SI
SI
discoversearch

We've detected that you're using an ad content blocking browser plug-in or feature. Ads provide a critical source of revenue to the continued operation of Silicon Investor.  We ask that you disable ad blocking while on Silicon Investor in the best interests of our community.  If you are not using an ad blocker but are still receiving this message, make sure your browser's tracking protection is set to the 'standard' level.
Politics : Politics for Pros- moderated -- Ignore unavailable to you. Want to Upgrade?


To: LindyBill who wrote (97985)2/1/2005 3:30:02 AM
From: LindyBill  Read Replies (1) | Respond to of 793928
 
BOOKS OF THE TIMES | 'WINNING THE FUTURE'
Does Tomorrow Belong to Gingrich's 'Popular Majority'?
By MICHIKO KAKUTANI
WINNING THE FUTURE
A 21st Century Contract With America
By Newt Gingrich
243 pages. Regnery. $27.95

The reviewer is THE classic NYT reviewer. Just what you would expect.

In his sloppy, poorly reasoned new book "Winning the Future," the former Speaker of the House Newt Gingrich sets up an either/or dynamic between "the liberal elite minority" and "the popular majority," and makes this aggrieved assertion: "Since the 1960's, the conservative majority has been intimidated, manipulated and bullied by the liberal minority. The liberal elites who dominate academia, the courts, the press and much of the government bureaucracy share an essentially European secular-socialist value system. Yet they have set the terms of the debate, which is why 'politics as usual' is a losing proposition for Americans."

Never mind that the Republicans currently control the White House and both houses of Congress. Never mind that a majority of the nation's governors are Republicans and that a majority of Supreme Court justices were appointed by Republican presidents. Never mind that Fox News further established itself as the dominant cable news network last year, outdrawing all of its competitors combined in prime time and extending its lead over CNN. Never mind that the Bush administration argues the last election gave it a mandate for the war in Iraq, or that it is now pushing Social Security reform (of a sort supported by Mr. Gingrich) and a conservative agenda on a host of social issues.

Indeed Mr. Gingrich's complaint that "the liberal elite minority is winning and the popular majority is losing" suggests that the author still has a mindset from the 1980's and early 90's (when his party was in the minority and he made a name for himself as a backbench revolutionary). It also points to larger problems with this book as a whole: the author's fondness for reductive Manichean dichotomies; his tendency to ignore facts that might contradict or undermine his thesis; and his substitution of attention-grabbing assertions for thoughtful analysis.

Similar problems contributed to Mr. Gingrich's fall from grace in 1998, when he announced that he was stepping aside as speaker and leaving Congress in the wake of unexpected Republican losses in the midterm elections.

It was a fall brought about, in part, by Mr. Gingrich's reputation as a polarizing bomb-thrower, his proclivity for overreaching, his failure to unite House Republicans around a persuasive agenda and his misreading of the public mood about the impeachment of President Bill Clinton. Combined with voter anger at the Republicans for the budget-related federal shutdowns in 1995 and Mr. Clinton's co-option of issues like welfare reform and a balanced budget, these missteps helped sink Mr. Gingrich, the man who four years earlier had been hailed as a visionary for winning Republican control of Congress with a 52-seat pickup and a controversial Contract With America that proposed to radically cut back the size of the federal government.

In "Winning the Future," Mr. Gingrich hops and skips over his earlier travails to deliver a kind of updated version of the Contract With America, a move that also seems designed as the opening sally in a political comeback attempt. Book-tour stops in Iowa and New Hampshire are on the author's schedule, and much of the volume reads like a platform for a possible 2008 presidential run.

As with the 1994 Contract With America, Mr. Gingrich here stresses less regulation, more free enterprise, lower taxes and fewer entitlements. But some chapters suggest that the author is trying to reposition himself within the Republican Party: whereas Mr. Gingrich, as House speaker, was more identified with tax cutters than with social conservatives and the religious right, he includes an entire chapter in this volume about "the centrality of our Creator in defining America" (in which he rails against what he calls "the secular left's unending war against God in America's public life"). He vigorously endorses President Bush's plan to export democracy to the Middle East (he calls it "the only strategy that can make America secure"), but acknowledges the alarming inadequacies of the administration's postwar planning: "Iraq is a mess," he writes. "It is going to remain a mess for a long time."

Like his 1995 book "To Renew America," this volume is replete with windy talk about big, ambitious plans (in this case, remaking health care and the Social Security system) but short on details, slip-sliding over counter arguments and practical impediments to his vision. Mr. Gingrich calls for an intelligence community "about three times the size of the current system," but fails to explain how this would be paid for, how it would be organized or how current problems (from the F.B.I.'s failed computer systems to interagency turf wars) would be corrected. He writes at length about the difficulties faced by the current Social Security system, but fails to apply equal scrutiny to the risks and costs involved in setting up personal investment accounts.

