department, and his commentary has appeared in Washington Quarterly, Foreign Policy, Foreign Affairs, National Review and the Times Literary Supplement.

Government Advisors

Mr. Joel Fischman Department of State
OFFICE OF STRATEGIC COMMUNICATIONS (IIP/SC)
- Senior Advisor Joel Fischman

Mr. David Jakubek DDR&E
- Lieutenant Commander David Jakubek, USN
- Command and Control expert

Mr. Chris Lamb National Defense University
- capabilities and planning expert
- threat assessment
- Defense Planning for CBW: A Policy Challenge, Chris Lamb, Presentation given at the Military Operations Research Society Chemical-Biological Weapons of Mass Destruction Workshop.

Mr. John Matheny Department of Defense SO/LIC
- appears to have been an aide to George H.W. Bush

Mr. Lloyd Neighbors Department of State
- Public Affairs Officer, China, Dept. of State 2003

Mr. William Parker Department of State
OFFICE OF STRATEGIC COMMUNICATIONS (IIP/SC)
- Office Director William V. Parker

Mr. Robert Reilly Department of Defense

Support

Ms. Nicole Coene SAIC

Mr. Mark Mateski SAIC

DSB Secretariat
LtCol David Robertson DSB

etc.