To: TobagoJack who wrote (61472 ) 4/2/2005 4:37:00 AM From: energyplay Read Replies (3) | Respond to of 74559 Main energy price puzzle - >$45 / bbl. should produce additional production and conservation, and this price level should not last more than a year - we are at 6 months now, and futures are higher and the price shows little sign of comming down. I don't think most oil producers think the high prices will last, so they don't increase capex for production. If most every producer keeps capex about the same, then prices will stay high MUCH longer. There's a large first mover or rather ONLY mover advantage - much like the classic two person Prisoner's Dilemma. Except for oil company executives, if you overexpand and every one else does, you will lose your job or company. Not expanding is almost completely safe....until Wall Street or your stockholders (or You) decide you have grab these prices - or you see "everyone else moving" ***** There's a similar logic for large expenditures on eneeergy conservation, with much milder consequences, however. ***** So we have an unstable situation, which is likely to resolve by going to extremes - a bi-modal outcome. Not the gaussian normal curve of outcomes. Also, the timming of these outcomes is very uncertain. So most of my risk management tools don't work. We get a 1 or 0, and we don't know when. Like a metastable flip flop.... Maybe a better historical example is the transistions to new generations of D-RAM memory. When these transistions involve building a new fab for xx micron, instead of just better steppers and process tweaks, there has been a similar timing uncertainty. Except in the D-RAM case you know the price direction long term... ***** How low could oil prices go ? The US has a flat yield curve and currently high oil prices - both formulas for a recession. Iraq could stablize soon (another election and accelerated US withdrawal plus more "international" supervision), and get back to about 80% of prewar production in a few months. If much Asian growth goes near flat, then oil in the $30 range would be very possible - if only for about 6 months or so.