On other subjects, Mr. Gingrich settles for chirpy, Pollyanna-ish assertions and fuzzy musings about the sort of technological change he has long championed. On health care and balancing the budget, he writes: "We must transform the health system so people can live longer and healthier lives while taking 20 percent out of the cost of the system. We can achieve this through the efficiencies of information technology, and by the kind of waste reduction and productivity increases that have been common in manufacturing for the last 30 years and in service industries for the last 15 years."

Many of Mr. Gingrich's arguments are riddled with gaps in logic. While he repeatedly ratifies the presidency of George W. Bush in this book, he complains that the Supreme Court - which effectively decided the presidential election of 2000 - has become a mechanism by which "appointed lawyers can redefine the meaning of the U.S. Constitution and the policies implemented under that Constitution either by inventing rationales out of thin air or by citing whatever foreign precedent they think helpful." He adds that "this is not a judiciary in the classic sense, but a proto-dictatorship of the elite pretending to still function as a Supreme Court," and yet he cites overrulings and reversals by the Supreme Court to try to impugn decisions made by the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, which he scorns even more.

This same chapter, "Bringing the Courts Back Under the Constitution," is filled with vintage Gingrichian bomblets sure to provoke talk. He asserts that "there is significant precedent in American history for believing that the legislative and executive branches can force the judicial branch into changing its views when they are out of touch with the values of the vast majority of Americans." And he argues that "Ninth Circuit judges who found the motto 'one nation under God' unconstitutional could be considered unfit to serve and be impeached."

These are the sorts of pronouncements that won Mr. Gingrich attention as a minority firebrand before the 1994 elections, but they are also the sorts of pronouncements that got him into trouble as speaker of the House. He seems to be hoping that this time they will help him assume the moniker of the Democratic president he was so obsessed with: the Comeback Kid.

Copyright 2005 The New York Times Company



To: LindyBill who wrote (97985)2/1/2005 3:56:21 AM
From: greenspirit  Respond to of 793928
 
Wow, great article! Reading these quotes today about the election really moved me. I can't help but think Iraq is in good hands with people this elequent and motivated to reach for freedom.

rightwingnews.com
----------

"I bow in respect and awe to the men and women of our people who, armed only with faith and hope are going to the polls under the very real threats of being blown to pieces. These are the real braves; not the miserable creatures of hate who are attacking one of the noblest things that has ever happened to us. Have you ever seen anything like this? Iraq will be O.K. with so many brave people, it will certainly O.K.; I can say no more just now; I am just filled with pride and moved beyond words.

....My condolences to the Great American people for the tragic recent losses of soldiers. The blood of Iraqis and Americans is being shed on the soil of Mesopotamia; a baptism with blood. A baptism of a lasting friendship and alliance, for many years to come, through thick and thin, we shall never forget the brave soldiers fallen while defending our freedom and future." -- Alaa, The Messopotamian

----------

"The turnout in Iraq was really like nothing that I had expected. I was glued in front of tv for most of the day. My mother was in tears watching the scenes from all over the country. Iraqis had voted for peace and for a better future, despite the surrounding madness. I sincerely hope this small step would be the start of much bolder ones, and that the minority which insists on enslaving the majority of Iraqis would soon realise that all that they have accomplished till now is in vain.

Another surprise was to see some Iraqis who had fled the country in fear of reprisals, such as the families of ex-regime figures and ex-Ba'athists, actually voting and encouraging others to vote! I know some of those from school and college and I imagined they would be bitter about the whole process, but many were not.

...I really want to write much much more but I have to run for now. I promise I will post again soon. In the mean time: Hold your head up high, Remember that you are Iraqi." -- Zeyad from Healing Iraq

----------

"In mainly Shi'ite Basra, Iraq's second biggest city, hundreds queued patiently to vote. "I am not afraid," said Samir Khalil Ibrahim. "This is like a festival for all Iraqis."

A small group cheered in Baghdad as Sharif Ali bin al-Hussein, a descendant of Iraq's last king, went to the polls.

...Baghdad's mayor was overcome with emotion by the turnout of voters at City Hall, where he said thousands were celebrating.

"I cannot describe what I am seeing. It is incredible. This is a vote for the future, for the children, for the rule of law, for humanity, for love," Alaa al-Tamimi told Reuters." -- Wired News

----------

"How can I describe it!? Take my eyes and look through them my friends, you have supported the day of Iraq's freedom and today, Iraqis have proven that they're not going to disappoint their country or their friends.

Is there a bigger victory than this? I believe not.

I still recall the first group of comments that came to this blog 14 months ago when many of the readers asked "The Model?"… "Model for what?" Take a look today to meet the model of courage and human desire to achieve freedom; people walking across the fire to cast their votes.

