Silicon Investor (SI) -- The First Internet Community

STOCKTALK

We've detected that you're using an ad content blocking browser plug-in or feature. Ads provide a critical source of revenue to the continued operation of Silicon Investor. We ask that you disable ad blocking while on Silicon Investor in the best interests of our community. If you are not using an ad blocker but are still receiving this message, make sure your browser's tracking protection is set to the 'standard' level.

Politics : American Presidential Politics and foreign affairs -- Ignore unavailable to you. Want to Upgrade?

To: calgal who wrote (1156)	5/2/2005 2:43:55 AM
From: Peter Dierks	Respond to of 71588

Are You Too Stupid To Manage Your Own Money? by Ed Frank 4/28/05 Finally, after suffering through months of demagoguery from the opponents of Social Security reform, we're beginning to see the true motivation behind their opposition: You're just too stupid to manage your own money. Sure, some opponents have tried to hide their true feelings behind phony arguments like transition costs, supposed benefit "cuts" and talk of Vegas slot machines. But in the past few weeks, we've seen a handful of honest opponents boldly say in public what many less straightforward opponents probably only say when they get together privately. "Are Americans smart enough to manage their own retirement savings?" columnist Froma Harrop asked Tuesday in the Christian Science Monitor. "No, as a matter of fact, they're not. Americans are amazingly dumb about investing," she concluded. In an attempt to boost her case, Harrop points to a mechanic friend who got bilked out of a large sum of money by a con man, corporate employees who only invest in company stocks like Enron, and homeowners who have seen the values of their homes skyrocket in recent years, but who are apparently now too stupid to realize the real-estate market's about to come crashing down around them like a house of cards. In addition to the obvious flaw in Harrop's core argument that Americans are too dumb to manage their own money, she also completely ignores the fact that the personal accounts being proposed for Social Security would be extremely diversified in a wide variety bond funds and stock funds. No shysters on the telephone conning you out of your money. No heavy investment in a single stock like Enron. No housing market crash wiping out your life savings. Harrop's stated belief in the stupidity of everyday Americans comes just a few weeks after the New York Times ran an article by Eduardo Porter headlined, "When It Comes to Managing Retirement, Many People Simply Can't." While Porter's article actually does point out that most people who have invested in 401(k)'s or IRAs have done very well for themselves, the focus is on the fact that some people -- 15 percent by the Times' estimation -- have not exactly maximized their returns or made the correct investment decisions 100 percent of the time. The clear implication in the Times' headline, as in Harrop's column, is that personal accounts are too "risky" because not every American has a Harvard MBA. That we must protect the unwashed masses from themselves before they ruin their lives or -- perish the thought -- prove that free markets operate more efficiently than huge government bureaucracies. Please. If Ms. Harrop or the editors of the New York Times want to pass up the option to invest their Social Security taxes in personal accounts, that's fine. Personal accounts would be completely voluntary. If they instead want to bury their savings in the backyard or stuff extra cash in their mattresses, that's their prerogative. But to argue that all American workers should be prohibited from investing a portion of our Social Security taxes in safe, diversified personal accounts because we don't all have Warren Buffett's investment track record is simply arrogant. These supporters of cradle-to-grave government intervention love to piously talk about how much they care about the little guy -- but how much do they really trust the little guy? americansforprosperity.org