To: Slagle who wrote (63092 ) 5/1/2005 5:12:14 PM From: gregor_us Respond to of 74559 There Seems to Be a Range Now on the XLE to XLF. I think where you are on to something is in the comparison between the two. They should both be watched in relation to each other, carefully. I'm less convinced however that money will sustainably depart XLE stocks for XLF stocks.stockcharts.com [h,a]daclyiay[dc][pb50!b200!f][vc60][iut!Ub14!La12,26,9]&pref=G Both have been under pressure, for different reasons. However, I really do question how much an institutional manager is going to give up the dividends, and valuations represented by the XLE universe, for the much lower divs and higher vals, in the XLF. Short-term, it may be percived there's less price risk in the XLF stocks. However, you have to remember that for most middle of the road money managers, they are "afraid" of the future direction of interest rates. What they see is that "The Fed is hiking." It's only the truly savvy that are willing to make a major bet on sustainably lower interest rates, here. (and a nice pop in the Financials.) Yes, the market is set up right now to have some moderate relief in either a) Fed hawkishness, or b) Inflation expectations. I'm currently arguing that if the Fed does NOT blink, just a little, on Tuesday and instead "acts tough", that's going to present a problem for all stocks and without question the XLF. Even though long rates will probably rally on that. Finally, it's important to remember that the vast majority of market participants do not understand interest rates with any depth whatsoever. It's always been that way. And I don't see it changing. For those who do understand interest rates, it is of course very intellectually rewarding. And, discussions of the the future rate environment and the possible behaviour of financial assets in that environment can reach a level that is almost philosphical. As others are noting, Longer Term Puts on the XLF look cheap. And reflect, imo, a tremendous amount of ingrained thinking and confidence these cos. are bullet-proof. Best, LP