To: DeplorableIrredeemableRedneck who wrote (8758 ) 2/11/2005 9:57:39 AM From: Haim R. Branisteanu Read Replies (1) | Respond to of 32591 When pigs flew in Britain By Jonathan Romain The day Michael Howard became leader of the Conservative party in Britain back in October 2003 was the day some British Jews began to worry. "It's not good for us to be too high profile," some said, "it will cause a backlash." Others feared that if Howard became prime minister and then made unpopular decisions, the entire Jewish community would suffer from any resultant opprobrium. Such fears have leapt to the fore in the run-up to the general election anticipated in May of this year. A series of posters were produced by the Labour election campaign team and posted on their Web site for party members to peruse and then vote for the best one. One of them attacked Conservative economic policy with the headline "The day the Tory sums add up" and depicted two pigs flying, with the faces of Michael Howard and his Shadow Chancellor Oliver Letwin (who is also Jewish) transposed on them. Some British Jews erupted in outrage at what they considered a contemptible attack on the religious affiliation of the two Conservative politicians. Personally, I was not at all perturbed. Many voters do not know that Howard is Jewish, and certainly not Letwin, so the ad was not pandering to a widely held perception. Even more importantly, there is nothing anti-Jewish about the phrase "pigs might fly." It is in common parlance, and something I often use myself to describe something I consider ludicrous. There is a thin dividing line between vigilance and paranoia, but in this case the poster was clearly an economic opinion rather than a religious jibe. The use of pigs was cleverly linked to a set phrase and not a Goebbels-type image. I was much more bothered by another of the posters, which showed Michael Howard swinging a gold watch and declaring, "I can spend the same money twice." It may indeed be the case, as Labour activists claimed, that it was based on a hypnotist in a popular television series. However, it was uncomfortably close to resembling a Fagin-figure, with anti-Semitic undertones that did not state out aloud but whispered subsconsciously "Jews are good at picking your pocket." Even if - to give Labour strategists the benefit of the doubt - that was definitely not the intention, it was unwise to use an image that could be misinterpreted so easily. The distaste was compounded because only a few days earlier on Holocaust Memorial Day, Prime Minister Tony Blair had declared that "the Holocaust did not start at Auschwitz but with the first brick through a Jew's window." If he had added "and through the first accusation of Jews being untrustworthy in public office," his election managers might have got the message more clearly. It is possible that we Jews have overreacted and seen anti-Semitism where none existed, but I believe it was right to raise the alarm and send a warning shot across the bows of all political parties that in the frenzied approach to an election, they should steer well clear of fanning religious or racial prejudice. It is especially important at this election because of the growing courtship of what is seen as "the Muslim vote," and the danger that some might think it useful to suggest that a Jewish leader would be less well disposed to them. With a Muslim population of 1.6 million compared to 300,000 Jews, some might find the political mathematics very tempting. Still, potential problems should not be confused with actual realities. It would be totally wrong to talk of institutional anti-Semitism in Britain: After all, this whole issue arose precisely because the right-of-center Conservative party chose to elect a Jew as its leader! Moreover, the result was that the two offending posters have been discarded, while the Labour Party has proclaimed its ongoing commitment to fight all forms of racism and bigotry. British Jews were right to protest: Sometimes it is useful to get mainstream political parties to restate the obvious. It is also good to remind people that prejudice never dies, it just lies dormant, and our task is to keep it asleep for as long as possible. Jonathan Romain is rabbi of Maidenhead Reform Synagogue and author of "Jews of England" (M. Goulston Educational Foundation). rabbi@maidenheadsynagogue.org.uk Anti-Semitic? Labour's posters showing Howard with a watch (top) and Howard and Letwin as pigs (above).