Could any model match this one!? Could any bravery match the Iraqis'!? Let the remaining tyrants of the world learn the lesson from this day." -- Mohammed and Omar, Iraq The Model

----------

"Women in black abayas whispered prayers at the sound of a nearby explosion as they waited to vote at one Baghdad polling station. But the mood for many was upbeat: Civilians and policemen danced with joy at one of the five polling stations where photographers were allowed, and some streets were packed with voters walking shoulder-to-shoulder to vote. The elderly made their way, hobbling on canes or riding wheelchairs; one elderly woman was pushed along on a wooden cart, another man carried a disabled 80-year-old on his back.

"This is democracy," said Karfia Abbasi, holding up a thumb stained with purple ink to prove she had voted." -- Yahoo

----------

"Samir Hassan lost his leg in a Baghdad bombing but that did not stop him reaching the polling station.

"I would have crawled here if I had to. I don't want terrorists to kill other Iraqis like they tried to kill me," said Hassan, 32, propping himself up on worn metal crutches as he queued in the working class district of Hurriya, a mixed Sunni and Shia neighbourhood near the old city.

"Today I am voting for peace. It is the only way, we must vote against them," he added.

With his shoddy clothes hanging off him, and his trouser leg folded up beneath his amputated leg, Hassan hardly looked like a campaigner. But in his eyes, resolute and reddened at the edges, and in his face, scarred by the October blast, there was absolute determination." -- The Times Online

----------

"Great day!

It is the birth of freedom and democracy in Iraq!

It is a great festival!

Today only we may announce the victory!

Today we hit back in the heart of the terrorists and the tyrants!

Today is the day in which the souls of our martyrs comforted!

Today those who were killed in Iraq or wounded among our friends from the USA and other allies, who helped us to reach this day, are with us again to inscribe their names with Gold for ever!

Today we challenged the killers and terrorists and foot on them with our shoes!

Many people walked long distances to vote in a most civilised way!

People asked for more time to enable them to vote!

One woman was crying because she can not reach the requested polling station to vote!

In many parts the police helped citizens to take them with their cars to the polling stations!

As we expected the enemies of God and freedom send their mentally retarded cockroaches in some suicidal attacks.

On the top of our privileged today are those who were killed in their way for voting. Their names should be perpetuated for ever! Their names should be written in Gold in Al-Fordos Square in Baghdad!

Our thanks go to George W Bush who will enter the history as the leader of the freedom and democracy in the recent history! He and his people are our friends for ever!

At this moment the voting closed and we will see the results then!

God bless Iraq and America." -- Hammorabi

----------

"Last night I couldn't sleep well. I was so excited and I wanted to be at the voting center before it even opens its door. I was afraid that I was going to be among a minority who are going to vote, but I was still very happy for rather a different reason. It's that just as I care about the outcome of this election and that democracy would work in Iraq, I cared no less about voting on a personal level. This was my way to stand against those who humiliated me, my family and my friends. It was my way of saying," You're history and you don't scare me anymore". It was my way to scream in the face of all tyrants, not just Saddam and his Ba'athists and tell them, "I don't want to be your, or anyone's slave. You have kept me in your jail all my life but you never owned my soul". It was my way of finally facing my fears and finding my courage and my humanity again.

...As I got out it was still early and I saw no one on the streets but as I got near to the voting center I started seeing people in groups heading the same way. Most of them were women. I saw a crippled man and my old neighbor and his older wife leaning on their walking sticks going to vote. An old woman cleaning her door step stopped me, "Say son, can I go and vote?" She asked after she saw many people going to vote. "Sure Khala (aunt)! Everyone can". She thanked me and went inside apparently to change and get her IDs.

...As I was walking with many people towards the center explosion hit and gun fire were heard but most were not that close. People didn't seem to pay attention to that. Some of them even brought their little kids with them! It's like the Eid but only a thousand times better.

I entered the school and the supervisors showed me the way to were I should vote. They and the ING guys were so polite and gentle. I cast my vote and got out, not in a rush at all. This is my Eid and I felt like a king walking in his own kingdom. I saw the same look of confidence and satisfaction in the eyes of all people I met. As I left one of the gurads said to me as he handed me back my cellular phone,"God bless you and your beloved ones. We don't know how to thank you. Please excuse any inconvinience on our part. We wish we didn't have to search you or limit your freedom. You are heroes" I was struck with surprise and felt ashamed. This man was risking his life all these hours in what has become the utmost target for all terrorists in Iraq and yet he's apologizing and calling us heroes. I thanked him back and told him that he and his comrads are the true heroes and that we can never be grateful enough for their services.

...I'm stil overwhelmed with thoughts and emotions that I don't know what to say more. The only things I can feel so strongly now are hope, excitement, pride and a strange internal peace. I have won my battle and I'm watching the whole Iraqis winning their battle too. I'll try to write to you later my friends.

A'ash Al Iraq, A'ashat America, A'ash Al Tahaluf. (Long live Iraq, long live America and long live the coalition)" -- Ali from Free Iraqi